keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Best Pokemon Games That Deserve a Remake

Card No. 06·80686 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

The top pick for a Pokemon game that deserves a remake is Pokemon Black 2 and White 2. These sequels offer the most content, the best post-game, and a story that directly builds on the original, making them the highest-value candidates for a modern update. A remake could fix their few flaws (like the slow start) while preserving what makes them the peak of the series’ 2D era.

What to Look For

When judging which Pokemon game deserves a remake, the criteria that actually matter go beyond just nostalgia. Here is what to weigh:

  • Story and Characters: A remake should enhance a narrative that was already strong. Games with compelling rivals, villains, and a memorable journey benefit the most from modern presentation.
  • Regional Design: The quality of the region itself—its layout, variety of environments, and sense of discovery—determines if a modern 3D version would be a treat to explore.
  • Content Depth: A remake needs enough base content (side activities, post-game areas, battle facilities) to justify the upgrade. A thin game will still feel thin in HD.
  • Mechanical Potential: How well would the game’s core mechanics translate to modern conveniences like the Exp. Share, the Poke Radar, or the DexNav? Games with unique mechanics (like seasons or triple battles) offer more to modernize.
  • Legacy and Rarity: Games that are hard to play legally today (due to age or price) are more deserving of a re-release. This includes the original Game Boy titles and the DS-era games that are now expensive.

Pokemon Black 2 & White 2 (DS)

Strengths: These sequels have the best story in the series, with a follow-up to Team Plasma’s arc that feels mature. The region of Unova is expanded with new areas, and the post-game is enormous, including the PWT (Pokemon World Tournament) where you battle past gym leaders and champions. The difficulty options (Challenge Mode) are a huge plus for veteran players.

Trade-offs: They are direct sequels, so a remake would ideally require remaking the first games too, or at least bundling them. The first 2-3 hours are famously linear and slow. Also, the pixel art is already quite good, so the visual upgrade might not feel as dramatic as for older games.

Best for: Players who want a deep, story-driven RPG with a huge amount of content and a real challenge. It is the most “modern” game on this list, so it would need the least mechanical overhaul.

Pokemon HeartGold & SoulSilver (DS)

Strengths: These are often considered the best remakes ever made, but they deserve a modern remake because they are stuck on the DS. They feature two full regions (Johto and Kanto), Pokemon following you, and the Pokeathlon. The sheer scope is unmatched. A Switch remake could add the QoL features from recent games while keeping the massive world.

Trade-offs: The games are already polished, so a new remake would need to justify its existence with significant new features, not just a graphical bump. The level curve in the original is notoriously unbalanced, and a remake would need to fix that. Also, the DS-era sprite art is beloved, and changing it to 3D models might alienate some fans.

Best for: Fans of the classic 2D era who want the ultimate “catch ’em all” experience with two regions. It is the safest bet for a guaranteed hit.

Pokemon Legends: Arceus (Switch)

Strengths: This is a unique case—it’s not a remake, but it is a perfect candidate for a “remake” of the Sinnoh region in a different style. The Hisui region is an ancient Sinnoh, and a future game could revisit the modern Sinnoh with the same action-based catching and exploration mechanics. The game’s focus on research and lore is a fresh take that many want to see expanded.

Trade-offs: It is a spinoff, not a mainline remake. The graphics are rough in places, and the battle system is simplified. A remake of Diamond/Pearl in this style would be a completely different game, not a faithful update.

Best for: Players who love the action-RPG direction and want to see the classic Sinnoh story told with modern catching mechanics and a living world.

Pokemon Emerald (GBA)

Strengths: Emerald is the definitive version of Hoenn, with the Battle Frontier, the Rayquaza storyline, and the improved gym leader teams. It is widely considered the peak of the GBA era. A remake could finally give us a proper Battle Frontier in 3D (since ORAS cut it) and modernize the stealthy Magma/Aqua plots.

Trade-offs: Omega Ruby and Alpha Sapphire already remade Hoenn in 3D, so a third remake in the same generation would feel redundant. The story is simpler than later games, and the water routes are famously tedious. It would need significant map design changes to feel fresh.

