If you love the idea of Elden Ring’s vast open world, deep lore, and sense of discovery but find its brutal difficulty and constant punishment off-putting, there are several games that offer a similar experience with a much gentler learning curve. This article lists the best alternatives that capture the same exploration and combat spirit without demanding perfection from the player.
What Makes Elden Ring Hard and What “Gentler” Means
Elden Ring is famous for its high difficulty: enemies deal heavy damage, bosses have complex attack patterns, and death sends you back to the last Site of Grace, often losing your collected runes. The game gives you tools to make it easier—spirit summons, over-leveling, and powerful builds—but it never holds your hand. A “gentler” game in this context usually means one that offers adjustable difficulty, more forgiving checkpoints, clearer guidance, or a lower baseline challenge while still providing a satisfying sense of exploration and combat.
Top Games That Offer a Similar Feel with Less Punishment
Here are the best-known titles that evoke Elden Ring’s atmosphere and structure but are more accessible:
- Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order and Jedi: Survivor – These action-adventure games feature a large interconnected map, melee combat with a focus on dodging and parrying, and a story-driven campaign. They have a difficulty slider that goes from “Story Mode” (very easy) to “Jedi Grand Master” (hard), so you can tailor the challenge. Checkpoints are frequent, and death simply reloads you a short distance back.
- Assassin’s Creed Odyssey and Valhalla – While not melee-focused in the same way, these open-world RPGs have a massive map, skill trees, gear customization, and a combat system that rewards timing. They feature an exploration mode and a difficulty setting, and you can easily over-level to trivialize most fights. The world is dense with secrets and lore, similar to the Lands Between.
- Horizon Zero Dawn and Horizon Forbidden West – These games offer a beautiful open world with a strong narrative and combat that involves targeting weak points on robotic creatures. They have multiple difficulty levels, including a “Story” mode that makes combat very forgiving. The sense of discovery and uncovering ancient mysteries is comparable to Elden Ring’s lore, but the gameplay is far more guided.
- The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt – A classic open-world RPG with a rich story, meaningful choices, and a world full of side quests and monsters. Combat is more straightforward, and you can adjust the difficulty at any time. The game also has a “Just the Story” difficulty for those who want to focus on exploration and narrative.
- Darksiders III – Often described as a “Souls-lite,” this game has a similar combat rhythm (dodge, attack, heal) but is generally more forgiving. It has a classic difficulty setting, and while it has some challenging bosses, it doesn’t punish death as harshly. The world is interconnected and full of secrets.
How These Games Compare to Elden Ring’s Core Loop
Elden Ring’s core loop is: explore, find a dungeon or boss, die repeatedly, learn patterns, eventually succeed, and feel a rush of accomplishment. Gentler alternatives keep the exploration and progression but soften the failure penalty. For example, in Jedi: Fallen Order, you still have a “bonfire” system (Meditation Points) where you rest to heal and level up, but enemies don’t respawn as aggressively, and your XP is never lost on death—you just lose a small amount of progress toward your next skill point. In Horizon, death simply reloads your last save, which is usually a few minutes back. The key difference is that these games don’t require you to memorize intricate attack patterns for hours; a casual player can progress by being reasonably careful.
How to Choose the Right One for You
Consider what specifically draws you to Elden Ring:
- If you love the medieval dark fantasy setting – Try Darksiders III (more linear) or The Witcher 3 (more story-driven).
- If you want sci-fi with lightsabers and force powers – The Jedi series is the closest match in terms of melee combat and exploration.
- If you prefer ranged combat and robot dinosaurs – Horizon games are perfect, with a strong emphasis on strategy over reflexes.
- If you want a huge, historically-inspired world with naval combat – Assassin’s Creed Odyssey is your best bet.
Common Misconceptions About “Easy” Souls-likes
Many players assume that a gentler game means no challenge at all, but that’s not true. Games like Jedi: Fallen Order on normal difficulty still require you to learn enemy timings and manage your health. The difference is that you have more margin for error: you can take a few hits before dying, and you have more healing items. Also, these games often have a more forgiving camera and lock-on system, which is a major source of frustration in Elden Ring. Another misconception is that “easy mode” ruins the game’s integrity—but many of these games are designed to be played at any difficulty, and the story and world remain fully intact.
What to Do If You Still Find These Too Hard
If you try one of these and still feel overwhelmed, there are several strategies:
- Lower the difficulty – There’s no shame in playing on Story mode. The game is there to be enjoyed.
- Over-level – In RPGs like Assassin’s Creed or The Witcher, doing side quests will make you stronger, making main story fights easier.
- Use guides – Unlike Elden Ring, these games have active wikis and map guides that show you where to go and what to do, removing the frustration of getting lost.
- Watch a walkthrough – Sometimes seeing a boss fight done correctly helps you learn the pattern faster.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is there a game with Elden Ring’s exact combat but easier?
No game replicates Elden Ring’s combat perfectly, but Jedi: Fallen Order and Darksiders III come closest. They both feature a dodge-roll, light and heavy attacks, and a stamina bar, but with more forgiving timing and less punishing enemy damage.
Can I play these games on PC or console?
Yes, all the games listed are available on PC, PlayStation, and Xbox (with the exception of some older titles that may not be on the latest consoles). Check the specific store page for each game to confirm availability on your system.
Do these games have a good story like Elden Ring?
Most of them have a much more direct and cinematic story than Elden Ring. The Witcher 3 and Horizon are praised for their narratives, while Jedi and Darksiders have solid but more straightforward plots.
Are there any free alternatives?
Free-to-play games like Genshin Impact offer a large open world and action combat, but with a gacha monetization system. It’s not exactly a Souls-like, but it’s gentle and free. Also, many of the games listed go on sale frequently, so you can often pick them up cheaply.
What if I want a game that’s gentle but still has a high skill ceiling?
You can play Jedi: Fallen Order on “Jedi Master” difficulty, which is challenging but still more forgiving than Elden Ring. Or you can play Assassin’s Creed Odyssey on “Nightmare” mode, which is tough but doesn’t punish death with resource loss.
Is there a way to make Elden Ring itself easier?
Yes, you can use spirit summons, over-level by farming runes, use ranged attacks, and equip the “Wondrous Physick” with the “Crimsonwhorl Bubbletear” to heal over time. Also, you can summon other players for co-op, which makes most bosses significantly easier.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Skip Ryobi and Milwaukee? Harbor Freight Tools to Buy
- Funny Subreddits That Make You Laugh
- Why Retro Gaming Is Still Worth Playing Today
- Neptune Facts That Will Blow Your Mind
- Survival Crafting Game Fatigue: Why & How to Fix It
- Sell Your EV Now Before Prices Plummet?