keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Enable Save As in OS X Mountain Lion

Card No. 06·85737 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

If you upgraded to OS X Mountain Lion and wondered where the “Save As” command went, you are not alone. Apple removed it from the File menu in most apps, replacing it with the new “Duplicate” and “Rename” workflow. You can restore the familiar Save As option by holding the Option key while clicking the File menu, or by re-enabling it in System Preferences for apps that still support it. This article explains exactly how both methods work, why Apple made the change, and what to do when an app still won’t show Save As.

Why Apple Removed Save As

Mountain Lion (OS X 10.8) introduced a new document model based on versions and auto-save, borrowed from iOS. Apple’s intent was to make saving invisible: your work is saved continuously, and you never have to think about it. In this model, the old Save As—which creates a new file and switches to it—was seen as redundant. Instead, Apple offered Duplicate (which creates a copy and switches to it) plus Rename, and the Save command was replaced by a “save on close” behavior in many apps.

The change confused many long-time Mac users, because Save As was a fundamental part of the Mac workflow since the original Macintosh. Apple did provide a hidden way to get it back, but it was not obvious and not every app honors it.

Method 1: The Option Key Trick (Works in Most Apps)

In most Cocoa-based apps (the standard Apple apps like TextEdit, Pages, Numbers, and many third-party apps), you can reveal the classic Save As command by holding down the Option key while opening the File menu. Here’s how:

  1. Open any document in an app like TextEdit or Pages.
  2. Press and hold the Option key on your keyboard.
  3. Click the File menu in the menu bar at the top of the screen.
  4. You will see Save As… appear in the menu, usually just below the regular Save command (which may be labeled “Save a Version” or “Save…”).
  5. Release the Option key and click Save As… to use it.

This works because Apple kept the keyboard shortcut Shift-Command-S (⇧⌘S) assigned to Save As in many apps, and the Option key reveals the hidden menu item. If you prefer using the keyboard, just press Shift-Command-S and the Save As sheet will appear immediately, without needing to touch the File menu.

Method 2: Re-enable Save As in System Preferences

For a more permanent fix, Apple added a setting in System Preferences that brings back the Save As command in the File menu for apps that support it. This setting is off by default in Mountain Lion. To turn it on:

  1. Open System Preferences from the Apple menu (or the Dock).
  2. Click General (the first row, with the gray gear icon).
  3. Look for the checkbox labeled “Show Save As command in File menu” (exact wording may vary slightly).
  4. Check the box.

After this, most Apple apps and many third-party apps will show Save As in the File menu without requiring the Option key. Note that this setting does not affect apps that were rewritten to use the new document model exclusively, such as some apps that use the modern NSDocument API with autosave enabled by default.

What to Do When Save As Still Doesn’t Appear

If you’ve enabled the System Preferences setting and the Option key trick doesn’t work, the app you’re using may have been updated to the new document model where Save As is genuinely removed. In that case, you have a few alternatives:

  • Use Duplicate + Rename: Choose File > Duplicate (or press Shift-Command-S in some apps), then use File > Rename to give the copy a new name. This achieves the same result as Save As: you end up with a new file with a different name.
  • Export a copy: Many apps offer File > Export or Share > Export, which lets you save a copy in a specific format. This is often the intended replacement for Save As in apps like Preview or iPhoto.
  • Copy the file manually: In the Finder, select the file, press Command-D to duplicate it, then rename the copy. This works for any file, regardless of the app.

If you are using a third-party app that still has the old Save As, but the Option key doesn’t reveal it, check the app’s preferences or its documentation—some apps have their own settings to re-enable the classic command.

Understanding the New Document Model

Mountain Lion’s changes are part of a broader shift toward a file system that is more like a database than a traditional folder structure. The new model includes:

  • Auto-save: Your work is saved automatically as you type, so you don’t lose data if the app crashes or you close a window accidentally.
  • Versions: The system keeps a history of changes, so you can browse or revert to earlier drafts.
  • Duplicate: Creates a copy of the current document and switches to it, leaving the original untouched.
  • Rename: Lets you change the file name without creating a copy.

In this model, the concept of “Save” is less important because you never have to manually save. The downside is that the old Save As workflow—where you create a new file and continue working in it—is not directly supported. The Duplicate command does exactly that, but it doesn’t ask for a name until you use Rename, which feels different.

Common Problems and Misconceptions

Many users think that the Option key trick is broken because they try it in an app that doesn’t support it. Here are some common issues and clarifications:

  • The Option key doesn’t work in all apps. It works in apps that use the standard Cocoa text system, but not in apps that are “sandboxed” or use a different framework. For example, some apps from the Mac App Store may not show Save As even with the Option key.
  • Shift-Command-S might be Duplicate. In some apps, the keyboard shortcut for Save As was reassigned to Duplicate. If you press Shift-Command-S and get a Duplicate, then the app has fully adopted the new model.
  • The System Preferences checkbox is not in all versions of OS X. This setting appeared in Mountain Lion, but was removed in later versions of macOS (starting with Mavericks or Yosemite). So if you are on a newer system, you won’t find it.
  • Save As is not the same as Export. Export creates a copy in a different format, but it doesn’t switch the app to that new file. Save As switches to the new file, so subsequent edits go to the new file.

Alternatives to Save As in Mountain Lion

If you need to create a new file from an existing one and continue working in it, here are the most reliable methods:

  1. Use Duplicate: Go to File > Duplicate (or press Shift-Command-S if it’s assigned). This creates a copy and switches to it. Then use File > Rename (or click the file name in the title bar) to give it a new name.
  2. Use Export: If you need a specific file format (like PDF or JPEG), use File > Export and choose the format. The original file remains open, and the exported copy is saved to the location you choose.
  3. Use the Finder: Duplicate the file in the Finder (select it, press Command-D), then rename the copy. Open the copy and work on it. This works for any file, regardless of the app.

These methods achieve the same end result as Save As, but they require a few extra clicks. Once you get used to them, they become second nature.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is Save As missing from the File menu?

Apple removed it in Mountain Lion to promote the new auto-save and versions system. The command is hidden by default, but you can reveal it with the Option key or by enabling the setting in System Preferences.

Does the Option key trick work in every app?

No. It works in most Apple apps and many third-party apps that use the standard Cocoa frameworks. Apps that have been fully updated to the new document model may not show Save As even with the Option key.

Can I get the old Save As back permanently?

Yes, for apps that support it. Go to System Preferences > General and check “Show Save As command in File menu.” This will make Save As appear in the File menu without holding Option. However, this setting is not available in later versions of macOS, and it doesn’t affect apps that don’t support the old command.

What is the keyboard shortcut for Save As in Mountain Lion?

The traditional shortcut is Shift-Command-S (⇧⌘S). In many apps, this still works even if the menu item is hidden. In some apps, it may be reassigned to Duplicate, so test it to see what it does.

Is there a way to make Save As the default instead of Duplicate?

No, there is no system-wide setting to replace Duplicate with Save As. The only way is to use the Option key or the System Preferences checkbox, and only in apps that support it. For apps that don’t, you’ll need to use Duplicate and Rename.

Does enabling the System Preferences checkbox affect performance?

No, it only adds a menu item. It doesn’t change the way documents are saved or how auto-save works. It’s purely a user interface change.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →