keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Leaving Samsung: Escape Upgrade Treadmill & Tracking

Card No. 06·75760 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

Total cost over cycle 1,500.00 USD
Average yearly cost
500.00 USD/year
Result
Phone upgrade cycle
3 years
You entered
Annual cost of phone
400 USD
You entered
You enter
Phone upgrade cycle, Annual cost of phone, Annual subscription cost
You get
Total cost over cycle, Average yearly cost
Rounding
2 dp

Yes, you can escape the upgrade treadmill and much of the tracking by leaving Samsung, but the degree of escape depends entirely on which phone you switch to and how you configure it. Moving to a phone with longer software support (like Apple or Google Pixel) reduces upgrade pressure, while switching to a de-Googled Android ROM or a minimalist phone (like Light Phone) eliminates most tracking. This article explains the practical differences, what you gain, what you lose, and how to make the switch without breaking your workflow.

Formula

The calculator above estimates the total cost of owning a phone over a given upgrade cycle. The formula is:

Total cost = (annual phone cost × upgrade cycle years) + (annual subscription cost × upgrade cycle years)

Where:

  • Phone upgrade cycle (t) – how many years you keep the same phone (typically 2–4 for Samsung, 3–5 for Pixel/iPhone).
  • Annual cost of phone (c) – the upfront price divided by the number of years you keep it (e.g., $800 phone over 3 years = $267/year).
  • Annual subscription cost (s) – any ongoing fees for cloud storage, insurance, or services you pay per year.

The result is the total out-of-pocket cost over the cycle, and the average yearly cost. This helps you compare the real financial difference between upgrading every 2 years versus keeping a phone for 4–5 years.

Worked Example

Using the default values: upgrade cycle = 3 years, annual phone cost = $400, annual subscription = $100.

  1. Phone cost over 3 years: $400 × 3 = $1,200
  2. Subscription cost over 3 years: $100 × 3 = $300
  3. Total cost = $1,200 + $300 = $1,500
  4. Average yearly cost = $1,500 / 3 = $500/year

If you instead kept the phone 5 years (with the same annual costs), the total would be $2,500, but the yearly average drops to $500 – same yearly cost, but you avoid the hassle of switching and the environmental impact of a new device.

Why Samsung Feels Like a Treadmill

Samsung’s flagship phones (Galaxy S series, Z Fold/Flip) receive about 4 years of major Android updates and 5 years of security patches. In practice, many users feel pressure to upgrade after 2–3 years because:

  • Battery degradation becomes noticeable (typically after 500–800 charge cycles).
  • New features (like Galaxy AI) are only available on newer models or require the latest One UI.
  • Trade-in promotions are heavily marketed, making an upgrade seem cheaper than it is.
  • Carrier financing plans tie you to a 24–36 month payment, after which you’re nudged to “upgrade” again.

In contrast, Apple and Google now offer 7 years of software updates for their latest phones (iPhone 15 and Pixel 8 onward). That alone can double the useful life of a phone, cutting the upgrade treadmill in half.

What Tracking Does Samsung Actually Do?

Samsung phones collect data through several layers:

  • Samsung Account – syncs contacts, calendar, notes, and usage data to Samsung’s cloud.
  • Telemetry – sends diagnostic and usage data to Samsung (you can opt out in Settings > Privacy).
  • Pre-installed apps – many come with ads (e.g., Samsung Health, Samsung Pay, and even the Weather app) and share data with ad partners.
  • Google services – since Samsung runs Android, Google Play Services also track your location, search history, and app usage unless you disable them.

You can reduce tracking on a Samsung phone by: turning off “Customization Service,” disabling “Marketing Information,” using a private DNS, and uninstalling or disabling bloatware. However, you cannot fully remove Google tracking without replacing the operating system.

Real Alternatives: What Actually Reduces Tracking?

If your goal is to minimize both upgrade pressure and tracking, consider these paths:

  • Apple iPhone – 7 years of updates, strong privacy defaults (App Tracking Transparency), but still tracks you via Apple ID and iCloud (though Apple claims less data for ads).
  • Google Pixel – 7 years of updates, but Google is the largest ad tracker; you must turn off “Ads Personalization” and limit location history.
  • De-Googled Android (e.g., LineageOS, GrapheneOS) – removes Google Play Services entirely. You lose access to some apps (banking, Google Pay) but gain near-total control over tracking. Requires technical comfort.
  • Light Phone or Punkt – minimalist phones with no app store, no tracking, and very long battery life. But they are not full smartphones; you lose maps, messaging apps, and mobile payments.

Each option has trade-offs. The iPhone is the easiest switch for most people; a de-Googled phone is the most radical but requires learning a new ecosystem.

How to Switch Without Losing Your Data

Moving from Samsung to another phone is straightforward, but you need to plan:

  1. Back up your Samsung phone – Use Samsung Smart Switch to export contacts, photos, and messages to a computer or external drive.
  2. Transfer photos and files – Use Google Photos (if you’re okay with Google) or a USB cable to copy files to your computer.
  3. Export passwords – Use a password manager (like Bitwarden) and export your vault before switching.
  4. Disable iMessage/FaceTime if you’re moving to Android – otherwise you may miss texts from iPhone users.
  5. Set up the new phone – Use the native transfer tool (Apple’s Move to iOS, or Google’s Switch to Android) to move contacts and calendars.
  6. Turn off tracking on the new phone – On iPhone: Settings > Privacy > Tracking > disable. On Pixel: Settings > Privacy > Ads > delete advertising ID.

Common Mistakes and Misconceptions

“All Android phones are the same.” Not true – Samsung adds its own tracking layer on top of Google’s. A Pixel with a custom ROM has far less tracking than a stock Samsung.

“De-Googling is illegal or voids warranty.” It’s legal, but it does void your warranty and may break SafetyNet (banking apps, Google Pay).

“Keeping a phone longer is always cheaper.” Not necessarily, if you factor in battery replacement costs and lost productivity from a slow device. But for most users, keeping a phone 4–5 years is cheaper than upgrading every 2.

“You can’t escape tracking completely.” True – even a Light Phone connects to a carrier that logs your calls. But you can reduce it to a level that feels acceptable.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will I lose Samsung-exclusive features like DeX or Samsung Pay?

Yes. If you switch to a non-Samsung phone, you lose Samsung DeX (desktop mode), Samsung Pay (though you can use Google Pay), and some camera features like Single Take. You also lose Samsung’s One UI skin, which some users prefer for its customization.

Can I install a custom ROM on a Samsung phone to remove tracking?

Yes, but it’s difficult. Samsung phones have locked bootloaders in the US and Canada, and installing a custom ROM (like LineageOS) will trip Knox, permanently voiding warranty and breaking Samsung Pay and Secure Folder. It’s easier on a Pixel or a phone with an unlocked bootloader.

Does Apple track me too?

Apple collects data, but it’s far less than Google/Samsung. Apple’s business model is selling hardware, not ads. However, Apple still tracks your App Store searches, iCloud usage, and location (for Find My). You can limit this in Settings > Privacy > Location Services.

What is the cheapest way to escape the upgrade treadmill?

Buy a mid-range phone (like a Pixel 8a or an iPhone SE) and keep it for 4–5 years. These phones get the same software updates as flagships but cost half as much. Avoid carrier financing – buy unlocked.

Is it worth switching to a Light Phone?

Only if you are willing to give up most smartphone functions. The Light Phone II has no camera, no maps, and no app store. It’s excellent for reducing screen time and tracking, but you’ll need a separate device for navigation and photos.

Related

Formula used
in t | Phone upgrade cycle | years | 3 | 1 | 10
in c | Annual cost of phone | USD | 400 | 0 | 2000
in s | Annual subscription cost | USD | 100 | 0 | 2000
out total | Total cost over cycle | USD | c * t + s * t | 2
out yearly | Average yearly cost | USD/year | c + s | 2

Each line is one input (in, sel, list) or one result (out: label, unit, formula, decimals). How the calculators work

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →