The top pick for most hiring teams is a structured, asynchronous video interview platform like HireVue or Spark Hire, because it lets you evaluate candidates on your own schedule while still seeing and hearing their responses. These tools give you the consistency of automated screening without the impersonal feel of a fully bot-driven chat, and they work for high-volume and specialized roles alike.
What to Look For
When you’re weighing alternatives to fully automated interviews, focus on these criteria:
- Human touch: Does the process include a live person at any stage? The best options keep a human in the loop for final decisions or even during the interview itself.
- Candidate experience: Look for tools that let candidates practice, re-record, or interact with a real person. A bad experience can cost you top talent.
- Flexibility: Can you mix live and pre-recorded questions? Can you customize the flow for different roles?
- Assessment quality: Does the tool measure job-relevant skills (e.g., coding, sales scenarios) rather than just personality or facial expressions?
- Ease of use: Both for your team and for candidates. If it takes hours to set up, it’s not practical.
- Cost and scalability: Some tools charge per candidate, others per seat. Make sure the pricing matches your hiring volume.
Option 1: Asynchronous Video Interviews (HireVue, Spark Hire, myInterview)
Strengths: Candidates record answers to pre-set questions on their own time. You get a consistent format for all applicants, which reduces bias, and you can review responses at 1.5x speed. Many platforms now offer “human review” add-ons where a real recruiter watches and scores responses.
Trade-offs: Candidates can feel they’re talking to a robot, and there’s no follow-up or spontaneity. Some tools include AI scoring, which can be a black box and may raise fairness concerns.
Best for: High-volume screening (e.g., retail, customer service) where you need to shortlist quickly without sacrificing a human final round.
Option 2: Live Video Interviews with Scheduling Tools (Zoom, Google Meet + Calendly)
Strengths: This is the most human alternative. You get real-time conversation, body language, and the ability to adapt questions on the fly. Scheduling tools like Calendly or Cal.com remove the back-and-forth email ping-pong.
Trade-offs: It’s time-consuming for your team, especially if you have many applicants. There’s also less consistency across candidates, which can introduce bias.
Best for: Small teams, senior roles, or any position where cultural fit and communication skills are critical.
Option 3: Skills-Based Assessments (Codility, HackerRank, Vervoe)
Strengths: These platforms go beyond the resume and test actual job skills—coding, data analysis, writing, or sales scenarios. Many allow for “work samples” that mimic real tasks, and results are objective and comparable.
Trade-offs: They can be impersonal and stressful if the tasks are too long or irrelevant. Candidates may also feel they’re being watched by a machine, and there’s little room for questions or clarification.
Best for: Technical roles, or any position where a portfolio or test is a better predictor than a conversation.
Option 4: Phone Screens (Human, But Structured)
Strengths: A 15-minute phone call with a recruiter using a standardized question script gives you a human voice, a chance to probe answers, and a quick way to filter. It’s low-tech and works for any role.
Trade-offs: It’s still time-consuming, and you can’t see body language. Scheduling can be a pain, though tools like Calendly help.
Best for: Early-stage screening when you have a manageable number of applicants and want a personal touch without full interviews.
Option 5: Panel Interviews (In-Person or Virtual)
Strengths: Multiple interviewers see the candidate at once, which reduces individual bias and gives a more rounded view. It’s the most collaborative and human approach.
Trade-offs: It’s expensive in time and coordination. It also can be intimidating for candidates, and it’s not scalable for high-volume hiring.
Best for: Final rounds for key roles, or when you want to test how a candidate handles pressure and multiple stakeholders.
Option 6: Take-Home Assignments (with Human Review)
Strengths: Candidates complete a realistic task (e.g., a marketing plan, a code challenge, a design mockup) in their own time. You then review the work and discuss it in a live follow-up call. This combines authenticity with human judgment.
Trade-offs: It can be a big time investment for candidates, and some may drop out. You also need to design and grade the assignment consistently.
Best for: Roles where the quality of work product is the top predictor—designers, writers, engineers, analysts.
How to Choose
Start by defining your budget and hiring volume. If you’re hiring dozens of entry-level staff, an asynchronous video platform (Option 1) is likely the sweet spot—it’s faster than phone screens and cheaper than live interviews at scale. If you’re hiring one senior manager, a live video interview (Option 2) or panel (Option 5) is worth the time.
Consider your candidate pool. Tech-savvy candidates may prefer a skills test (Option 3) over a video. Less tech-comfortable candidates might do better with a phone screen. Always ask yourself: “What is the single most important predictor for success in this role?” If it’s communication, go live. If it’s technical ability, use a skills test. If it’s both, combine a skills test with a short live interview.
A common trade-off is speed vs. depth. Automated tools are fast but shallow. Live interviews are deep but slow. A hybrid approach—asynchronous screening followed by a live final round—often gives you the best of both worlds without too much extra cost.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Are asynchronous video interviews really better than fully automated chat interviews?
Yes, for most roles. Video lets you see and hear the candidate, which gives you more signal than text-based chat. It also feels more human to the candidate, which improves your employer brand.
2. Can I use these tools for technical roles?
Absolutely. Platforms like Codility and HackerRank are built for technical assessments. You can also use a take-home assignment (Option 6) followed by a live technical discussion.
3. How do I avoid bias in a human-led process?
Use a structured interview guide—the same questions in the same order for every candidate. Score each answer on a pre-defined scale. This is the single best way to reduce bias, whether you’re live or recorded.
4. What if candidates refuse to do a video interview?
Some may, especially if they’re uncomfortable on camera. Offer an alternative (like a phone screen) for those candidates, but be clear that the process is the same for everyone. If a large portion of your pool refuses, reconsider the tool.
5. How long should a take-home assignment take?
Keep it under 2-3 hours. Longer assignments cause drop-off and may disadvantage candidates with less free time. Always pay for assignments over 4 hours, or consider a paid trial project instead.
6. Can I mix automated and human steps?
Yes, and it’s often the best approach. For example, use an asynchronous video screening for all applicants, then invite the top 20% for a live panel interview. This balances efficiency with human judgment.
Bottom Line
The best alternative to fully automated interviews is a structured, asynchronous video platform like HireVue or Spark Hire—it gives you speed and consistency while keeping a human in the loop for final decisions. Pair it with a live interview for your shortlist, and you’ll have a process that’s efficient, fair, and respectful of candidates. For smaller teams or senior roles, skip the automation entirely and go with live video or panel interviews. The key is to match the tool to the role and always include a human touch at the point where it matters most.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Arctic Sea Ice Forecasts Disagree: What to Do
- MySQL Workbench to VPS: SSH Tunnel Setup
- Bluesky Beginners Guide: How to Get Started5.00 min/km
- LG V20 Won’t Turn On? Fixed
- Snagit vs Camtasia: Which One Do You Need?
- Scale a Small Business Without Losing Culture