Citizen is a personal safety app that sends real-time alerts about nearby emergencies, but it is not the only option. If you are looking for alternatives, you can choose from other alert apps, built-in phone safety features, or community-based tools, depending on whether you want broader coverage, more privacy, or lower cost. This article compares the main competitors and helps you decide which fits your needs.
What Citizen Is and How It Works
Citizen launched in 2016 (originally as Vigilante) and uses public safety data, police scanners, 911 feeds, and user reports to push notifications about crimes, fires, car accidents, and other emergencies near your phone. The app shows a map with incident pins, live video streams from users, and a “safety score” for your area. It is free to use, but a premium subscription (Citizen Plus) adds features like 24/7 access to safety agents and location sharing with trusted contacts.
The core value is speed and context: you get notified within minutes of a reported incident, often before news outlets pick it up. However, the app has drawn criticism for fueling fear, spreading unverified information, and occasionally broadcasting graphic content. These issues have led many users to seek alternatives.
Key Alternatives to Citizen
There is no single app that replicates Citizen exactly, but several come close. Here are the main categories and examples:
- Neighborhood crime maps: Apps like Neighbors (by Amazon) and Nextdoor focus on community posts about suspicious activity, crime, and safety tips. They are less real-time but more community-driven.
- Emergency alert systems: FEMA’s Wireless Emergency Alerts (WEA) and local government apps send official alerts for severe weather, AMBER alerts, and imminent threats. These are reliable but not hyper-local like Citizen.
- Personal safety apps: bSafe, Noonlight, and Life360 focus on your personal safety—sharing your location with contacts, sending SOS signals, and triggering fake calls. They do not broadcast nearby incidents but are proactive tools.
- Scanner apps: Apps like Scanner Radio and Broadcastify stream live police and fire scanner audio. You get raw, unfiltered information but must interpret it yourself.
- Built-in phone features: Both iOS and Android have native safety features like Emergency SOS, crash detection, and location sharing via Find My. These are free and private, but they do not alert you to neighborhood events.
Each alternative trades off one of Citizen’s strengths: real-time coverage, ease of use, or breadth of data.
How to Choose the Right Alternative
Your choice depends on what you want from a safety app. Ask yourself these questions:
- Do you want alerts about incidents near you? If yes, consider Neighbors or a local alert app. Citizen is the most comprehensive, but if you dislike its tone, Neighbors is a calmer option.
- Do you want to be prepared for emergencies? If you want to call for help or share your location, choose a personal safety app like Noonlight or bSafe.
- Do you want official, verified alerts? For weather and government warnings, use WEA or your local emergency management app. These are the most authoritative.
- Do you care about privacy? Citizen collects location data and user reports. If that bothers you, use a scanner app or built-in phone features that do not require an account.
- Are you willing to pay? Citizen Plus costs about $20/month. Many alternatives are free or one-time purchases. Neighbors and Nextdoor are free; scanner apps are often free with ads.
There is no perfect app. Many people use two: one for official alerts and one for community or personal safety.
Common Problems and Misconceptions
One common misconception is that Citizen is always accurate. In reality, it relies on unverified user reports and scanner audio, which can lead to false alarms or outdated information. For example, a user might report a “suspicious person” who turns out to be a delivery driver. Another issue is notification fatigue—if you live in a busy city, you may get dozens of alerts a day, most of which are not relevant to you.
Privacy is another concern. Citizen’s terms allow it to share location data with law enforcement in some cases. If you are uncomfortable with that, a scanner app or a personal safety app that only shares your location when you trigger an SOS is a better fit.
Finally, many people think that having an alert app makes them safer. In reality, these apps are reactive—they tell you about incidents after they happen. They do not prevent crime. For proactive safety, consider learning self-defense, installing security cameras, or joining a neighborhood watch.
Cost Comparison
Citizen is free, but the premium tier costs around $20 per month. Here is how that compares:
- Neighbors: Free (with ads). No premium tier.
- Nextdoor: Free (with ads). Optional paid features for businesses.
- Noonlight: Free basic plan; premium starts around $5/month.
- bSafe: Free basic; premium around $8/month.
- Life360: Free basic; paid plans start around $8/month.
- Scanner Radio: Free with ads; ad-free version is a one-time purchase of about $3.
- Built-in phone features: Free (already on your phone).
If you only need basic alerts, free options work well. If you want 24/7 human monitoring, you will pay a premium.
Safety and Privacy Considerations
When using any safety app, be aware of what data you share. Citizen and Neighbors collect your location and may share it with third parties. Read the privacy policy before installing. For maximum privacy, use a scanner app that does not require an account, or rely on your phone’s built-in emergency features, which keep data on-device.
Also, remember that these apps are not substitutes for calling 911 in an emergency. If you see a crime in progress, call emergency services first. Apps can supplement, not replace, official response.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Citizen free?
Yes, the basic Citizen app is free to download and use. It includes real-time alerts and a map of incidents. The premium tier, Citizen Plus, costs about $20 per month and adds features like 24/7 safety agents and location sharing with trusted contacts.
What is the best Citizen alternative?
There is no single “best” alternative—it depends on your needs. For community-based crime alerts, Neighbors is the closest free option. For personal safety, Noonlight or bSafe are strong choices. For official emergency alerts, use your phone’s built-in WEA system.
Does Citizen work outside the US?
Citizen is available in the US, UK, Canada, and Australia, but coverage varies by city. In other countries, you may not receive alerts. Alternatives like Neighbors are more widely available, but still primarily in North America and Europe.
Can I use Citizen without giving my location?
No, Citizen requires location access to send relevant alerts. If you deny location permission, the app will not work. If you are concerned about privacy, consider using a scanner app that does not require location or an account.
Are Citizen alerts always accurate?
No. Citizen relies on user reports and scanner audio, which can be inaccurate or delayed. Always verify information from official sources before acting. False alarms are common, especially in dense urban areas.
What should I do if I get too many alerts?
You can adjust notification settings in the Citizen app to only receive alerts for certain types of incidents or a smaller radius. Alternatively, switch to a less noisy app like Neighbors, which allows you to mute non-urgent posts.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Reliable Subaru vs New Honda Civic Cost
- Pokemon Bookmark Corner Designs & Pokemon GO DIY
- Forgotten Games That Created Your Favorite Genres
- Lexus vs Genesis Luxurious Compact SUV0.075 hp/lb
- Uber VW Robotaxi LA Launch Date
- Notebook vs Tablet: Which Saves You More Money?