keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Best RPGs Like Baldur’s Gate 3 for Companion Stories & Romance

Card No. 06·80738 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

If you’re chasing the deep companion bonds and romance arcs that made Baldur’s Gate 3 unforgettable, the top pick is Dragon Age: The Veilguard — it’s the only game that matches BG3’s fully voiced, morally complex companions with dedicated romance paths that react to your choices across the entire story. Its party banter and personal quests feel like a direct lineage from BioWare’s golden era, and the combat is more action-oriented, so you get the character depth without turn-based tactics. If you specifically want turn-based combat AND romance, then Pathfinder: Wrath of the Righteous is the closest mechanical sibling, but its companions are less animated and its romance writing is sparser.

What to Look For

When you’re hunting for a BG3-like companion experience, these are the criteria that actually matter:

  • Companion reactivity: Do party members comment on your quests, argue with each other, and change their opinions based on your actions? BG3’s companions feel alive because they react to everything.
  • Romance depth: Look for games where romance isn’t just a dialogue tree at the end — it should have multiple stages, approval requirements, and ideally a sex scene or meaningful culmination that respects your earlier choices.
  • Personal quests: Each companion should have a multi-step personal storyline that reveals their backstory and can end in different ways depending on your choices.
  • Party banter: The best games have ambient dialogue between companions as you explore — this is what makes the party feel like a group of friends (or enemies).
  • Choice consequence: Your decisions should lock you out of some romances and alter companion endings. If everyone can romance everyone with zero friction, it feels hollow.

Dragon Age: The Veilguard

Strengths: This is the closest modern equivalent to BG3’s companion system. Each of the seven companions has a fully voiced, multi-stage personal quest that intertwines with the main plot. Romance is a dedicated path with multiple beats — flirting, commitment, and a payoff scene — and your choices can break up or deepen relationships. The party banter is constant and often hilarious, and companions will argue with each other over your decisions. The character creator is also excellent if you care about your own avatar.

Trade-offs: Combat is real-time action, not turn-based, and the tone is lighter than BG3 — less morally grey, more heroic fantasy. The romance scenes are less explicit than BG3’s, and there are no origin characters (you can’t play as a companion).

Who it’s for: Players who want the emotional depth and reactivity of BG3 but prefer action combat and a more polished, modern presentation.

Pathfinder: Wrath of the Righteous

Strengths: If you want turn-based combat and a huge party of companions with distinct personalities, this is the strongest contender. It has 10+ companions, each with a personal questline that can lead to different endings, and romances that range from sweet to genuinely disturbing (the demon romance is a highlight). The approval system is deep — companions will leave if you go against their core beliefs. It also has a Mythic Path system that changes how companions react to you, adding replayability.

Trade-offs: The writing is more uneven than BG3 — some companions are memorable, others are forgettable. Romance scenes are mostly text-based with a single static image, not fully animated. The game is also much harder and more complex, with a steep learning curve for the ruleset.

Who it’s for: Tactical players who want BG3’s combat depth and don’t mind less cinematic presentation. If you’re a completionist who loves build-crafting, this is your game.

Baldur’s Gate 1 & 2: Enhanced Editions

Strengths: The original games that defined the formula. BG2 in particular has some of the best-written companions in RPG history — Jaheira, Viconia, Aerie, and others have romance arcs that span the entire game and are affected by your race, class, and actions. The banter system was revolutionary, and the writing is sharp and witty. You also get the satisfaction of seeing the origins of the world and characters that BG3 references.

Trade-offs: The graphics are dated (2D isometric), combat is real-time-with-pause (though you can set it to auto-pause), and the UI is clunky by modern standards. Romance is text-only with no voice acting, and the pacing is much slower.

Who it’s for: Players who want the original BioWare magic and don’t mind old-school presentation. If you loved BG3’s story, you’ll appreciate the callbacks and the depth of the original.

Dragon Age: Origins

Strengths: The 2009 classic that still holds up for companion storytelling. Alistair, Morrigan, and Leliana are iconic, and their romances are deeply tied to the main plot — Morrigan’s romance literally changes the ending. The approval system is transparent (you can see exactly how each companion feels), and party banter is excellent. The origin stories give your character a personal stake that BG3 lacks.

Trade-offs: It’s old — dated graphics, clunky combat (real-time with tactics), and no voice acting for your protagonist. The romance scenes are tasteful but fade to black, not explicit like BG3.

Who it’s for: Players who want a more grounded, political fantasy with companions that feel like real people. If you liked the “origin” aspect of BG3’s characters, this is the gold standard.

Mass Effect Legendary Edition

Strengths: The trilogy is the only series that matches BG3’s romance continuity — your choices carry across three games, and romances from the first game can continue into the third. Garrus, Tali, Liara, and others are beloved for a reason. The companion missions are excellent, and the loyalty system in ME2 forces you to make hard choices that affect who survives the final mission. The Legendary Edition includes all DLC, so you get the full experience.

Strengths (cont.): The romance scenes are more tasteful but still meaningful, and the dialogue wheel makes conversations feel cinematic.

Trade-offs: It’s a shooter, not a fantasy RPG — no turn-based combat, no deep character builds. The first game’s combat is dated even in the remaster, and the companion roster is smaller than BG3’s.

Who it’s for: Players who want a sci-fi setting with the same emotional investment in companions. If you’re okay with shooting instead of spells, this is the best romance arc in gaming.

Divinity: Original Sin 2

Strengths: Made by the same studio (Larian), so you’ll feel right at home. It has origin characters with personal quests, turn-based combat, and a similar sense of player freedom. The romance is less developed than BG3 — it’s mostly a few dialogue scenes and a fade-to-black — but the companion banter and reactivity are excellent. The magic system is also more creative than BG3’s, allowing for environmental combos.

Trade-offs: The story is more whimsical and less character-driven than BG3. Companions have less dialogue and fewer romance scenes. The final act is notoriously rushed.

Who it’s for: Players who want more of Larian’s turn-based combat and exploration but don’t need romance to be the focus. It’s also cheaper than BG3, making it a good budget option.

How to Choose

Budget first: If you can only buy one game, Dragon Age: The Veilguard is the safest bet for modern graphics and companion depth. If you’re on a tight budget, Dragon Age: Origins and Baldur’s Gate 2 are often on sale for under $10 and offer hundreds of hours of content. Divinity: Original Sin 2 is also frequently discounted.

Combat preference: If you must have turn-based combat, choose Pathfinder: Wrath of the Righteous or Divinity: Original Sin 2. If you’re fine with real-time or action combat, Dragon Age: The Veilguard and Mass Effect are better picks.

Romance intensity: For the most explicit and integrated romance, Baldur’s Gate 3 remains the king, but Dragon Age: The Veilguard is close. Mass Effect has the best slow-burn romance arc across multiple games. Pathfinder has the most variety but the least cinematic payoff.

Time investment: Mass Effect Legendary Edition is three games, easily 100+ hours. Pathfinder: Wrath can take 150+ hours for a single playthrough. If you want a tighter experience, Dragon Age: Origins is about 40-60 hours, and The Veilguard is about 60-80.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is there any game with romance as deep as Baldur’s Gate 3?
A: Not quite. BG3’s combination of full voice acting, motion-captured scenes, and branching romance paths is unique. Dragon Age: The Veilguard is the closest in terms of integration, but the scenes are less explicit.

Q: Are there any indie RPGs with good companion stories?
A: Yes — Disco Elysium has amazing dialogue but no romance. Tyranny has a small cast with interesting companions but limited romance. Pillars of Eternity 2 has decent companions but romance is minimal.

Q: Can I romance characters of any gender in these games?
A: Most modern games (Veilguard, Pathfinder, BG3) are player-sexual — any companion can be romanced by any gender. Older games like Dragon Age: Origins and Mass Effect have some same-sex options but not for every companion.

Q: Which game has the best party banter?
A: Dragon Age: Origins and Baldur’s Gate 2 are legendary for banter. The Veilguard has frequent and well-written banter too, but it’s more polished and less edgy.

Q: Is Pathfinder: Wrath of the Righteous too hard for a casual player?
A: Yes, it can be. The ruleset is complex, and even on normal difficulty, you’ll need to understand builds. If you’re not a tactics veteran, start on story mode or choose Divinity: Original Sin 2 instead.

Q: Do I need to play Dragon Age Origins before The Veilguard?
A: No, each game has a new protagonist and mostly self-contained story. You’ll miss some references, but you won’t be lost. If you want the full experience, start with Origins and play in order.

Bottom Line

For the most BG3-like companion and romance experience, Dragon Age: The Veilguard is the clear winner — it’s modern, reactive, and treats romance as a core mechanic. If you want turn-based combat, choose Pathfinder: Wrath of the Righteous despite its rough edges. For a budget option that still delivers on story, grab Dragon Age: Origins or Baldur’s Gate 2 on sale. And if you’re open to sci-fi, Mass Effect Legendary Edition offers the most emotionally rewarding romance arc in gaming. Whichever you pick, you’ll find companions that feel like old friends by the end.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →