keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Best Colony Management Games with Diplomacy Like Going Medieval

Card No. 06·80753 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

If you loved Going Medieval but want deeper political systems, the top pick is RimWorld with its Royalty and Ideology expansions. It combines the same base-building, survival, and raider-defense loop with faction relationships, trade negotiations, and even noble court politics. No other game matches its moddable diplomacy depth while keeping the colony sim feel you already enjoy.

What to Look For

When evaluating colony management games for diplomacy, focus on these concrete features rather than marketing buzzwords:

  • Faction Interaction Systems – Can you send emissaries, trade, form alliances, or declare war? Static reputation bars alone aren’t enough.
  • Meaningful Choices – Does diplomacy affect gameplay (e.g., trade prices, military aid, refugee waves) or is it just flavor text?
  • Colonist Personality – Do individual pawns have traits, opinions, and social relationships that influence negotiations or internal politics?
  • Reactive World – Do factions remember your actions and change behavior accordingly? A static world map with fixed enemies gets stale.
  • Modding Support – The best diplomacy often comes from community mods. Check if the game has a Steam Workshop or active mod scene.
  • Pause & Plan – Like Going Medieval, you want the ability to pause and think through diplomatic moves without real-time pressure.

RimWorld

Strengths: The gold standard for colony sims with emergent storytelling. Factions have distinct ideologies, and you can negotiate via comms console, trade caravans, or even capture and release prisoners to improve relations. The Royalty expansion adds a noble hierarchy with titles, permits, and imperial quests. Ideology lets you customize your own belief system, affecting how other factions perceive you. Mods like Vanilla Expanded and Hospitality add even deeper diplomatic options.

Trade-offs: Base game diplomacy is relatively simple – mostly goodwill points and trade requests. The UI can be overwhelming for new players. The graphics are 2D and less detailed than Going Medieval‘s 3D voxel world.

Who it suits: Players who want maximum replayability and don’t mind a steeper learning curve. If you enjoy crafting your own stories and tweaking systems via mods, this is your game.

Dwarf Fortress (Steam Edition)

Strengths: The deepest simulation of any game on this list. Civilizations have histories, grudges, and treaties that evolve over in-game centuries. You can send diplomats, negotiate peace treaties, and even engineer political marriages between dwarven houses. The Steam version (2022) adds a proper UI and graphics, making it more accessible than the classic ASCII version.

Trade-offs: The learning curve is brutal – even with the new UI, managing dwarves, moods, and the military is complex. Diplomacy is not a separate screen; it’s woven into the simulation, so you’ll need to read logs and understand dwarf psychology. Performance can lag with large populations.

Who it suits: Players who want the ultimate sandbox and don’t mind spending time learning systems. If you loved the survival aspect of Going Medieval but wanted more depth, this is the next step.

Kenshi

Strengths: A squad-based survival RPG with base building and faction politics. You can align with major factions (Holy Nation, United Cities, Shek Kingdom) or carve your own path. Diplomacy is practical: you can pay tribute, bribe, or wage war. Factions have patrols, trade routes, and territorial claims that react to your actions. The world is hostile but also offers opportunities for trade and alliances.

Trade-offs: No pause-and-plan – it’s real-time, and combat can be brutal. The base building is less polished than Going Medieval, and there’s no story mode – you create your own goals. Diplomacy is mostly about reputation and not getting attacked, not nuanced negotiation.

Who it suits: Players who enjoy open-world exploration and survival challenges. If you want diplomacy to be a survival tool rather than a political sim, this is a good fit.

Stellaris (with Utopia and Federations DLCs)

Strengths: While it’s a grand strategy game, it has deep colony management (planets, pops, buildings) and the best diplomacy system in the genre. You can form federations, trade resources, negotiate research agreements, and even engage in espionage. The Federations DLC adds diplomatic weight, galactic community votes, and crisis management. The Utopia DLC adds megastructures and hive minds, giving you more options for internal and external politics.

Trade-offs: It’s not a base-building sim – you don’t manage individual colonists. The learning curve is steep, and the mid-game can feel like a waiting game. Diplomacy is abstract – you’re negotiating as a government, not with individual characters.

Who it suits: Players who want a grander scale and enjoy managing factions, trade, and alliances across a galaxy. If you liked the resource management of Going Medieval but want more strategic depth, this is a strong choice.

RimWorld – With the Hospitality Mod

Strengths: The Hospitality mod transforms RimWorld into a diplomacy-focused experience. You can build hotels, host visitors, and run diplomatic events. Guests have needs and opinions, and their factions will react to how you treat them. Combined with the base game’s faction system, this creates a robust diplomatic loop: you can negotiate trade deals, form alliances, or even host peace conferences.

Trade-offs: Requires mod management – you need to ensure compatibility with other mods. The mod doesn’t add a full UI for diplomacy; it’s more about the emergent interactions. Some players find the guest AI finicky.

Who it suits: Players who already own RimWorld and want to enhance diplomacy without buying a new game. If you’re on a budget, this is the most cost-effective way to get more political gameplay.

Gnomoria (or its successor, Odd Realm)

Strengths: Gnomoria is a dwarf-fortress-lite with a friendly interface. It has trade caravans, diplomacy with other kingdoms, and a simple but effective reputation system. Odd Realm (early access) builds on this with more factions, procedural events, and a focus on community management. Both are lighter on the CPU and easier to learn than Dwarf Fortress.

Trade-offs: Diplomacy is fairly basic – you can trade and improve relations, but there’s no complex negotiation. The games are less deep overall, and Odd Realm is still in development, so content may change.

Who it suits: Players who want a more casual, accessible colony sim with a hint of diplomacy. If you’re new to the genre, these are good starting points.

How to Choose

Budget: RimWorld is the most expensive (especially with DLCs), but it’s often on sale. Dwarf Fortress is cheaper and has no DLC. Kenshi is mid-priced. Stellaris goes on deep discounts frequently. If you’re on a tight budget, start with Gnomoria or wait for a sale on Dwarf Fortress.

Use case: If you want deep character-driven diplomacy, choose RimWorld. If you want a complex world simulation, choose Dwarf Fortress. If you want a more action-oriented survival with diplomacy as a side mechanic, Kenshi is great. If you want to manage a civilization rather than a colony, Stellaris is the way.

Common trade-offs: Depth vs. Accessibility – RimWorld and Dwarf Fortress are deep but hard to learn. Kenshi is accessible but less deep. Stellaris is strategic but not a base-builder. Also consider graphics – if you prefer 3D like Going Medieval, you’ll have to accept that most of these are 2D or top-down.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is there a game exactly like Going Medieval but with more diplomacy?

No single game replicates its exact 3D building style with deeper diplomacy. RimWorld is the closest in spirit. For 3D, you might look at Medieval Dynasty (more survival than colony) or Foundation (no diplomacy). You may need to mod or accept a different perspective.

Do I need DLCs for RimWorld to get good diplomacy?

The base game has basic diplomacy. The Royalty expansion adds a noble system, and Ideology adds cultural relations. For the best experience, get at least Royalty. The Hospitality mod is free and adds a lot.

Is Dwarf Fortress too hard for a casual player?

The Steam version has a better tutorial and UI, but it’s still complex. If you’re willing to watch a few YouTube tutorials, it’s manageable. Start with a small fortress and don’t be afraid to lose.

Can I play these games on a low-end PC?

RimWorld and Gnomoria run on almost anything. Dwarf Fortress can be CPU-heavy with large worlds. Kenshi is poorly optimized and may lag. Stellaris is heavy on late-game performance. Check the system requirements before buying.

Do these games have multiplayer?

RimWorld has a multiplayer mod, but it’s not official. Dwarf Fortress has no official multiplayer. Kenshi is single-player only. Stellaris has multiplayer, but it’s not a co-op colony sim.

Which game has the best modding community for diplomacy?

RimWorld has the largest and most active modding community. You’ll find dozens of diplomacy-related mods. Dwarf Fortress also has a strong modding scene, but it’s more about world-gen than diplomacy.

Bottom Line

If you want the most complete package of colony management and diplomacy, RimWorld is the clear winner. It’s the spiritual successor to Going Medieval in terms of gameplay loop, and the modding scene lets you tailor the diplomacy to your liking. If you want something more challenging and don’t mind a steep learning curve, Dwarf Fortress offers unmatched depth. For a different take, Stellaris provides grand-scale diplomacy, while Kenshi offers a gritty survival experience. Start with RimWorld – it’s the safest bet for fans of Going Medieval.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →