keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Best Smart Relay Switches for Home Automation

Card No. 06·75414 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

The best smart relay switch right now is the Shelly Plus 1 for most people because it is compact, affordable, and works with nearly every major smart home platform without requiring a hub. It installs behind an existing wall switch, is rated for 16 amps, and costs less than most competitors. If you need more than one channel or want built-in energy monitoring, the Sonoff MINIR4 or the Shelly Plus 1PM are better fits.

What to Look For

Smart relay switches are small modules that retrofit into standard electrical boxes, letting you control lights, fans, or appliances from your phone or voice assistant. When comparing models, focus on these criteria:

  • Wet vs. dry contacts: Most relays are “dry” (switching only the load, no power for the relay itself) and need a neutral wire; some models like the Aqara T1 are “wet” (powered by the load circuit) and work without a neutral. Check your wiring before buying.
  • Current rating: Standard relays handle 10-16 amps for resistive loads (lights, heaters) but derate for inductive loads (fans, motors). If you plan to control a motor, look for a relay rated for at least 15 amps or use a contactor.
  • Neutral wire requirement: Many homes built after the 1980s have a neutral in the switch box, but older homes may not. If you lack a neutral, you need a no-neutral model like the Aqara T1 No-Neutral or the Shelly L1.
  • Smart home compatibility: Check for native support for Alexa, Google Home, Apple Home (HomeKit), or Matter. Some relays (e.g., Sonoff) require a cloud bridge, while others (Shelly) work locally over Wi-Fi without a hub.
  • Integration and automation: Look for local API, MQTT, or webhooks if you use Home Assistant or other advanced systems. Cloud-only relays can be slow or unreliable.
  • Size and installation: Measure your electrical box depth. Some relays are larger and may not fit in shallow boxes behind a switch.
  • Energy monitoring: If you want to track power usage, choose a model with built-in current sensing (e.g., Shelly Plus 1PM, Sonoff MINIR4).

Top Picks

Shelly Plus 1

Strengths: The Shelly Plus 1 is the best overall smart relay for most users. It is small (about the size of a matchbox), works over Wi-Fi without a hub, and supports both dry and wet contact modes. It has a 16A rating, a built-in web server, and integrates with Alexa, Google Home, and Home Assistant via local API. The Plus 1 also supports Matter over Wi-Fi (with a firmware update), making it future-proof.

Trade-offs: It requires a neutral wire for most installations (unless you use the L1 variant). The app is basic, and it lacks energy monitoring. The relay is designed for indoor use only.

Who it suits: DIYers who want a reliable, affordable relay for lighting or appliance control with local control and no subscription.

Sonoff MINIR4

Strengths: The Sonoff MINIR4 is a budget-friendly option that also works as a dry contact switch. It is very compact, supports up to 16A, and includes built-in energy monitoring. It works with the eWeLink app, which supports Alexa and Google Home, and it also has a local API for Home Assistant via Tasmota (after flashing). The MINIR4 is often cheaper than the Shelly Plus 1.

Trade-offs: It requires a neutral wire and the eWeLink cloud is needed for voice control unless you flash custom firmware. The app is not as polished as Shelly’s, and some users report occasional connectivity drops.

Who it suits: Budget-conscious users who want energy monitoring and are comfortable with a bit of tinkering.

Shelly Plus 1PM

Strengths: The Shelly Plus 1PM is the same as the Plus 1 but adds accurate energy monitoring (voltage, current, power, and energy). It is rated for 16A and supports the same local API, Matter, and integrations. The added monitoring lets you track appliance usage and set automation based on power draw.

Trade-offs: It is slightly larger than the Plus 1 and costs more. It still requires a neutral wire.

Who it suits: Users who want to monitor energy consumption of a specific circuit or appliance, such as a water heater or EV charger (though for high current, you may need a contactor).

Aqara T1 No-Neutral

Strengths: The Aqara T1 is a no-neutral smart relay that works with Zigbee (requires an Aqara Hub or a Zigbee coordinator). It is designed for homes without a neutral wire and is rated for 8A resistive, 3A inductive. It integrates with Apple Home, Alexa, and Google Home via the Aqara Home app. It is very small and fits in shallow boxes.

Trade-offs: It requires a separate Zigbee hub (unless you have a Home Assistant with a Zigbee stick). The current rating is lower than Wi-Fi relays, so it is not suitable for high-power loads like space heaters. It also does not support energy monitoring.

Who it suits: Homeowners with older wiring (no neutral) who want a reliable, low-power solution for lighting control.

Zooz ZEN34 (Z-Wave)

Strengths: The Zooz ZEN34 is a Z-Wave relay that works with any Z-Wave hub (SmartThings, Hubitat, Home Assistant). It is a dry contact switch rated for 15A and is known for its reliability and local control. It supports scene control (multi-tap) for advanced automation and is compatible with most Z-Wave networks.

Trade-offs: Z-Wave requires a hub, and the ZEN34 is more expensive than Wi-Fi relays. It also requires a neutral wire.

Who it suits: Users who already have a Z-Wave network and prioritize local, reliable control without cloud dependence.

Fibaro Relay Switch (FGS-214)

Strengths: The Fibaro FGS-214 is a premium Z-Wave relay that offers two independent channels, each rated for 10A. It supports energy monitoring on both channels, works with most Z-Wave hubs, and is known for its high build quality. It also has a built-in temperature sensor.

Trade-offs: It is significantly more expensive than other options, and it requires a neutral wire. It is also larger than other relays, so it may not fit in tight boxes.

Who it suits: Advanced smart home enthusiasts who need dual-channel control (e.g., two lights in one room) and energy monitoring, and are willing to pay a premium.

How to Choose

Budget: Wi-Fi relays like the Sonoff MINIR4 and Shelly Plus 1 are the cheapest (around $15-25). Zigbee and Z-Wave relays cost more ($30-50) but often offer better reliability and local control. If you are just starting, a Wi-Fi relay is the easiest and cheapest way to test the waters.

Use case: For simple on/off control of lights or fans, any relay will do. For appliances like heaters or pumps, check the current rating and consider a relay with a higher amp rating or a contactor. For energy monitoring, choose a model like the Shelly Plus 1PM. For homes without a neutral wire, you must choose a no-neutral model like the Aqara T1.

Common trade-offs:

  • Neutral wire vs. no-neutral: No-neutral relays are limited to lower currents (usually 8A) and may not work with some LED bulbs due to standby power draw. If you have a neutral, always prefer a neutral-required relay for higher reliability.
  • Cloud vs. local: Cloud-dependent relays (e.g., Sonoff with eWeLink) are easier to set up but rely on internet connectivity. Local control (via API or Z-Wave) is more reliable and faster, but requires more technical setup.
  • Hub vs. no hub: Wi-Fi relays work without a hub, but they can clutter your Wi-Fi network. Zigbee and Z-Wave relays need a hub but are more stable and secure.
  • Size: Always measure your electrical box depth. Some relays are too large to fit behind a switch, especially in older homes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need a neutral wire for a smart relay?

Most smart relays require a neutral wire to power the relay’s electronics. However, there are no-neutral models (like the Aqara T1) that work by leaking a small current through the load. Check your wiring before buying.

Can I use a smart relay to control a ceiling fan?

Yes, but you need to check the relay’s current rating for inductive loads. Most relays are rated for resistive loads up to 16A, but for fans, the rating is often lower (e.g., 5A). Use a relay with a sufficient inductive rating or add a contactor.

Will a smart relay work with a 3-way switch setup?

Yes, many smart relays support 3-way switching by connecting to the traveler wires. However, you need to ensure the relay is compatible with your wiring configuration. Some relays (like Shelly) have detailed diagrams for 3-way setups.

Can I control a smart relay without internet?

Yes, if the relay supports local control via API or MQTT (e.g., Shelly, Zooz). Cloud-dependent relays like Sonoff may require internet for voice control, but you can still use the physical switch locally.

Is it safe to install a smart relay myself?

If you have basic electrical knowledge and can turn off the breaker, you can install a relay. However, if you are unsure, always hire a licensed electrician. Working with live wires is dangerous.

What is the difference between a smart relay and a smart switch?

A smart switch replaces the entire wall switch and requires a neutral wire, while a smart relay is a small module that fits behind an existing switch, allowing you to keep the original switch. Relays are more flexible for retrofitting.

Bottom Line

For most users, the Shelly Plus 1 is the best smart relay switch due to its balance of price, size, and compatibility. If you need energy monitoring, spend a little more on the Shelly Plus 1PM. If you lack a neutral wire, the Aqara T1 No-Neutral is your best bet, though it requires a hub. For budget buyers, the Sonoff MINIR4 is a solid choice. Always verify your wiring and current requirements before purchasing.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →