Yes, EU regulators approved Google’s acquisition of Fitbit on December 17, 2020, but only after Google made binding commitments to protect user health data and prevent anti-competitive use of Fitbit’s data. The European Commission, the EU’s antitrust authority, cleared the deal under the EU Merger Regulation, subject to conditions that last for ten years.
Background: Why the Deal Raised Red Flags
Google announced its plan to acquire Fitbit in November 2019 for $2.1 billion. The deal immediately drew scrutiny because Fitbit is one of the leading makers of wearable fitness trackers, and Google already operates the dominant mobile operating system (Android) and a massive digital advertising business. The key concern was that Google could use Fitbit’s health and location data to strengthen its advertising profiles, giving it an unfair advantage over rivals in both the wearable device market and the digital advertising market.
The European Commission opened an in-depth investigation in August 2020. It focused on two main areas: whether the merger would let Google use Fitbit data to improve its ad targeting, and whether Google could restrict rivals’ access to Fitbit’s wearable technology, such as its operating system and APIs.
How the EU Review Process Works
The European Commission is the EU’s competition authority. It reviews large mergers under the EU Merger Regulation to ensure they do not significantly reduce competition in the European Economic Area. The process has two phases:
- Phase 1: A preliminary review lasting up to 25 working days. If concerns arise, the Commission can move to Phase 2.
- Phase 2: A deeper investigation lasting up to 90 working days, where the Commission can issue a Statement of Objections and negotiate remedies.
In the Google/Fitbit case, the Commission went to Phase 2. It sent a Statement of Objections in October 2020, outlining its preliminary concerns. Google then offered commitments to address those concerns, which the Commission market-tested with competitors and customers before accepting.
The Commitments: What Google Had to Promise
To win approval, Google made legally binding commitments for a ten-year period. The European Commission’s decision was based on these promises:
- No use of Fitbit health data for ads: Google committed not to use Fitbit’s health and wellness data (such as heart rate, sleep patterns, and exercise logs) for Google Ads or any other advertising purposes. This data would be kept separately in a “data silo.”
- No combining with Google data: Google cannot combine Fitbit data with other Google data (like search, maps, or YouTube) unless users give explicit consent.
- Access for rivals: Google must continue to allow third-party apps and services to access Fitbit’s APIs and the Android Wear OS platform, ensuring competitors can still interoperate with Fitbit devices.
- No degradation of rival wearables: Google cannot restrict or degrade the functionality of rival wearable devices that connect to Android phones.
- No use of Fitbit data to disadvantage rivals: Google cannot use Fitbit’s data to gain an unfair advantage in the wearable market, such as by improving its own services while withholding data from competitors.
These commitments are monitored by a trustee and can be extended if necessary. The European Commission can fine Google up to 10% of its global turnover if it breaches them.
Why the EU Approved Despite Concerns
The European Commission concluded that, with the commitments, the merger would not significantly harm competition. The Commission found that Fitbit’s market share in wearables was not dominant enough to raise competition concerns on its own, and that the main risk was the data combination. Since Google agreed to keep health data separate and not use it for ads, the Commission decided the deal could proceed.
The decision was not unanimous in the tech world. Some privacy advocates and competitors, such as Sonos and the Austrian data protection authority, called for a full prohibition. However, the Commission’s legal test is about competition, not privacy. Privacy issues fall under data protection law (like GDPR), not merger law, so the Commission could only address privacy indirectly through competition concerns.
What Happened After Approval
Google completed the acquisition in January 2021, shortly after the EU approval. Since then, Google has integrated Fitbit into its hardware division. The company has continued to sell Fitbit devices, and in 2023 it launched the Fitbit Sense 2 and Versa 4. Google also introduced new features that require a Google account, which was a change from Fitbit’s previous standalone account system.
However, the EU’s commitments remain in force. In 2022, the European Commission sent Google a questionnaire asking for details on how it was implementing the data silo and other commitments. The Commission has not publicly reported any major violations as of 2024.
Common Misconceptions
Many people believe the EU “approved” the deal without conditions, or that Google can freely access Fitbit health data. Both are wrong. The approval was conditional, and the conditions are legally binding. Another misconception is that the EU rejected the deal because of privacy concerns. In reality, the EU’s review was about competition, and privacy was a secondary factor.
Another common question is whether the commitments apply to users outside the EU. The commitments are global in scope for the data silo and ad-use restrictions, but the interoperability commitments are primarily about the EEA market. Google has stated it will apply the data silo globally.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did the EU approve Google’s acquisition of Fitbit?
Yes, the European Commission approved the acquisition on December 17, 2020, with binding commitments. The approval was not unconditional; Google had to agree to keep Fitbit health data separate and not use it for advertising.
Why did the EU take so long to review the deal?
The deal was announced in November 2019, but the EU’s in-depth investigation ran from August to December 2020. The Commission needed time to gather evidence, send a Statement of Objections, and market-test Google’s proposed commitments. This is typical for large tech mergers with data implications.
Can Google use my Fitbit health data for ads now?
No. Under the EU commitments, Google cannot use Fitbit health and wellness data for Google Ads or any advertising purposes. This restriction is global and lasts for ten years. Users can also revoke consent for any data combination at any time.
What happens if Google violates the commitments?
The European Commission can fine Google up to 10% of its global annual turnover. The Commission can also reopen the merger review and potentially order divestiture if the violations are serious.
Does the EU approval affect Fitbit users in the US?
Google has said it will apply the data silo globally, so US users also benefit from the restriction on using Fitbit health data for ads. However, the EU commitments are specifically enforceable by the European Commission, so enforcement mechanisms differ.
Is the merger still under review?
No, the merger was cleared in 2020. However, the European Commission continues to monitor compliance with the commitments. In 2022, it sent a questionnaire to Google about implementation, which is a normal part of monitoring.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Infinity Essence in Sailor Piece: Farming and Uses
- Apollo.io Alternatives for Sales Prospecting
- Deploy AI Agents in a Service Desk With Human Oversight
- AIM and Yahoo Profiles: When Did You Last Look?
- Best Smartwatch Under ₹5,000 in India: What to Buy
- Chat History vs Saved Memory in AI Assistants