The Game of Thrones books and the HBO TV series share the same broad story—a struggle for the Iron Throne amid looming supernatural threats—but they diverge significantly in plot, character, and depth. The books (starting with A Game of Thrones, 1996) are far more expansive, with intricate subplots and a large cast, while the show compresses and alters events, especially after the source material ran out. Below are the major differences, explained clearly for anyone curious about both versions.
Why the Books and Show Differ
George R.R. Martin began writing A Song of Ice and Fire in the early 1990s, planning a trilogy that eventually expanded to seven planned novels (five published so far). The HBO adaptation, which ran from 2011 to 2019, was developed by David Benioff and D.B. Weiss. The show had to condense thousands of pages into roughly 10 episodes per season. This forced the writers to cut, merge, and streamline characters and plots. Additionally, the show caught up to the books by season 5 (the books were still on A Dance with Dragons, published 2011), and from season 6 onward, the show moved beyond the published material, using Martin’s outline but filling in details with original writing. This is why the later seasons diverge most dramatically from the books.
Character Age and Physical Differences
One of the most obvious differences is the age of the characters. In the books, the Stark children are very young: Jon Snow is 14 at the start, Daenerys is 13, Robb is 15, Arya is 9, and Bran is 7. The show aged them up to make the story more palatable for television and to avoid child-actor restrictions. This aging changes how you perceive events—Daenerys’s marriage to Khal Drogo is horrifying in the book because she is a child, while in the show she is a teenager. Also, in the books, Tyrion is described as extremely ugly, with a scarred face and a missing nose after the Battle of the Blackwater, whereas Peter Dinklage’s Tyrion remains relatively handsome. Similarly, Tormund is older and more grizzled in the books, and Daario Naharis has a blue beard and gold mustache, which the show simplified.
Major Plotlines Cut or Altered
The show cut many subplots entirely. For example:
- Lady Stoneheart – In the books, Catelyn Stark is resurrected by Beric Dondarrion as a vengeful, zombie-like figure called Lady Stoneheart. She leads the Brotherhood Without Banners and hangs Freys. The show omitted this entirely.
- Young Griff (Aegon Targaryen) – A major book character who claims to be Rhaegar’s son and invades Westeros with the Golden Company. He does not exist in the show.
- Quentyn Martell – In the books, Quentyn travels to Meereen to marry Daenerys and is killed by a dragon. The show replaced him with a different Dorne plot.
- The Iron Islands succession – The show simplified the kingsmoot and removed the character of Victarion Greyjoy, who plays a large role in the books.
- Dorne – The book’s Dorne plot is complex, with Arianne Martell scheming to crown Myrcella. The show turned it into a simple revenge plot, killing off several Sand Snakes.
Some storylines were also merged. For instance, the character of Sansa Stark in the show takes over the role of Jeyne Poole from the books, who is forced to marry Ramsay Bolton. This change significantly alters Sansa’s arc and the dynamics of her relationship with Theon.
Character Development and Motivations
Several characters have deeper or different motivations in the books. For example:
- Jaime Lannister – In the books, Jaime’s arc is more nuanced. He stays in the Riverlands and has a complex relationship with Brienne, and his break from Cersei is more gradual. In the show, he leaves Cersei earlier and then returns to her in the final season, a decision many found inconsistent with his book counterpart.
- Euron Greyjoy – The book Euron is a terrifying, mystical figure who claims to have sailed to Valyria and possesses a dragon-binding horn. The show’s Euron is a crude, lecherous pirate who is easily defeated.
- Bran Stark – In the books, Bran’s training with the Three-Eyed Raven is more mystical and involves greenseeing and warging. The show reduces this to a few visions, and his final role as king feels less earned.
- Daenerys – The show’s Daenerys is more decisive and ruthless from early on, while the book Daenerys is more hesitant and often questions her own actions. The show’s turn to madness in season 8 is seen by many as abrupt, whereas the books show a slower, more conflicted process.
Magic and Supernatural Elements
The books include more overt magic and prophecy. For instance:
- Wargs and skinchangers – In the books, many Stark children are wargs (Arya wargs into a cat, Bran wargs into Hodor), and this is a central part of their identity. The show only briefly touches on this.
- The Others (White Walkers) – The books give the Others a language and a culture, and they are more mysterious. The show depicts them as simple ice zombies.
- Prophecies – The books are full of prophecies, like the Azor Ahai prophecy and the “Prince That Was Promised.” The show simplifies or omits many of these.
- Resurrection – Jon Snow’s resurrection in the books is more ambiguous; he may be warged into Ghost, and his revival is not shown directly. The show shows a straightforward resurrection.
Endings and Future Books
The show’s ending (season 8) is controversial: Bran becomes king, Daenerys is killed by Jon, and the Seven Kingdoms become an elective monarchy. The books have not yet reached that point. Martin has stated that the ending will be “bittersweet” but has also said that the show’s ending is not the same as his book ending. Many fans expect the books to have a different conclusion, with more nuance and fewer plot conveniences. For example, in the books, Jon’s parentage (Rhaegar and Lyanna) is confirmed through a vision, but the political implications are more complex. The show’s “King Bran” ending was reportedly based on Martin’s outline, but the execution may differ.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I read the books or watch the show first?
It depends on your preference. Reading first gives you the full depth and detail, but you may be disappointed by the show’s simplifications. Watching first makes the show easier to follow, but you will miss many subplots and character nuances. Many fans recommend reading the books first, then watching the show to see a different interpretation.
Are the books finished?
No. Five novels are published: A Game of Thrones (1996), A Clash of Kings (1998), A Storm of Swords (2000), A Feast for Crows (2005), and A Dance with Dragons (2011). Two more are planned: The Winds of Winter and A Dream of Spring. Neither has a release date.
Which book corresponds to which TV season?
The first three books roughly align with the first three seasons, but from season 4 onward, the show starts mixing elements from later books. Season 5 covers parts of A Feast for Crows and A Dance with Dragons, and seasons 6-8 are mostly original content with some plot points from Martin’s outline.
Why did the show change so much after season 4?
Because the show ran out of published source material. After season 4, the showrunners had to create their own story based on Martin’s broad outline. This led to faster pacing, simplified plots, and different character arcs.
Are the books better than the show?
Most readers consider the books superior in depth, complexity, and character development. However, the show has its own strengths, such as visual storytelling, memorable performances, and a tighter narrative. It’s a matter of personal taste.
What is the biggest difference between the books and show?
The biggest difference is the level of detail and the handling of characters. The books have dozens of POV chapters, allowing deep insight into many characters. The show focuses on a smaller set of main characters and often simplifies their motivations. Also, the books are darker and more morally ambiguous, with fewer clear heroes and villains.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Arctic Sea Ice Forecasts Disagree: What to Do
- MySQL Workbench to VPS: SSH Tunnel Setup
- Bluesky Beginners Guide: How to Get Started5.00 min/km
- LG V20 Won’t Turn On? Fixed
- Snagit vs Camtasia: Which One Do You Need?
- Scale a Small Business Without Losing Culture