keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Best External Hard Drives for Backups

Card No. 06·73656 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

The best external hard drive for most people is the Seagate Backup Plus Hub because it offers a massive amount of storage for the price, comes with built-in USB hub ports, and includes a two-year data recovery service. It’s a reliable workhorse that balances cost, capacity, and practical features for desktop users who need straightforward backup storage.

What to Look For

Before picking a drive, focus on these criteria that actually matter for backups:

  • Capacity vs. Price: Calculate how much data you need to back up, then double it for future growth and version history. Look for the best cost per terabyte (TB).
  • Drive Type (HDD vs. SSD): Hard disk drives (HDDs) are cheaper per gigabyte and fine for backups. Solid-state drives (SSDs) are faster, quieter, and more shock-resistant, but cost more. For most backups, an HDD is sufficient.
  • Interface and Speed: USB 3.0 (or newer) is standard. USB-C offers faster transfers and universal compatibility with modern laptops. Thunderbolt is overkill for backups.
  • Portability: If you travel with the drive, choose a 2.5-inch model that draws power from the USB port. For desk use, a 3.5-inch drive with an AC adapter offers more capacity per dollar.
  • Reliability and Warranty: Look for a reputable brand and a warranty of at least two years. Some drives include data recovery services, which can be a lifesaver.
  • Software and Features: Many drives come with backup software, but you can often use free tools like Windows File History or Time Machine. Hardware encryption adds security for sensitive data.

Top Picks

Seagate Backup Plus Hub (Desktop HDD)

Strengths: Excellent cost per TB, up to 18TB capacity, two front-facing USB ports for charging or connecting other devices, and includes two years of Seagate Rescue data recovery. The bundled Toolkit software supports scheduled backups and folder mirroring.

Trade-offs: Requires an AC power outlet, so it’s not portable. The plastic enclosure feels less premium, and the included software is basic compared to some rivals.

Who it suits: Desktop users who need a large, stationary backup drive for a whole family’s photos, videos, and documents.

Western Digital My Book (Desktop HDD)

Strengths: Reliable, widely available, and comes with hardware encryption (256-bit AES) and WD Backup software. Capacities up to 22TB. The drive is well-cooled and quiet.

Trade-offs: The software can be intrusive, and the drive is not portable. It’s often slightly more expensive per TB than the Seagate equivalent.

Who it suits: Users who want a trusted, secure desktop drive with built-in encryption for sensitive files.

Samsung T7 Shield (Portable SSD)

Strengths: Fast (up to 1,050 MB/s), rugged (IP65 water and dust resistance, drop-tested up to 3 meters), and pocket-sized. USB-C interface works with modern laptops and phones. Includes AES 256-bit hardware encryption.

Trade-offs: Much more expensive per TB than HDDs. Capacities top out at 4TB, which may be small for whole-system backups.

Who it suits: Photographers, videographers, and travelers who need a durable, fast drive for on-the-go backups.

SanDisk Extreme Portable SSD

Strengths: Similar performance to the T7 Shield (up to 1,050 MB/s), IP65 rating, and a carabiner loop for easy attachment. Available up to 4TB. Works well with both USB-C and USB-A (with adapter).

Trade-offs: Slightly slower sustained write speeds than the T7 in some tests. The rubberized exterior can pick up lint.

Who it suits: Users who want a rugged, fast SSD for active backups and file transfers between multiple devices.

LaCie Rugged Mini (Portable HDD)

Strengths: Classic orange bumper provides drop, shock, and crush resistance (up to 1.2 tons). Compatible with USB-C and Thunderbolt 3. Includes a one-year data recovery service. Capacities up to 5TB.

Trade-offs: Uses a spinning hard drive, so it’s slower than SSDs (around 130 MB/s). It’s also heavier and bulkier than SSD options.

Who it suits: Field workers and students who need a durable, portable drive that can handle rough conditions without breaking the bank.

WD My Passport (Portable HDD)

Strengths: Compact, reliable, and available in many colors. Capacities up to 6TB. Includes WD Backup software and 256-bit AES hardware encryption. USB 3.2 Gen 1 interface.

Trade-offs: The USB-C version costs extra; the standard model uses a Micro-B port. Not as fast as an SSD.

Who it suits: Everyday users who want a simple, portable backup drive for a laptop or a single desktop.

How to Choose

Budget: If you’re on a tight budget, a 1TB portable HDD (like the WD My Passport) offers the lowest cost per GB. For larger backups, desktop HDDs (like the Seagate Backup Plus Hub) give you the most storage for your money. SSDs are a luxury for those who need speed and durability.

Use Case: For a stationary home backup of a desktop PC, choose a 3.5-inch desktop drive with a large capacity. For a laptop, a portable 2.5-inch HDD is convenient. For creative professionals who edit directly from the backup drive, an SSD is worth the premium.

Common Trade-offs: The main trade-off is speed vs. price. HDDs are cheap and large, but slow and fragile. SSDs are fast and rugged, but expensive and smaller. Another trade-off is portability vs. capacity: you can’t get a 20TB SSD at a reasonable price, so if you need massive storage, you’ll likely need a desktop HDD that requires a power outlet.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much storage do I need for backups?

A good rule of thumb is to have at least twice the amount of data you’re backing up. If your computer has 500GB of files, get a 1TB drive. This leaves room for future data and multiple backup versions.

Should I use an HDD or SSD for backups?

For most people, an HDD is sufficient and offers better value. Choose an SSD if you need faster transfers, plan to work directly from the drive, or need extra durability for travel.

Can I use the same external drive for both Mac and Windows?

Yes, but you’ll need to format it in a cross-compatible file system like exFAT. Note that some drives come pre-formatted for one OS, so you may need to reformat.

How long do external hard drives last?

Typically 3-5 years, but it varies. Always keep a second backup (like a cloud service) for critical data. Replace the drive if you notice unusual noises or errors.

Do I need backup software?

Not necessarily. Windows and macOS have built-in tools (File History and Time Machine). Many drives include software, but it’s not required. The key is to schedule regular backups.

Is it safe to leave my external drive plugged in all the time?

Yes, but it may reduce the drive’s lifespan due to constant power and heat. For desktop drives, it’s fine. For portables, unplug when not in use to avoid wear.

Bottom Line

For the best balance of price, capacity, and reliability, the Seagate Backup Plus Hub is our top pick for desktop backups. If you need portability, the WD My Passport is a solid, affordable choice. And if you’re willing to spend more for speed and durability, the Samsung T7 Shield is the best portable SSD. Whatever you choose, remember that a backup is only good if it’s tested and updated regularly.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →