keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

ASUS RT-AX1800S vs Xiaomi AX1800: Key Checks

Card No. 06·82500 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

Both the ASUS RT-AX1800S and Xiaomi AX1800 are dual-band Wi-Fi 6 routers aimed at budget-conscious users, but they differ in hardware, software, and long-term support. The ASUS offers better firmware features and security updates, while the Xiaomi provides slightly higher raw throughput and a lower price. Before choosing, check your need for advanced controls, mesh expansion, and regional warranty support.

Background: What Each Router Offers

The ASUS RT-AX1800S is a rebranded version of the RT-AX55, sharing the same Broadcom chipset but with a simplified design. It supports Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax) on both bands, with combined speeds up to 1800 Mbps (574 Mbps on 2.4 GHz, 1201 Mbps on 5 GHz). It includes four Gigabit LAN ports, one Gigabit WAN port, and USB 2.0 for storage or printer sharing. The Xiaomi AX1800 (also known as the Redmi AX1800 in some markets) uses a Qualcomm IPQ6000 quad-core processor and offers the same dual-band Wi-Fi 6 speeds, but only three Gigabit LAN ports and no USB port. Both routers support OFDMA, MU-MIMO, and WPA3 encryption, but they differ in software maturity and ecosystem integration.

Hardware Comparison: Chipset, Ports, and Design

  • Chipset: ASUS uses a Broadcom BCM6755; Xiaomi uses a Qualcomm IPQ6000. Both are quad-core, but the Qualcomm chip generally has stronger CPU performance for routing tasks.
  • Ports: ASUS has 4 LAN + 1 WAN; Xiaomi has 3 LAN + 1 WAN. If you need to wire several devices, the ASUS gives you one more port.
  • USB: ASUS includes a USB 2.0 port; Xiaomi has none. The USB port allows file sharing or a printer server, but USB 2.0 is slow (around 30 MB/s).
  • Antennas: Both have four external antennas, but the Xiaomi’s are fixed, while the ASUS’s are also fixed. Neither allows replacement or repositioning.
  • Physical size: The Xiaomi is slightly smaller and has a more angular design; the ASUS is taller and more traditional.

In real-world throughput, the Xiaomi AX1800 often edges out the ASUS on 5 GHz range due to its higher gain antennas, but the difference is usually less than 10% in most homes.

Software and Firmware: The Biggest Difference

ASUS’s firmware (AsusWRT) is the main reason many choose the RT-AX1800S. It includes:

  • Parental controls with per-device time limits and content filtering.
  • VPN client and server support (OpenVPN, WireGuard, PPTP).
  • Guest networks with separate SSIDs and access schedules.
  • Traffic analysis per device, including real-time bandwidth usage.
  • Regular security patches and bug fixes, often for several years after release.
  • Support for AiMesh, allowing you to combine multiple ASUS routers into a mesh system.

Xiaomi’s firmware is more basic and consumer-focused. It has a clean app (Mi WiFi) that simplifies setup and offers basic parental controls, but it lacks advanced features like VPN, guest network scheduling, or per-device traffic graphs. Xiaomi also has a mesh feature, but it only works with other Xiaomi routers that support the same protocol, and the implementation is less mature than AiMesh. Security updates for Xiaomi routers are less frequent and often region-dependent.

Performance and Range: What to Expect

Both routers perform similarly in typical homes. On 2.4 GHz, they reach about 200-300 Mbps at close range, dropping to 50-100 Mbps at 10 meters through walls. On 5 GHz, they can deliver 600-900 Mbps at close range, but that quickly drops to 200-300 Mbps at 8-10 meters. The Xiaomi tends to have slightly better range on 5 GHz due to its antenna design, but the ASUS has more stable firmware that handles many connected devices (30+) without dropping. If you have a large home (over 150 m²), neither router will cover it fully; you would need a mesh system or an additional access point.

How to Choose: Key Questions to Ask Yourself

  1. Do you need advanced features? If you want VPN, guest network scheduling, or granular parental controls, choose the ASUS.
  2. Do you need USB sharing? Only the ASUS has a USB port, so if you want to share a hard drive or printer, the ASUS is the only option here.
  3. Do you plan to expand to a mesh later? ASUS’s AiMesh works with many older ASUS routers, giving you flexibility. Xiaomi’s mesh is limited to a few models and is less documented.
  4. Is price your top priority? The Xiaomi AX1800 is typically 20-30% cheaper than the ASUS. If you only need basic Wi-Fi 6 and don’t care about advanced settings, the Xiaomi saves money.
  5. Do you need more LAN ports? The ASUS has four, the Xiaomi has three. If you have four wired devices, the ASUS is necessary unless you add a switch.
  6. Do you want long-term security updates? ASUS has a better track record of firmware updates, especially for security vulnerabilities. Xiaomi’s updates are less predictable.

Common Problems and How to Avoid Them

Both routers have known quirks:

  • ASUS RT-AX1800S: Some users report that the 2.4 GHz band drops when using certain IoT devices. Fix: disable “AirTime Fairness” and set the channel width to 20 MHz for better compatibility.
  • Xiaomi AX1800: The Mi WiFi app sometimes fails to detect the router after a firmware update. Fix: reset the router and re-add it, or use the web interface (192.168.31.1).
  • Both: Wi-Fi 6 features like OFDMA can cause issues with older devices. If you experience slowdowns, disable OFDMA in the settings (if available) or update the router firmware.

Also, note that both routers have a limited number of simultaneous connections (around 128 devices), but in practice, they handle 30-40 devices well. If you have more, consider a more powerful router.

Cost and Value

Prices vary by region and time, but generally the Xiaomi AX1800 is the budget pick, often priced 30-40% lower than the ASUS. The ASUS commands a premium because of its firmware and brand reputation. For most users, the Xiaomi offers better value if they only need basic Wi-Fi 6. However, if you value advanced features, the ASUS’s extra cost is justified, especially if you plan to use VPN or mesh. Keep in mind that neither router supports Wi-Fi 6E (6 GHz band), so if you have devices that use 6 GHz, you need a different router.

Alternatives to Consider

If neither router meets your needs, consider:

  • TP-Link Archer AX55: Similar to the ASUS but with a simpler interface and slightly lower price.
  • Asus RT-AX55: The original version of the RT-AX1800S, with the same firmware but a different design.
  • Xiaomi Redmi AX3000: A newer model with Wi-Fi 6 and 160 MHz channel support, offering faster speeds for a similar price.
  • Used enterprise gear: If you have technical skills, used Ruckus or Aruba access points can offer better performance, but they require a controller or standalone setup.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use the ASUS RT-AX1800S with Xiaomi AX1800 in a mesh?

No. They use different mesh protocols (AiMesh vs Xiaomi’s own). You cannot mix them. If you want mesh, stick to one brand.

Which router has better parental controls?

ASUS has more robust parental controls, including per-device time limits, content filters, and even scheduling by day. Xiaomi’s parental controls are basic (e.g., pause internet, block specific sites) and are managed through the app.

Does either router support VPN?

Only the ASUS supports VPN client and server natively. Xiaomi AX1800 does not have VPN support in its firmware, though you could flash OpenWrt (if supported) to add it, but that voids warranty and is risky.

Which router is better for gaming?

Both are fine for casual gaming, but the ASUS has a gaming mode that prioritizes traffic to a specific device. The Xiaomi lacks this feature. However, the Xiaomi’s faster CPU may handle heavy loads better, but in practice, the difference is minimal.

Can I connect a USB drive to the Xiaomi AX1800?

No. The Xiaomi AX1800 does not have a USB port. If you need USB storage sharing, choose the ASUS RT-AX1800S.

Which router has better range?

In most tests, the Xiaomi AX1800 has slightly better 5 GHz range due to its antenna design, but the ASUS is more consistent. In a typical apartment or small house, both will cover the area adequately. For larger homes, neither is sufficient.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →