Apple TV vs Disney+ for Families: Which Wins?

For most families, Disney+ is the better choice because it offers a larger, more kid-focused library at a lower price, while Apple TV+ has fewer but higher-quality originals that appeal more to adults and older children. The right answer depends on your children’s ages, your budget, and whether you already subscribe to other Apple services. This guide compares both streaming services across content, cost, features, and safety to help you decide.

Background: What Each Service Offers

Apple TV+ launched in November 2019 as Apple’s original-only streaming service. It has no licensed movies or shows from other studiosâ€”everything is an Apple Original, from dramas like Ted Lasso to kids’ shows like Snoopy in Space. Disney+ launched the same month and combines Disney’s vast catalogâ€”including Pixar, Marvel, Star Wars, and National Geographicâ€”with new originals like The Mandalorian. Disney+ also includes most classic Disney animated films, which is a major draw for families with young children.

Content Library: Depth vs. Quality

Disney+ has a much larger library. As of 2024, it offers over 1,000 movies and hundreds of TV series, including nearly every Disney animated classic, all Pixar films, the entire Star Wars saga, and the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Apple TV+ has a smaller catalogâ€”roughly 200 titlesâ€”but focuses on high-budget originals with big-name talent. For families, Disney+ is the clear winner if you want variety and familiar characters. Apple TV+ is better if your kids are older and prefer thought-provoking stories like For All Mankind or Severance (though the latter is not for children).

Cost and Value

Disney+ is cheaper. As of 2024, Disney+ costs $7.99/month with ads or $13.99/month ad-free, while Apple TV+ costs $9.99/month (with a free trial for new subscribers). However, Apple TV+ is included in the Apple One bundle (starting at $19.95/month), which also gives you Apple Music, iCloud storage, and other services. If you already pay for Apple One, Apple TV+ is effectively free. Disney+ also offers bundle deals with Hulu and ESPN+, which can be great value if you want those services. For a family on a budget, Disney+ gives more content per dollar.

Parental Controls and Safety

Both services offer robust parental controls, but they work differently. Disney+ allows you to set a profile PIN and restrict content by rating (e.g., G, PG, PG-13). You can also create a “Kids Profile” that only shows age-appropriate content. Apple TV+ has similar features: you can set content restrictions in the Settings menu, requiring a PIN to change them. However, Apple TV+ does not have a dedicated kids’ profile; you must manually set restrictions on each profile. Disney+ also has a more extensive set of kid-friendly profiles, including a “Junior Mode” for very young children that simplifies the interface.

User Experience and Features

Both services are easy to use, but there are differences. Disney+ has a colorful, visually rich interface that kids find intuitive. It also supports up to four simultaneous streams and allows downloads for offline viewing. Apple TV+ supports up to six streams and also allows downloads. Apple TV+ integrates seamlessly with the Apple TV app and offers 4K HDR and Dolby Vision on most titles. Disney+ also offers 4K on select titles, but not all. One notable difference: Disney+ has a “GroupWatch” feature that lets you watch with friends, while Apple TV+ has “SharePlay” for FaceTime viewing. Both are useful for families in different locations.

Common Problems and Misconceptions

A common misconception is that Apple TV+ is a free service because it comes with new Apple devices. In reality, you get a 3-month trial, after which you must pay. Another issue: Disney+ has been criticized for removing some classic content due to cultural sensitivity, which can disappoint parents expecting every old movie. Also, both services have had technical glitches during major releases, causing buffering or login issues. If you encounter problems, restarting the app or device usually fixes them. For persistent issues, check the service’s status page or contact support.

How to Choose for Your Family

Consider these factors:

Age of children: Under 10? Disney+ is likely better. Teens? Apple TV+ may appeal more.
Budget: Disney+ is cheaper unless you already use Apple One.
Content preferences: Does your family love superheroes, Star Wars, or Disney classics? Then Disney+. If they prefer unique, high-quality originals, Apple TV+.
Device ecosystem: If your family uses iPhones and iPads, Apple TV+ integrates better. If you use various devices, Disney+ works on more platforms.
Trial offers: Both offer free trials (7 days for Disney+, 7 days for Apple TV+). You can try both and see which your family watches more.

Alternatives to Consider

If neither service fully meets your needs, consider other family-friendly options. Netflix has a large kids’ section and many originals, but prices have risen. Amazon Prime Video includes a decent selection of family movies with a Prime membership. For educational content, PBS Kids is free and ad-free. You could also rotate subscriptions: subscribe to Disney+ for a few months, then switch to Apple TV+ when you’ve exhausted the content. This can save money while giving your family variety.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I share my Disney+ or Apple TV+ account with family? Yes, both allow multiple profiles and simultaneous streams. Disney+ allows up to 7 profiles and 4 streams; Apple TV+ allows up to 6 profiles and 6 streams. You can share with family members, but note that sharing outside your household may violate terms of service.

Do these services have ads? Disney+ offers an ad-supported plan at a lower price. Apple TV+ is completely ad-free on all plans. If you hate ads, Apple TV+ is the better choice.

Can I download shows for offline viewing? Yes, both services allow downloads on mobile devices and tablets. Disney+ allows downloads on up to 10 devices per account, while Apple TV+ allows downloads on any device with the app. Downloaded content expires after a certain period (usually 30 days) or after you finish watching it.

Which service has better original content for kids? Disney+ has a larger and more varied kids’ library, including classics like Frozen and Moana, plus new originals like Bluey (in some regions). Apple TV+ has high-quality but fewer kids’ shows, such as Wolfboy and the Everything Factory and Fraggle Rock: Back to the Rock. For most families, Disney+ wins on quantity and familiarity.

Is Apple TV+ worth it if I don’t have Apple devices? Yes, you can watch on any smart TV, streaming stick, or game console via the Apple TV app. You don’t need an Apple device, but you do need to create an Apple ID. The experience is similar to other streaming apps.

Can I cancel anytime? Yes, both services are month-to-month with no contracts. You can cancel online and continue watching until the end of your billing period. If you cancel, you lose access to downloaded content immediately.

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →