Indie Games on Steam, itch.io, and GOG: How Stores Choose

Steam, itch.io, and GOG surface indie games in different ways: Steam relies heavily on a large catalog, tags, recommendations, and sales; itch.io gives creators flexible publishing and lets players browse community-made collections; GOG selects games for a curated catalog with an emphasis on DRM-free access. None guarantees that a game is good or suitable for you, so checking store pages, updates, and policies matters.

Three stores, three different approaches

“Curation” can mean several things: deciding what may be listed, organizing a catalog, choosing what appears in recommendations, and featuring selected games on a homepage. These are not the same process. A store can allow many titles while still highlighting only a small portion, and an algorithmic recommendation is not necessarily a staff endorsement.

Steam is Valve’s broad PC game store. It includes games from major publishers and small developers, and its discovery tools draw on information such as tags, player activity, and user preferences. itch.io is an open platform where creators publish games and other digital projects, often with substantial control over presentation and pricing. GOG, operated by GOG sp. z o.o., maintains a more selective catalog and is known for offering games without mandatory digital rights management (DRM).

How Steam helps players discover indie games

Steam’s scale is both its advantage and its challenge. The catalog contains a very large number of games, so Steam combines browse pages, tags, personalized recommendations, wishlists, user reviews, and seasonal events to help people find titles. Its store pages can also show information such as supported features, screenshots, trailers, and community reviews.

Developers can submit games through Steamworks, Valve’s publishing and developer tools. Steam does not operate as a traditional small editorial shop in which every release is chosen for a limited shelf. Instead, it uses a broad listing model alongside store rules and discovery systems. Valve has described recommendation features such as Discovery Queue and personalized recommendations as ways to help users find games; their visibility can vary with account activity, preferences, and store layout.

Tags are useful, but they are not a guarantee of quality or a formal genre certification. A player looking for short narrative games, turn-based tactics, or local co-op can use tags and filters, then check whether the actual game supports the desired features. Reviews also need context: read recent reviews, look at the number of reviews, and compare comments about performance or updates with the game’s listed system requirements.

How itch.io’s creator-led model works

itch.io is especially associated with independent creators, experimental projects, game jams, prototypes, and small releases. Publishers can create pages, upload files, set prices or offer a pay-what-you-want option where available, and choose how to present their work within itch.io’s platform tools. Many games are downloadable, while browser-playable titles are also common.

Its discovery experience includes browsing by categories and tags, collections, search, and community activity. Because creators and community members play a visible role in organizing the catalog, a themed collection or game-jam page can expose players to work that might not have a large advertising budget. That openness also means listing a game should not be confused with a detailed editorial review. Page quality, update history, and documentation vary from project to project.

For a less familiar itch.io release, check the creator’s page for installation instructions, platform compatibility, recent updates, and whether the download is a demo, prototype, or finished game. If a game is offered in several formats, confirm which file matches your operating system. The site’s open-ended character is a strength for discovery, but it puts more responsibility on the shopper to inspect the details.

What GOG’s curation means

GOG’s catalog is comparatively selective. Its best-known distinction is DRM-free distribution: for many games, players can download installers and play without a continuing online connection or a client running, though details vary by title and some games may still use online services for particular features. GOG Galaxy is an optional client for managing games and other functions; buyers should check the individual listing rather than assume every feature works offline.

GOG’s catalog includes older PC games as well as newer releases, including indie titles. Compatibility work can be important for older games: a listing may include adjustments intended to help a game run on modern systems. The store’s editorial selection is not a promise that every game will work perfectly on every computer, however. Check the supported operating systems, system requirements, user reviews, and any notes about multiplayer or third-party services.

“DRM-free” describes restrictions on access and copying, not a guarantee that a game is open source, freely redistributable, or free of online dependencies. It also does not mean every store feature or saved game is available offline. Consult the product page and GOG’s current support information for the specific title.

How to choose where to buy an indie game

Start with the game, not the store’s reputation. The same title may appear on more than one platform, but its price, updates, extras, operating-system support, and multiplayer arrangements can differ. Compare the actual listings before purchasing.

For broad discovery: Steam’s tags, recommendations, reviews, and frequent themed browsing make it convenient if you want to explore a large catalog.
For experimental projects: itch.io is a natural place to browse game jams, prototypes, small releases, and creator-led collections.
For DRM-free access: GOG is worth checking when downloadable installers and reduced dependence on a client are priorities.
For any store: verify operating-system support, controller and multiplayer features, recent update activity, refund terms, and whether the listed version is complete or an early release.

Refund policies are store-specific and can change, so read the policy shown by the store before buying. A demo, when available, is often a better way to check performance and controls than relying on screenshots or a high review score alone.

Common misconceptions and practical limits

A featured placement does not necessarily mean a game passed a comprehensive quality review. Storefronts may highlight a release through editorial choices, a promotional event, personalization, popularity, or other signals. Likewise, a game being available in a store does not establish that it is polished, actively maintained, or compatible with a particular computer.

Reviews are helpful but imperfect evidence. A review score can reflect different versions of a game, changing updates, hardware problems, or preferences that do not match yours. Look for patterns in recent, detailed reviews rather than treating a single comment or overall score as decisive. For multiplayer games, check whether servers are active and whether cross-play is supported; those details can change after launch.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Steam more curated than itch.io?
Not in the sense that every game is individually selected by editors. Steam offers a broad catalog with discovery and promotion systems, while itch.io gives creators and community collections a prominent role. Both require shoppers to assess individual games.

Does GOG sell only indie games?
No. GOG’s catalog includes indie releases alongside older and newer games from a range of publishers. Its defining characteristic is its selective catalog and emphasis on DRM-free releases, not an indie-only focus.

Does DRM-free mean I can share or resell a GOG game?
No. DRM-free generally means the game does not require certain access controls to run; it does not grant permission to redistribute or resell a copy. Check the applicable terms for the details.

Are itch.io games less reliable than Steam games?
Not automatically. Quality and support vary on every store. On itch.io, check the project’s development status, update history, platform notes, and creator information, especially for prototypes and game-jam entries.

Which store is best for finding hidden indie games?
There is no single best choice. Steam offers personalized browsing across a large catalog, itch.io is strong for experimental and creator-led discovery, and GOG can be useful for selected indie releases that fit its catalog. Try the tags and collections that match your interests.

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →