keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Are esoteric programming languages useful for learning to code?

Card No. 06·71925 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

Yes, esoteric programming languages (esolangs) are useful for learning to code, but not in the way most beginners expect. They won’t teach you syntax you’ll use on the job, but they force you to think about computation, problem decomposition, and debugging from a completely different angle. This article explains what esolangs are, how they work, and which ones are actually worth your time as a learning tool.

Background: What makes a language “esoteric”?

An esoteric programming language is one designed as an experiment, a joke, or an artistic statement rather than for practical software development. The term was coined in the 1990s by the creators of the Befunge language, which was deliberately made as hard to compile as possible. Since then, hundreds of esolangs have appeared on sites like the Esolang Wiki, ranging from languages that use only two symbols to ones where the program is written in a made-up alien script.

Common traits of esolangs include:

  • Minimal instruction sets – e.g., Brainfuck has only 8 commands.
  • Unusual execution models – e.g., Befunge runs in a 2D grid, not a linear sequence.
  • Deliberate obfuscation – e.g., Malbolge was designed to be nearly impossible to program in.
  • Creative constraints – e.g., Piet programs are images made of colored blocks.

How esolangs actually work (with examples)

To understand their learning value, you need to see how they differ from normal languages. Take Brainfuck – it operates on an array of memory cells and has only 8 commands: > (move right), < (move left), + (increment), - (decrement), . (output), , (input), [ (jump forward if cell is zero), and ] (jump back if cell is not zero). That’s it. A program that prints “Hello” is dozens of lines long.

Befunge is different: the program is a 2D grid, and the instruction pointer moves in any direction (up, down, left, right). The command v makes it go down, < makes it go left, and so on. This forces you to think about control flow as a path, not a sequence.

Piet takes this further – programs are images where each color represents a command, and the transition between colors determines the operation. Writing a Piet program means drawing a picture that is also a program.

What you actually learn from esolangs

Esolangs teach concepts that are transferable to any programming language:

  • Low-level thinking – Brainfuck forces you to understand memory, pointers, and loops at a very basic level.
  • Algorithmic thinking – You learn to break a problem into tiny, mechanical steps because that’s all the language allows.
  • Debugging – When your program doesn’t work, you have to trace every single step. That skill carries over to normal languages.
  • Understanding interpreters and compilers – Writing an interpreter for a small esolang is a classic exercise that teaches how languages are processed.
  • Creativity and problem-solving under constraints – Esolangs are like puzzles; they train you to find unconventional solutions.

How to choose an esolang for learning

Not all esolangs are equally useful. Some are too trivial (like Whitespace, which ignores all non-space characters) and some are too sadistic (like Malbolge, which was designed to be nearly impossible). For a beginner, these are the best choices:

  • Brainfuck – The most famous. It’s simple enough to learn in an hour, but writing a nontrivial program takes real effort. It teaches you about memory and loops.
  • Befunge – Teaches 2D control flow and stack-based programming. You can actually write small games in it.
  • Piet – Great for visual thinkers. You design programs as images, which forces you to think about state transitions.
  • LOLCODE – Not as esoteric, but its silly syntax (e.g., HAI for “hello”) makes it approachable. It still teaches basic programming logic.

Stay away from Malbolge until you’re comfortable with assembly and interpreters – it’s designed to be a nightmare.

Common problems and misconceptions

A common misconception is that esolangs will make you a better programmer in a practical sense. They won’t – you won’t write a web app in Brainfuck. But they will make you a more thoughtful programmer. Another issue is frustration: esolangs are deliberately hard, so beginners can get discouraged. The key is to treat them as puzzles, not as a primary learning tool.

Another problem is that many esolangs lack good documentation or online help. The community is small, and resources are scattered. If you get stuck, you may have to read the interpreter’s source code, which is a great learning experience but not always beginner-friendly.

Comparing esolangs to normal programming languages

If you’re just starting to code, you should learn a normal language first – Python, JavaScript, or similar. Esolangs are not a replacement for that. They are more like a gym for your brain. Here’s a comparison:

  • Syntax – Normal languages have readable syntax; esolangs often have none.
  • Libraries – Normal languages have vast libraries; esolangs have none.
  • Debugging tools – Normal languages have debuggers; esolangs often require manual tracing.
  • Learning curve – Normal languages are designed to be learnable; esolangs are designed to be challenging.

But the core logic – variables, loops, conditionals – is the same. Once you understand that logic in a normal language, esolangs can deepen your understanding.

Costs and time investment

Esolangs are free – most interpreters are open-source and available online. The cost is time. Writing a simple program in Brainfuck can take hours. That’s not a bad thing if you’re using it to learn, but it’s not efficient for building real projects. A better approach is to spend a weekend on one esolang as a mental exercise, then move on.

Alternatives to esolangs for learning

If you want a challenge that’s less extreme, consider these alternatives:

  • Assembly language – Teaches low-level concepts but is still practical.
  • Functional programming – Languages like Haskell or Lisp change how you think about problems.
  • Code golf – Writing the shortest possible solution in a normal language teaches you about language features.
  • Writing your own interpreter – This is a classic project that teaches both programming and language design.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can I get a job knowing only esolangs?
No. Esolangs are not used in industry. You need a practical language like Python, Java, or C++ for employment. Esolangs are for learning and fun.

Q: Which esolang is the easiest to start with?
Brainfuck is the easiest to learn the syntax of, but the hardest to use. For a gentler introduction, try LOLCODE – it has readable keywords and teaches basic logic.

Q: Do esolangs help with algorithmic problem-solving?
Yes, especially Brainfuck and Befunge. They force you to think in tiny steps and to plan your memory usage carefully, which is helpful for competitive programming or low-level work.

Q: Are there any real-world uses for esolangs?
Almost none. They are used in esoteric programming contests, as art, and as a way to test compiler design. Some have been used in code obfuscation contests, but that’s it.

Q: How long does it take to learn Brainfuck?
You can learn the commands in 10 minutes. Writing a nontrivial program, like a “Hello World” that takes input, might take a few hours for a beginner. It’s not about speed; it’s about understanding.

In summary, esoteric programming languages are a unique and valuable learning tool if you approach them with the right mindset. They won’t teach you how to build apps, but they will teach you how to think like a computer – and that’s a skill every programmer needs.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →