keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Best Batman Games for Animated Series Fans

Card No. 06·81072 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

If you love Batman: The Animated Series, the top pick is Batman: Arkham Asylum. It captures the gothic atmosphere, the voice of Kevin Conroy as Batman, and Mark Hamill’s Joker, while delivering tight stealth and combat that makes you feel like the Dark Knight. The game’s story and tone are the closest any game has come to the show’s blend of noir and superhero action.

What to Look For

When choosing a Batman game that captures the spirit of the animated series, focus on these criteria:

  • Voice Cast: Kevin Conroy (Batman) and Mark Hamill (Joker) are the definitive voices from the show. Games featuring them instantly feel more authentic.
  • Art Direction: The show’s dark deco style, with its moody shadows and exaggerated architecture, is a key part of its identity. Look for games that lean into that gothic, film-noir aesthetic rather than a hyper-realistic or neon-soaked look.
  • Story Tone: The animated series balanced serious detective work with comic-book melodrama. Games that focus on mystery, character-driven plots, and a brooding atmosphere will resonate more than those with a purely action-heavy narrative.
  • Gameplay Feel: The show’s Batman is a master detective and a stealthy predator. Look for games that emphasize stealth, gadget use, and hand-to-hand combat that feels methodical rather than just button-mashing.
  • Rogues Gallery: The animated series gave us definitive versions of many villains. Games that feature those classic interpretations—like a cunning Riddler or a tragic Mr. Freeze—will feel more connected to the show.

Batman: Arkham Asylum

Strengths: The most direct spiritual successor to the animated series. It features Kevin Conroy and Mark Hamill in their iconic roles, a story that focuses on a single night in Arkham Asylum, and a heavy atmosphere that mirrors the show’s gothic horror. The combat is simple but satisfying, and the stealth sections make you feel like the predator Batman is meant to be.

Trade-offs: The game is from 2009, so the graphics and some mechanics feel dated. The world is smaller and more linear than later entries, and the Riddler trophies can feel like busywork.

Who it suits: Anyone who wants the purest animated series experience in a game. It’s perfect for those who prioritize story, atmosphere, and voice acting over open-world freedom.

Batman: Arkham City

Strengths: Expands on everything from Asylum with a larger open-world (a section of Gotham), more gadgets, and a deeper story that brings in many classic villains. Kevin Conroy and Mark Hamill return, and the game adds a more complex narrative involving Hugo Strange and the fate of Arkham City. The combat and predator mechanics are refined to near-perfection.

Trade-offs: The open world can feel less focused than Asylum’s tight design. The story, while good, is more convoluted and less intimate. Some of the side missions feel like filler.

Who it suits: Players who want more gameplay variety and a bigger playground while still craving that animated series tone. It’s the best balance of the Arkham trilogy for most fans.

Batman: The Telltale Series

Strengths: This is a narrative-driven adventure that focuses on Bruce Wayne as much as Batman. It captures the detective and moral dilemma aspects of the animated series, with a strong emphasis on choice and consequence. The art style, while cel-shaded, has a comic-book feel that echoes the show’s aesthetic.

Trade-offs: There is very little action or stealth gameplay—it’s mostly dialogue and quick-time events. The story takes liberties with Batman lore (especially regarding his parents) that may not sit well with purists. The voice cast is different from the animated series.

Who it suits: Fans who enjoy interactive stories and character drama more than action. If you loved the show’s quieter, character-driven episodes, this is a great fit.

Batman: The Enemy Within

Strengths: The sequel to Telltale’s first season, this one leans even harder into the Bruce Wayne/Joker relationship, offering a unique take on the Joker’s origin. It has some of the best writing in any Batman game, with choices that genuinely affect the outcome. The art style remains consistent with the first season and feels like a modern take on the animated series’ look.

Trade-offs: Same as the first season: limited gameplay beyond choices and QTEs. The story is even more divergent from the animated series, so don’t expect a faithful adaptation. The pacing can be slow for action-oriented players.

Who it suits: Players who want a deep, emotional story with tough moral choices. It’s perfect for those who appreciated the psychological depth of the animated series’ best episodes.

Batman: Arkham Knight

Strengths: The most visually stunning and mechanically polished Arkham game. It features a massive open-world Gotham, the Batmobile (which can be fun or frustrating), and a story that brings the Arkham saga to a close. Kevin Conroy returns as Batman, and the game includes many references to the animated series.

Trade-offs: The Batmobile is heavily featured and some players find it overused. The story is more action-heavy and less focused on detective work. The identity of the Arkham Knight may be a letdown for some. The tone is darker and more violent than the animated series.

Who it suits: Those who want a modern, epic Batman experience with the best graphics and combat. It’s less about the animated series feel and more about a blockbuster conclusion to the Arkham series.

Lego Batman: The Videogame (or Lego Batman 2)

Strengths: The Lego games are charming, humorous, and surprisingly faithful to the source material. The first Lego Batman features a wide roster of villains and a lighthearted take that still respects the characters. Lego Batman 2 adds an open-world Gotham and voice acting (though not the original cast). They are great for co-op play.

Trade-offs: The gameplay is simple and geared toward a younger audience. The tone is comedic, not noir. There is no real stealth or detective work.

Who it suits: Families, younger players, or anyone who wants a fun, stress-free Batman game that still celebrates the classic rogues gallery. It’s a great palate cleanser after the dark Arkham games.

How to Choose

Your budget and preferred play style are the biggest factors. If you want the closest animated series experience, start with Arkham Asylum—it’s often available for very little and is a short, focused game. If you want more gameplay hours and an open world, Arkham City is the best value. If you prefer story over action, the Telltale games are excellent, especially if you can get both seasons in a bundle. If you already have a modern console and want the best graphics, Arkham Knight is the showpiece, but be prepared for the Batmobile. If you’re playing with kids or want a light-hearted experience, the Lego games are the way to go.

Common trade-offs: Older games have dated graphics but often have better voice acting and atmosphere. Newer games have better mechanics but may stray from the animated series tone. Action-heavy games may sacrifice story depth, while story-driven games may lack gameplay variety. Decide what matters most to you: atmosphere, narrative, or gameplay.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are the Arkham games all in the same universe as the animated series?

No, they are a separate continuity, but they borrow heavily from the animated series—especially the voice cast and the general tone. Think of them as a spiritual successor rather than a direct continuation.

Do I need to play the Arkham games in order?

It’s recommended, as the story builds on itself. But each game can be enjoyed standalone. If you only play one, Arkham City is a good middle ground, but Asylum is the best starting point.

Which game has the best Joker?

Mark Hamill’s Joker in Arkham Asylum and Arkham City is widely considered the definitive game version. The Telltale games offer a different, more nuanced take on the Joker that is also excellent.

Is the Batmobile in Arkham Knight mandatory?

Yes, it is required for many story missions and puzzles. If you dislike vehicle sections, this may be a downside. You can avoid some optional Batmobile content, but not the main story.

Are the Telltale games canon?

No, they are an alternate universe. They are not connected to the Arkham games or the animated series. They offer a fresh take on the Batman mythos.

Which game is best for a younger child?

The Lego Batman games are the most kid-friendly. They have no blood, no scary moments, and the humor is appropriate for all ages. The Arkham games are rated T or M and are not suitable for young children.

Bottom Line

For the definitive animated series experience, buy Batman: Arkham Asylum first. It’s the perfect blend of the show’s atmosphere, voice acting, and gameplay. If you want more of that but with a bigger world, move to Arkham City. For a story-first approach, the Telltale series is a fantastic choice. And if you just want to have fun with Batman without the darkness, the Lego games are a great pick. Whichever you choose, you’ll be in good company with the Caped Crusader.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →