keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Best Indie Games: Top Picks & Buying Guide

Card No. 06·57832 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

The best indie game right now is Hades (Supergiant Games). It masterfully blends fast-paced combat, a gripping story that unfolds through repeated runs, and stunning art, earning near-universal acclaim and multiple Game of the Year awards. While it’s a roguelike, its narrative depth and accessibility make it a must-play for almost anyone.

What to Look For

When choosing an indie game, you’re not just picking a title—you’re picking an experience. Here are the criteria that actually matter:

  • Gameplay Loop: What will you do for the 10–50 hours? Is it a tight platformer, a deep RPG, a tense survival sim? The core loop should be engaging enough to keep you coming back.
  • Story & Atmosphere: Many indies shine in narrative. Do you want a wordless, environmental story (like Journey) or a dialogue-heavy, character-driven tale (like Disco Elysium)?
  • Art Direction & Sound: Graphics don’t need to be photorealistic, but the visual style and soundtrack create the mood. A cohesive aesthetic can elevate a simple game to a masterpiece.
  • Replayability: Will you play it once and be done, or does it have multiple endings, unlockables, or procedural generation that give it legs?
  • Difficulty & Accessibility: Some games are brutally hard (like Cuphead), others are chill. Check for difficulty options, remappable controls, and colorblind modes.
  • Price & Length: Indie games range from $5 to $40. Know how long the experience is—a 2-hour gem might be fine at $10, but not at $30.

Hades

Strengths: Perfectly tuned action-RPG combat, a story that integrates death and failure into the narrative, gorgeous hand-drawn art, and an incredible soundtrack. The voice acting and character writing are AAA quality. It’s also surprisingly forgiving for a roguelike, with a ‘God Mode’ that reduces damage each time you die.

Trade-offs: The isometric camera and fast-paced combat may not appeal to those who prefer slower, strategic games. It’s also heavily focused on combat—there’s no exploration in the traditional sense. The story requires many runs to fully see, which can feel repetitive to some.

Who it’s for: Anyone who loves action games, Greek mythology, or a good story. It’s the perfect entry point into roguelikes, and a great pick for players who usually bounce off ‘hard’ games.

Stardew Valley

Strengths: A deeply relaxing and rewarding farming/life sim. You can farm, fish, mine, forage, and build relationships with townsfolk. It’s incredibly polished, has a wonderful pixel-art style, and offers endless hours of content. The multiplayer mode is a great co-op experience.

Trade-offs: The game is essentially a time-management loop—each day is 15 minutes, and you have to prioritize. It can feel overwhelming with the sheer number of things to do, and the ‘chill’ vibe can turn into stress if you’re a completionist. The combat in the mines is basic.

Who it’s for: Perfect for players who love Animal Crossing, Harvest Moon, or just want a low-stress game to unwind with. It’s also a great game to play with a partner or friends.

Hollow Knight

Strengths: A masterclass in Metroidvania design. The hand-drawn world of Hallownest is vast, interconnected, and full of secrets. Combat is tight and fair, and the boss fights are some of the best in the genre. The atmosphere is hauntingly beautiful, and the lore is deep (but optional).

Trade-offs: It is genuinely difficult. The game gives you no hand-holding, and you will get lost. The map system is intentionally vague, and the save points can be far apart. It’s a long game (30+ hours) and the difficulty spikes can be frustrating.

Who it’s for: Players who love exploration, challenge, and atmospheric worlds. If you enjoyed Super Metroid or Castlevania: Symphony of the Night, this is a must-buy. It’s not for those who want a relaxed, guided experience.

Celeste

Strengths: A pixel-perfect platformer with a deeply personal and moving story about anxiety and self-doubt. The controls are incredibly tight, and the level design is brilliant. The ‘Assist Mode’ (options for invincibility, extra jumps, etc.) is a gold standard for accessibility, making it playable by anyone.

Trade-offs: The core game is very hard—precision platforming that requires patience. The story, while touching, is delivered in short cutscenes and text, which might not engage everyone. The music is great, but the chiptune style isn’t for all.

Who it’s for: Platformer fans who want a challenge, but also anyone who appreciates a heartfelt story. The assist mode means you can experience the narrative even if you’re not a platforming expert.

Disco Elysium

Strengths: A revolutionary RPG where you play a detective with amnesia in a politically charged, surreal world. There is no combat—instead, you use skills and dialogue to solve a murder. The writing is phenomenal, hilarious, and heartbreaking. Your character’s internal thoughts are a character in themselves.

Trade-offs: It is a text-heavy game—you will read a lot. The lack of traditional action means it’s not for everyone. The subject matter (politics, addiction, existentialism) is heavy and can be emotionally draining. The game’s pace is slow, and some players may find it boring.

Who it’s for: Perfect for readers, fans of classic CRPGs, and anyone who loves deep, consequential choices. If you want action, look elsewhere. If you want a story that will stay with you for years, this is it.

Baba Is You

Strengths: An incredibly innovative puzzle game where you manipulate the rules of the game itself. Words are objects you can push around—’Baba Is You’ can become ‘Baba Is Rock’ or ‘Wall Is Stop’. It’s a brilliant concept that leads to hundreds of mind-bending puzzles. The game is pure logic, with no filler.

Trade-offs: It is brain-meltingly difficult. The puzzles require lateral thinking and can have you stuck for hours. The presentation is minimalist, almost stark, with simple graphics and no story. It’s a game you play in short bursts, not long sessions.

Who it’s for: Puzzle enthusiasts, programmers, and anyone who loves to think. It’s a fantastic brain workout, but it’s not relaxing. If you get frustrated easily, this might not be for you.

How to Choose

Start with your budget. Indie games are cheaper than AAA titles, but prices vary. If you’re on a tight budget, look for games under $20—many of the best (like Celeste and Baba Is You) are in that range. For a longer experience, Stardew Valley and Hollow Knight offer dozens of hours for a low price.

Next, consider your use case. Are you playing in short bursts on a commute? A puzzle game like Baba Is You is perfect. Do you want to sink into a world for a weekend? Disco Elysium is immersive. Playing with a partner? Stardew Valley has co-op.

Finally, weigh the trade-offs. The biggest one is difficulty vs. story. Hollow Knight and Celeste are hard but rewarding. Disco Elysium is easy but text-heavy. Hades is a perfect middle ground—it’s challenging but forgiving. If you’re new to indie games, start with Hades or Stardew Valley—they’re the most universally appealing. If you’re a veteran, try Hollow Knight or Baba Is You for a challenge.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Are indie games only for PC?
A: No, most indie games are also on consoles and the Switch. Check the store page for platform availability.

Q: How long are indie games?
A: It varies wildly. Some are 2-3 hours (like Journey), others are 50+ hours (like Stardew Valley). The game’s store page usually lists an estimated length.

Q: Are indie games worth the money?
A: Yes, often more than AAA games. They offer unique experiences you can’t find elsewhere, and many are priced lower than their length and quality would suggest.

Q: Can I play indie games on a low-end laptop?
A: Many yes, but not all. Games with pixel art (like Stardew Valley) run on almost anything, but 3D games (like Hades) need a decent GPU. Check the system requirements before buying.

Q: What’s the difference between indie and AA games?
A: Indie games are made by small teams with independent funding. AA games are larger, often backed by a publisher, but still not AAA budget. It’s a spectrum.

Q: Are there any good free indie games?
A: Yes, there are many free indie games on platforms like itch.io and Steam. They are often shorter or experimental, but some are excellent. Doki Doki Literature Club is a famous free indie game, though it’s a psychological horror.

Bottom Line

If you only buy one indie game, make it Hades. It’s the most polished, accessible, and universally loved indie game of the past decade. But if you prefer a more relaxed experience, go for Stardew Valley. For a deep story, Disco Elysium. For a challenge, Hollow Knight or Celeste. The beauty of indie games is that there’s something for everyone—you just have to pick the one that fits your taste.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →