If you just finished the Modern Warfare reboot (2019) campaign and want more tight, cinematic, grounded military shooting, the top pick is Battlefield 1 — its War Stories mode delivers the same blend of personal stakes, varied set-pieces, and historical grit, but with a WWI setting that feels fresh. It’s the closest you’ll get to that “everyman soldier” tone without feeling like a copy.
What to Look For
Not all FPS campaigns scratch the same itch. Here’s what actually matters when picking your next one after Modern Warfare:
- Gunplay feel: You want responsive, weighty weapons with punchy audio and minimal bullet sponge enemies. Aim for games where headshots matter and reloads feel deliberate.
- Mission variety: Modern Warfare shines with stealth sections, vehicle sequences, and “all hell breaks loose” moments. Look for campaigns that mix up pacing rather than 8 hours of corridor shooting.
- Story tone: Do you want gritty and grounded (like MW), over-the-top action (like Call of Duty: Black Ops), or something more character-driven? Pick based on the mood you’re in.
- Length: Most military campaigns run 6–10 hours. If you want a weekend romp, stick to that range. Longer isn’t always better if it’s padded.
- Replayability: Collectibles, difficulty options, and optional objectives add value. If you like 100% runs, check for those features.
- Technical polish: Check for stable framerates, minimal bugs, and good PC optimization if you’re on that platform. Nothing kills immersion like stutter.
Battlefield 1
Strengths: The War Stories anthology format gives you six mini-campaigns, each with a distinct protagonist and setting — from a Harlem Hellfighter to a Bedouin rebel. The gunplay feels chunky and unforgiving, and the set-pieces are spectacular (zeppelin crashes, tank charges, trench raids). The sound design is among the best in the genre.
Trade-offs: It’s WWI, so no modern gadgets or loadout customization. Some stories are shorter (2–3 hours each), and the tone can swing from somber to action-movie without warning.
Who it suits: Anyone who wants a change of era but the same “average soldier” perspective. Also great if you like historical settings with a cinematic sheen.
Titanfall 2
Strengths: This campaign is a masterclass in pacing and movement. You get wall-running, double-jumps, and a giant robot companion (BT-7274) who becomes genuinely endearing. The “Effect and Cause” time-travel level is one of the best FPS missions ever made. It’s short (6–7 hours) but every minute counts.
Trade-offs: It’s sci-fi, so not strictly “military” in the realistic sense. The multiplayer is dead-ish, but the campaign is self-contained. Some players find the movement system hard to master at first.
Who it suits: Players who want a break from realism but still want tight shooting mechanics and a memorable buddy dynamic. It’s also a great palate cleanser after a gritty MW.
Call of Duty: Black Ops Cold War
Strengths: Set in the 1980s, this campaign blends historical events (like the KGB mole hunt) with classic Black Ops conspiracy nonsense. It offers multiple endings and some choice-based missions, which adds replay value. Gunplay is identical to Modern Warfare (same engine), so it feels instantly familiar.
Trade-offs: The story can be confusing if you’re not into Cold War lore, and some missions feel like padding. It’s shorter (around 5–6 hours), and the “choices” don’t drastically change the experience.
Who it suits: If you loved Modern Warfare’s mechanics but want a more spy-thriller vibe with branching paths, this is your pick.
Metro Exodus
Strengths: This is a post-apocalyptic shooter, but it’s grounded in survivalist military tactics. You manage resources, clean your weapons, and make moral choices. The environments are stunning (from Moscow’s tunnels to the Caspian desert), and the atmosphere is oppressive and tense. The gunplay is methodical — every bullet counts.
Trade-offs: It’s slower-paced than MW, with stealth and survival elements that might frustrate action-first players. The story is linear-ish but has open-world hub levels. Also, the horror elements might not be for everyone.
Who it suits: Players who want a more thoughtful, immersive military survival experience with a strong narrative. If you liked the “clean your gun” moments in MW, you’ll love this.
Spec Ops: The Line
Strengths: This third-person shooter is a psychological deconstruction of the military shooter genre. It starts like a standard cover-shooter but slowly reveals a dark, disturbing narrative about war crimes and PTSD. The story is unforgettable, and it makes you question every “heroic” action you take.
Trade-offs: Gameplay is generic (think Gears of War), and the combat can feel dated. It’s more of an experience than a “fun” shooter. Also, it’s third-person, not first-person.
Who it suits: If you want a campaign that makes you think and feel uncomfortable, this is the anti-Modern Warfare. Perfect for players who care more about story than mechanical polish.
Halo: The Master Chief Collection (Halo 2 or Reach)
Strengths: This is a sci-fi military epic, but it hits the same “super-soldier” power fantasy that Modern Warfare occasionally gives you. Halo 2’s dual-wielding and vehicle sections are iconic, while Reach’s story is a tragic, character-driven war drama. The MCC includes all games, so you get tons of content for one price.
Trade-offs: The gunplay is floatier than CoD (shields regenerate, no recoil), and the AI is old-school. If you want realistic ballistics, look elsewhere. But if you want a grand space war, it’s unbeatable.
Who it suits: Players who want a longer campaign (each game is 8–10 hours) with a strong co-op option. Also great if you like alien enemies and epic scale.
How to Choose
Budget: If you’re on a tight budget, look for older titles like Titanfall 2 or Spec Ops: The Line, which are often on sale for under $10. Battlefield 1 is also cheap these days. Newer games like Black Ops Cold War are still full price, so wait for a sale if you’re not desperate.
Use case: Do you want a quick weekend blast? Titanfall 2 or Black Ops Cold War (both ~6 hours) fit. Want a longer, more immersive world? Metro Exodus or Halo MCC will give you 20+ hours. If you’re playing with a friend, Halo MCC and Battlefield 1 have co-op campaigns (Halo is better for co-op).
Common trade-offs: Realistic vs. sci-fi: if you want modern military realism, stick to CoD or Battlefield. If you’re open to fantasy, Titanfall 2 and Halo offer more creativity. Story vs. gameplay: Spec Ops has a better story but worse gameplay; Titanfall 2 has great gameplay but a lighter story. Also, consider your tolerance for horror (Metro) and dated graphics (Spec Ops).
Frequently Asked Questions
Are these games available on PC?
Yes, all of the above are on PC (Steam, Epic, or Microsoft Store). Halo MCC and Battlefield 1 are also on Xbox Game Pass, which is a great deal if you have it.
Can I play these without playing the previous games in the series?
Yes. Battlefield 1, Titanfall 2, and Spec Ops: The Line are standalone stories. Black Ops Cold War is a sequel but you don’t need to play the older Black Ops games to understand it. Metro Exodus is the third game in the Metro series, so you’ll miss some backstory, but it works as a standalone. Halo MCC includes all games, so you can start with Halo 1 if you want.
Which one has the best graphics?
Metro Exodus and Battlefield 1 are the most visually impressive, with Metro having the best lighting and detail. Black Ops Cold War looks similar to Modern Warfare (good, but not groundbreaking). Titanfall 2 is older but still holds up well.
Are these games too hard for casual players?
Most have difficulty settings. Titanfall 2 and Halo are forgiving on Normal. Metro Exodus can be tough on higher difficulties but has a story mode. Spec Ops: The Line is medium difficulty. Battlefield 1’s War Stories are fairly easy on Normal.
Do these games have multiplayer?
Battlefield 1, Black Ops Cold War, and Halo MCC have active multiplayer. Titanfall 2’s multiplayer is mostly dead. Metro Exodus and Spec Ops are single-player only.
Which one is the most like Modern Warfare?
Black Ops Cold War is the closest in terms of gunplay and feel. Battlefield 1 is similar in tone and set-pieces but with a different era. If you want the same “modern military” vibe, go with Cold War.
Bottom Line
If you want the closest experience to Modern Warfare, pick Call of Duty: Black Ops Cold War — it’s the same engine, same gunplay, and a solid spy story. But if you’re willing to try something different, Battlefield 1 offers the best blend of cinematic action and emotional weight. And if you want pure fun, Titanfall 2 is the most underrated gem in the genre. Whichever you choose, you’re in for a good time.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Reliable Subaru vs New Honda Civic Cost
- Pokemon Bookmark Corner Designs & Pokemon GO DIY
- Forgotten Games That Created Your Favorite Genres
- Lexus vs Genesis Luxurious Compact SUV0.075 hp/lb
- Uber VW Robotaxi LA Launch Date
- Notebook vs Tablet: Which Saves You More Money?