keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Best Open World RPGs If You’re Unsure About Crimson Desert

Card No. 06·4031 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

If you’re on the fence about Crimson Desert, the top pick to try instead is Black Myth: Wukong — it delivers the same cinematic, boss-heavy action with a gorgeous open world, but with a tighter, more focused experience that doesn’t demand hundreds of hours. It’s the closest match in combat feel and visual spectacle, and it’s already proven and polished. For a broader open-world sandbox, Elden Ring remains the gold standard, but Wukong is the safer bet if you want that Crimson Desert energy without the uncertainty.

What to Look For

When you’re unsure about Crimson Desert, you’re really weighing a few core things. First, combat depth — Crimson Desert promises fast, skill-based, action-RPG combat, so you want games that nail that. Second, open-world structure — do you want a dense, handcrafted map or a sprawling sandbox with emergent stories? Third, story and pacing — Crimson Desert seems to blend a personal narrative with a living world; some games do this better than others. Fourth, time commitment — some open-world RPGs demand 100+ hours, others respect your time more. Finally, polish and performance — you don’t want a buggy mess after a big purchase. Keep these in mind as you compare.

Black Myth: Wukong

Strengths: Spectacular boss fights, fluid and responsive combat, stunning visuals, and a surprisingly rich world inspired by Chinese mythology. It’s linear-ish but with large, explorable areas that reward curiosity. The difficulty is challenging but fair, and the story is more focused than most open-world epics.

Trade-offs: Not a true open world — it’s more like interconnected levels. There’s no character creation or branching dialogue, and the RPG elements are lighter (skill trees, gear, but no stats to allocate).

Who it’s for: Players who want Crimson Desert’s action and visual flair but prefer a more curated, less overwhelming experience. If you loved Sekiro or God of War, this is your pick.

Elden Ring

Strengths: The definitive open-world action RPG. A massive, handcrafted world with no hand-holding, incredible boss design, deep build variety, and a sense of discovery that’s unmatched. It’s the game Crimson Desert is clearly drawing inspiration from.

Trade-offs: Brutal difficulty that can be off-putting, cryptic story told through item descriptions, and a world that can feel lonely. Performance on older hardware can be an issue, and the sheer scale can be intimidating.

Who it’s for: Veterans who want the ultimate challenge and don’t mind a steep learning curve. If you’re looking for a game that respects your intelligence and rewards exploration, this is it.

Dragon’s Dogma 2

Strengths: Dynamic combat with a unique pawn system (AI companions), a living world that feels reactive, and emergent gameplay that leads to memorable stories. Climbing on monsters is a blast, and the physics-based magic is fantastic.

Trade-offs: Fast travel is limited, the story is serviceable at best, and the world can feel sparse in places. Performance issues on PC at launch were significant, though patches helped. It’s also a game that expects you to engage with its systems, not just follow quest markers.

Who it’s for: Players who love emergent gameplay and don’t mind a slower pace. If you want a world that feels alive and combat that’s creative, this is a great alternative to Crimson Desert’s more scripted approach.

Ghost of Tsushima

Strengths: Beautiful open world, tight and satisfying combat (especially on lethal difficulty), and a strong narrative about honor and duty. The wind-guided exploration is a refreshing change from cluttered maps, and the game is polished to a shine.

Trade-offs: The open-world activities (fox dens, haiku spots) can feel repetitive, and the combat, while excellent, is less deep than Crimson Desert’s seems to be. It’s also a more grounded, historical setting rather than fantasy.

Who it’s for: Players who want a cinematic, story-driven open-world action game with a focus on swordplay. If you liked the samurai vibe of Sekiro but want a more accessible experience, this is perfect.

Horizon Forbidden West

Strengths: Gorgeous open world, engaging combat against robotic dinosaurs, and a compelling sci-fi story. The skill tree is deep, and there are plenty of side activities that feel meaningful. It’s a AAA polish machine.

Trade-offs: The story can be a bit convoluted, and the melee combat is weak compared to the ranged options. Some players find the dialogue and character animations stiff. It’s also a PlayStation title, so PC players need to wait for ports.

Who it’s for: Players who enjoy a mix of ranged and tactical combat, and who appreciate a more hopeful, sci-fi tone. If you want a game that’s less grim than Crimson Desert, this is a good choice.

Assassin’s Creed Valhalla

Strengths: Massive open world, satisfying Viking power fantasy, and a wealth of content. Combat is visceral and weighty, and the settlement-building adds a layer of progression. It’s also frequently on sale.

Trade-offs: It’s a huge time sink (100+ hours), and the story can feel bloated. The RPG elements are shallow compared to dedicated RPGs, and the world can feel repetitive. Performance on older hardware is a concern.

Who it’s for: Players who want a long, content-rich open-world game with a focus on raiding and building. If you’re not afraid of commitment and want a game that will last months, this is a solid pick.

How to Choose

Start with your budget. If you want to spend less, Assassin’s Creed Valhalla or Ghost of Tsushima are often discounted and offer tons of content. If you’re willing to pay full price, Black Myth: Wukong and Elden Ring are worth it. Next, consider your use case: do you have limited time? Then Black Myth: Wukong or Ghost of Tsushima are more respectful of your hours. Want a game to sink into for months? Elden Ring or Valhalla are better. The biggest trade-off is between handcrafted, focused experiences (Wukong, Ghost) and sprawling, emergent sandboxes (Elden Ring, Dragon’s Dogma 2). Also, think about difficulty: if you get frustrated easily, avoid Elden Ring; if you want a challenge, it’s the best. Finally, check your PC specs — all these games are demanding, but Elden Ring and Valhalla are more forgiving on older hardware than Wukong or Dragon’s Dogma 2.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is Black Myth: Wukong as open-world as Crimson Desert?
A: No, it’s more of a linear action game with large, explorable areas. It’s not a true open world, but it offers a similar sense of discovery.

Q: Which game has the best combat if I love Crimson Desert’s trailers?
A: Black Myth: Wukong and Elden Ring are the closest. Wukong is faster and more flashy, while Elden Ring is more methodical and build-focused.

Q: Are these games too hard for a casual player?
A: Ghost of Tsushima and Horizon Forbidden West have difficulty options that make them accessible. Elden Ring and Black Myth are challenging by design, but you can always use guides or summons.

Q: Do any of these games have a good story?
A: Ghost of Tsushima and Horizon Forbidden West have the most cinematic, character-driven stories. Black Myth’s story is more cryptic, and Elden Ring’s is told through lore.

Q: Will my PC run these games?
A: All of them are demanding. Check the minimum requirements on Steam. Dragon’s Dogma 2 and Black Myth are the most demanding, while Valhalla and Ghost of Tsushima are better optimized.

Bottom Line

If you’re unsure about Crimson Desert, the safest bet is Black Myth: Wukong — it gives you the same adrenaline-pumping combat and visual splendor without the open-world commitment. If you want a true open-world experience, Elden Ring is the definitive choice, but be ready for a challenge. For a more relaxed but still gorgeous adventure, Ghost of Tsushima is a fantastic pick. Ultimately, the best choice depends on how much time you have and how much challenge you want. Try one of these, and you’ll know exactly what you’re looking for in Crimson Desert.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →