The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is best approached as a story-driven game with meaningful combat and rewarding exploration layered on top. If you must choose one pillar as the core, it is the story; however, the game is designed so that combat and exploration feed directly into narrative progression, and skipping either makes the experience noticeably poorer.
Formula
The calculator takes your self-rated interest in the three main pillars of The Witcher 3 — story, combat, and exploration — each on a 1–10 scale. The overall score is simply the sum of the three values (maximum 30). The balance indicator subtracts the absolute differences between adjacent pillars from 10; a higher balance means your preferences are more evenly spread across the three activities.
Variables:
- t – your interest in story and narrative (1–10)
- c – your interest in combat mechanics (1–10)
- e – your interest in exploration and world discovery (1–10)
The balance formula is: 10 - |t - c| - |c - e|. The maximum balance (10) occurs when all three values are equal. The minimum is not bounded below, but in practice it will be between -10 and 10.
Worked Example
Using the default values from the calculator (t=8, c=6, e=7):
- Overall score = 8 + 6 + 7 = 21
- Balance = 10 – |8-6| – |6-7| = 10 – 2 – 1 = 7
So with those inputs, you get an overall experience score of 21 out of 30, and a balance of 7, indicating a reasonably even mix with a slight tilt toward story.
Background: How The Witcher 3 Structures Its Gameplay
CD Projekt Red’s 2015 action RPG is often cited as a benchmark for open-world design. The game presents a vast continent with two main regions (Velen/Novigrad and Skellige) plus the smaller White Orchard and Kaer Morhen. The main questline is a linear narrative about finding Ciri, but the world is filled with dozens of side quests, monster contracts, and points of interest that are not required to finish the story.
The game’s combat is action-based: Geralt uses a steel sword for humans and a silver sword for monsters, along with five signs (magic) and a crossbow. Combat is skill-based but not as deep as dedicated action games like Dark Souls. Exploration is rewarded with gear, recipes, and lore, often through the game’s “?” markers on the map, which mark hidden treasures, monster nests, and abandoned sites.
The three pillars are interconnected. Many side quests have multiple solutions that depend on choices you make during dialogue, and those choices can affect the ending. Combat is often the means to resolve quests, but you can sometimes avoid fights through dialogue or stealth. Exploration yields resources that make combat easier and also uncovers story fragments that enrich the world.
How the Three Pillars Interact
In practice, you cannot fully separate the three. Consider the famous quest “The Bloody Baron.” It is a story-heavy quest with several branching outcomes, but it also involves combat against a botchling and a wraith. If you ignore combat upgrades, the fight can be frustrating; if you ignore the story, you miss the emotional weight of the choice. Similarly, exploration often leads to side quests that are themselves mini-stories, such as the “Towerful of Mice” quest, which is both a combat encounter and a narrative puzzle.
The game’s progression system also blurs the lines. You earn experience points (XP) from both quests and combat, but main quests give far more XP. Exploration gives you loot that can be sold or used to craft better gear, which in turn makes combat easier. The game’s difficulty settings also affect the balance: on higher difficulties, combat becomes more demanding, while on lower difficulties you can focus almost entirely on story and exploration.
How to Choose Your Focus
If you are new to the game, the best approach is to follow the main quest until you reach Velen (the first large area). By then, you will have a feel for the combat and the story. From there, you can decide how much to engage with side content. Here are some guidelines:
- Story-first players: Stick to main quests and the most prominent side quests (those with unique names and characters). You can ignore most “?” markers and still have a satisfying narrative experience.
- Combat-focused players: Play on a higher difficulty (Blood and Broken Bones or Death March) and seek out monster contracts and bandit camps. These provide tougher fights and better rewards. Crafting and alchemy become more important.
- Exploration enthusiasts: Turn off the minimap (or at least the question marks) and wander. The world is hand-crafted, and many locations have hidden stories. You will find plenty of loot and lore, but be prepared to backtrack to complete quests.
Most players naturally fall into a mix. A common recommendation is to do side quests that are at or near your level, as they give good XP and gear. Avoid over-leveling by doing too many low-level quests, as they will become trivial and less rewarding.
Common Problems and Misconceptions
One frequent complaint is that the combat feels “clunky” compared to other action RPGs. This is often because players try to button-mash. The game rewards dodging, parrying, and using the right sign for the right enemy. Another misconception is that exploration is pointless because the loot is random and often worse than what you can craft. While true for some chests, exploration also leads to unique gear sets (like the Witcher gear) and places of power that give ability points.
Another issue is the “overwhelming map” problem. The map is full of “?” markers, and many players feel compelled to clear them all, leading to burnout. The game does not require you to do this. You can safely ignore most of them and still finish the game. The markers are there for players who enjoy completionism, not as a mandatory checklist.
A common question is whether you can play the game without any combat mods or exploits. Yes, the game is beatable on any difficulty with careful play and preparation. On Death March, you need to use oils, potions, and signs effectively, but it is not as punishing as some other games.
Comparisons with Other Open-World RPGs
Compared to Skyrim, The Witcher 3 has a more linear main story but more complex moral choices. Skyrim offers more freedom in character builds and exploration, but its combat is often criticized as shallow. Horizon Zero Dawn has tighter combat and a more focused story, but less impactful choices. Red Dead Redemption 2 excels in story and immersion but has less RPG-style character progression. The Witcher 3 sits in a middle ground: it has a strong narrative, decent combat, and a world that rewards curiosity.
The two expansions, Hearts of Stone and Blood and Wine, are often praised as even better than the base game. Hearts of Stone is a compact, story-driven questline with a memorable villain, while Blood and Wine adds a whole new region with a lighter tone and more exploration. Both add new combat encounters and gear, so they are worth playing regardless of your focus.
Costs and Time Investment
The base game takes about 50-60 hours for a story-focused playthrough. If you do a significant number of side quests, that number jumps to 100+ hours. Completionists can spend 200+ hours. The game is often on sale, and the Game of the Year Edition (which includes both expansions) is frequently priced similarly to the base game. There is no monthly subscription or microtransaction; you pay once and get the full experience.
If you are short on time, you can still enjoy the main story in about 40 hours by skipping most side content. The game’s level scaling means you can rush the main quest without grinding, though you may struggle on higher difficulties if you skip too much.
Safety and Technical Considerations
This is a single-player game, so there are no online safety concerns. However, be aware that the game contains mature themes, violence, and sexual content, and it is rated M for Mature. If you are sensitive to these, you may want to adjust your settings or skip certain quests.
On PC, the game is well-optimized, but it can be demanding on older hardware. The next-gen update (released in 2022) added ray tracing and improved graphics, but it also increased system requirements. If you have a mid-range PC, you can lower settings to get a smooth experience. On consoles, the game runs well on PS4, Xbox One, PS5, and Xbox Series X/S, with performance modes available on newer consoles.
Save files can become large, especially if you explore a lot, so keep some free space. The game has an autosave feature, but it is wise to manually save before major decisions, as some choices have long-term consequences.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I play The Witcher 3 without doing any side quests?
Yes, you can complete the main story by focusing only on main quests. You will be under-leveled for some fights, but on lower difficulties it is manageable. However, you will miss out on a lot of context and some of the best content in the game.
Is the combat in The Witcher 3 really that bad?
No, it is functional but not exceptional. It takes time to learn the rhythm of dodging and using signs. Many players who dislike it initially come to appreciate it after a few hours. The game offers a tutorial area that teaches the basics, and you can adjust difficulty at any time.
What is the best way to level up quickly?
Main quests give the most XP. Side quests that are close to your level also give good XP. Grinding enemies gives very little XP, so it is not efficient. Focus on quests, and you will level naturally.
Should I explore everything or just follow the story?
It depends on your preference. The game is designed so that exploration is optional. If you enjoy getting lost and finding hidden gems, explore. If you prefer a tight narrative, stick to the story. You can always come back later to clear leftover markers.
Does the game have multiple endings?
Yes, there are three main endings and two epilogue variations, depending on choices you make throughout the game, especially in the final act. Some side quests also have their own endings. Your choices matter, so save before major decisions.
Is the Witcher 3 worth playing in 2025?
Absolutely. The game still holds up graphically (especially with the next-gen update), and its storytelling and world-building remain among the best in the genre. It is frequently cited as one of the greatest RPGs of all time, and it continues to attract new players.
Related
Formula used
in t | Story focus (1-10) | - | 8 | 1 | 10 in c | Combat focus (1-10) | - | 6 | 1 | 10 in e | Exploration focus (1-10) | - | 7 | 1 | 10 out total | Overall experience score | /30 | t + c + e | 0 out balance | Balance indicator | - | 10 - abs(t - c) - abs(c - e) | 0
Each line is one input (in, sel, list) or one result (out: label, unit, formula, decimals). How the calculators work
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Arctic Sea Ice Forecasts Disagree: What to Do
- MySQL Workbench to VPS: SSH Tunnel Setup
- Bluesky Beginners Guide: How to Get Started5.00 min/km
- LG V20 Won’t Turn On? Fixed
- Snagit vs Camtasia: Which One Do You Need?
- Scale a Small Business Without Losing Culture