Best for: Fans of the GBA era who want the definitive Hoenn experience with modern graphics and the full Battle Frontier. It is a niche but passionate request.

Pokemon Platinum (DS)

Strengths: Platinum fixed many of Diamond and Pearl’s issues: it improved the pacing, added the Distortion World, and expanded the Pokedex. It has the best version of the Sinnoh story. A remake could finally give Sinnoh the visual and mechanical polish it deserves, with the modern Exp. Share and the Grand Underground.

Trade-offs: Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl (BDSP) were recent remakes, and they were widely criticized for being too faithful. A Platinum remake would need to deviate significantly from BDSP to be worth it. The game’s pacing is still slow, and the HMs (like Defog) are annoying.

Best for: Players who were disappointed by BDSP and want a true, enhanced remake that respects Platinum’s improvements and adds modern QoL.

Pokemon Yellow (GB)

Strengths: The original Kanto games are the most iconic, and Yellow is the definitive version with Pikachu following you and the ability to get all three starters. A remake could bring Kanto into the modern era with a cohesive art style (unlike the Let’s Go games, which were simplified). It would be a pure nostalgia trip with modern mechanics.

Trade-offs: Kanto is the most remade region (FireRed/LeafGreen, Let’s Go, and the post-game in Gold/Silver). The story is almost nonexistent, and the region is small by modern standards. A remake would need to add a lot of new content to feel substantial.

Best for: New players who want to experience the origin of the series, and old fans who want the classic 151 with modern graphics and no motion-control gimmicks.

How to Choose

Your choice depends on what you value most. If you want a deep story and a huge amount of content, Black 2/White 2 is the clear winner. If you want the most iconic and complete classic adventure, HeartGold/SoulSilver is the safest pick. If you want a fresh take on an old region, Legends Arceus-style is the most innovative option.

Budget is a factor: DS-era games are expensive on the secondhand market, so a remake of those would be more valuable financially. Use case matters too—if you play on a Switch and refuse to emulate, you’ll want a remake of a game you can’t already play. If you have a DS or 3DS, you can already play most of these, so a remake is less urgent.

Common trade-offs: Faithful remakes (like BDSP) satisfy purists but feel outdated; bold remakes (like ORAS) add features but cut content. Consider whether you want a 1:1 update or a reimagining. Also, think about the art style—some games (like Emerald) are best in 2D, while others (like Black/White) could shine in 3D.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why not remake Pokemon Diamond and Pearl again?

Because Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl were just released in 2021. A Platinum-style remake would be more valuable, but it would need to be significantly different from BDSP to be worth another purchase.

Are the DS games really that expensive?

Yes, Pokemon Black, White, Black 2, and White 2 are among the most expensive DS games, often costing $100+ for a complete copy. HeartGold and SoulSilver are also pricey. This makes remakes of those games more financially appealing to players.

What about a remake of Pokemon Crystal?

Crystal is a great game, but HeartGold and SoulSilver already remade its region and added most of its features. A new remake would be redundant unless it was a completely different style, like a Legends-style game set in Johto.

Will a remake ever include all Pokemon?

Unlikely. Recent games have limited the Pokedex to regional species. A remake would probably do the same, but it would include the full regional dex from the original game, which is usually a good selection.

Which remake would be the best for a newcomer?

HeartGold and SoulSilver are the most beginner-friendly because they have a gentle difficulty curve and a huge world to explore. Black 2 and White 2 are more challenging and assume you know the basics.

Do remakes usually change the story?

Sometimes. Omega Ruby and Alpha Sapphire expanded the story with the Delta Episode, while Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl kept the story almost identical. It depends on the developer’s approach.

Bottom Line

If you can only pick one, Pokemon Black 2 and White 2 are the most deserving of a remake because they combine the best story, the most content, and the highest legacy value. They are also the hardest to play legally today, making a modern version a genuine service to the community. For a more nostalgic pick, HeartGold and SoulSilver are a close second, but they have already been remade once. Ultimately, the best choice is the one that gives you the experience you can’t already have.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →