If you’ve just finished Doom: The Dark Ages and crave more fast, movement-heavy, skill-based arena combat, the top pick is Ultrakill. It matches Doom’s loop of aggressive resource management and stylish combos, but pushes movement tech and score-chasing to a level that feels like a natural evolution of what you just played. No other game nails that same blend of speed, precision, and pure mechanical depth.
What to Look For
Not all shooters called “arena” are the same. After Doom: The Dark Ages, you want games that respect your skill and keep you moving. The criteria that actually matter:
- Movement mechanics: bunny hopping, sliding, dashing, or wall-jumping. Static strafing will feel like a downgrade.
- Resource loop: health and ammo from aggressive play (glory kills, health packs, or a similar risk-reward system) rather than passive regen.
- Enemy design: enemies that demand specific weapons and tactics, not just bullet sponges.
- Skill ceiling: a high skill ceiling with room for mastery, combo systems, or speedrunning potential.
- Single-player focus: a strong campaign or wave-based mode, not just competitive multiplayer (unless you want that).
Ultrakill
Strengths: The closest spiritual successor to Doom’s loop. You heal by dealing damage, and style points reward varied weapon use. Movement is a deep rabbit hole: slide-jumping, wall-jumping, and coin tricks create a combat sandbox that makes you feel like a god. The level design encourages replay for P-ranks.
Trade-offs: It’s visually minimalist (low-poly, PS1-inspired aesthetic), which can be a shock after Doom’s cinematic grandeur. The difficulty spikes hard on certain bosses, and there’s no multiplayer.
Who it suits: Players who care most about pure mechanics and love the idea of endlessly improving their run. If you chased every secret in Doom, this is your next obsession.
Titanfall 2
Strengths: The campaign is a masterclass in movement and level design, with wall-running, double jumps, and a time-travel level that’s still talked about. The multiplayer is the best modern arena shooter, mixing pilot speed with giant mech combat. The movement feels fluid and forgiving, even for newcomers.
Trade-offs: It’s a 2016 game, and the player base is small but dedicated. The campaign is short (6-8 hours), and the multiplayer’s skill gap can be brutal when you face veterans.
Who it suits: Players who want a polished, AAA-feeling shooter with a great story and a multiplayer that rewards mobility. A perfect bridge if you’re not ready for the indie scene.
Quake Champions
Strengths: The purest arena shooter DNA: rocket jumping, strafe jumping, and lightning gun duels. Champions add unique abilities that add variety without breaking the core. The gunplay is precise, and the 1v1 and 2v2 modes are the ultimate test of skill. It’s free-to-play, so you can try it risk-free.
Trade-offs: The player population is smaller than it once was, and matchmaking can be uneven. The learning curve for movement is steep, and the ability system can feel gimmicky to purists.
Who it suits: Competitive players who want to test their aim and movement against real humans. If you loved Doom’s multiplayer or want to understand the genre’s roots, start here.
Turbo Overkill
Strengths: A cyberpunk boomer shooter that takes Doom’s formula and adds a chainsaw leg for sliding. The level design is open and vertical, encouraging constant movement. The weapon mods and enemy variety are excellent, and the game is packed with secrets and hidden areas. It has a strong identity and doesn’t take itself too seriously.
Trade-offs: It’s less polished than Doom in terms of animation and story. The difficulty can be inconsistent, and some levels feel longer than they should. No multiplayer.
Who it suits: Players who want a single-player experience that feels like a love letter to Doom and Quake, with a unique twist. If you want a wild ride with a killer soundtrack, this is it.
Halo: The Master Chief Collection
Strengths: Specifically Halo 3 and Reach offer arena combat that’s more about map control and weapon timing than raw speed. The multiplayer is legendary for its balance and teamwork. The collection gives you six games for the price of one, with remastered graphics and a huge player base.
Trade-offs: The movement is slower and more deliberate than Doom. There’s no modern sprint or slide, and the TTK (time-to-kill) is longer, which feels very different. The campaigns are great but not as intense as Doom.
Who it suits: Players who want a change of pace but still crave skill-based arena combat. If you enjoy teamwork and map strategy more than solo rampages, this is a solid choice.
Doom (2016) and Doom Eternal
Strengths: The obvious answer. If you haven’t played the previous entries in the series, they are the closest to The Dark Ages. Doom Eternal has the most refined movement and resource loop of the trilogy, with a deeper combat puzzle. Doom 2016 is more grounded but still excellent. Both are available on all platforms and run well.
Trade-offs: If you just played The Dark Ages, you might want something different. Eternal is faster and more demanding, while 2016 feels simpler in comparison. You’ll be retreading similar ground.
Who it suits: Anyone who skipped them or wants to see the evolution of the series. It’s the safest bet if you just want more Doom, but it’s not a new experience.
How to Choose
Start with your budget. Quake Champions is free, so try it first. If you want a polished single-player campaign, Ultrakill and Turbo Overkill are both affordable indie titles that offer 15-20 hours of content. Titanfall 2 and Halo MCC are often on sale and give you a lot for your money, especially if you want multiplayer.
Consider your preferred play style. If you want pure speed and mechanical depth, choose Ultrakill. If you want a more accessible but still deep movement shooter, Titanfall 2. If you want competitive duels, Quake Champions. If you want a team-based arena experience, Halo.
A common trade-off is single-player vs. multiplayer. Ultrakill and Turbo Overkill are strictly single-player. Titanfall 2 and Halo offer both. Quake Champions is multiplayer only. If you’re burned out on multiplayer, go single-player. If you want to test your skills against others, go multiplayer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Are these games on console?
A: Doom (2016) and Eternal, Titanfall 2, and Halo MCC are on all consoles. Ultrakill and Turbo Overkill are on PC only (Ultrakill is coming to consoles eventually). Quake Champions is PC only.
Q: Which has the best single-player campaign?
A: Titanfall 2 has the most critically acclaimed campaign, but Ultrakill offers more replayability due to its scoring system.
Q: I’m not great at fast movement. Which is easiest to get into?
A: Halo has the slowest movement and is the most forgiving. Titanfall 2 is also approachable due to its smooth controls.
Q: Which game has the most active multiplayer?
A: Halo MCC has the largest player base, followed by Titanfall 2. Quake Champions is smaller but dedicated.
Q: Do any of these have a demo or free trial?
A: Quake Champions is free-to-play. Titanfall 2 and Halo MCC occasionally have free multiplayer weekends. Ultrakill and Turbo Overkill have demos on Steam.
Q: Which is most like Doom Eternal specifically?
A: Ultrakill is the closest in terms of fast-paced resource management and style. Turbo Overkill is also similar but with a different movement feel.
Bottom Line
For the best overall experience that respects your Doom skills, Ultrakill is the clear winner. It offers the deepest mechanical challenge and is endlessly replayable. If you want something more mainstream, Titanfall 2 is a fantastic choice with a great campaign and multiplayer. And if you want to go back to the roots, Quake Champions is free and will sharpen your aim. Any of these will scratch the arena shooter itch.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Skip Ryobi and Milwaukee? Harbor Freight Tools to Buy
- Funny Subreddits That Make You Laugh
- Why Retro Gaming Is Still Worth Playing Today
- Neptune Facts That Will Blow Your Mind
- Survival Crafting Game Fatigue: Why & How to Fix It
- Sell Your EV Now Before Prices Plummet?