Some games are so tied to their original moment, technology, or design philosophy that a remake would either betray what made them special or prove impossible to improve. This article explains which games fall into that category and why, based on the reasons that make a remake unnecessary, risky, or actively harmful to the original’s legacy.
What Makes a Game “Unremakeable”?
A game becomes a poor remake candidate when its core appeal depends on elements that cannot be reproduced or improved without changing the experience. The most common reasons are:
- Technical limitations as art: Games like Metal Gear Solid (1998) used the PlayStation’s fog and low-polygon models to create atmosphere and hide loading. A modern remake with crisp visuals removes that fog, changing the mood entirely.
- Unique control schemes: Katamari Damacy (2004) is built around the dual-stick roll mechanic. Remaking it for a single-stick or touch interface would either break the game or require a complete redesign.
- Licensed music and voice acting: Crazy Taxi (1999) had a soundtrack by The Offspring and Bad Religion. Re-releases had to remove those songs due to licensing, and a remake would likely face the same problem, losing part of the game’s identity.
- Cultural context: Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas (2004) is a satire of early-2000s American culture. A remake set in the present day would lose the specific references and tone that made it memorable.
The Problem with “Faithful” Remakes
Remakes often try to be faithful, but faithfulness itself creates a paradox. If you keep the original’s mechanics, controls, and level design, you are essentially making a high-resolution port. If you change them, you are making a new game that borrows the name. This is the core issue with games like Final Fantasy VII (1997) – the 2020 remake changed the battle system from turn-based to action, added new plot elements, and split the story into multiple parts. Many fans argued it was no longer the same game. The problem is not that the remake was bad; it is that it replaced the original in public discourse, making the original harder to experience on its own terms.
Games That Rely on Hardware Quirks
Some games were designed around the specific limitations or features of their original hardware. Remaking them for modern systems requires either emulating those quirks or abandoning them. Examples include:
- Silent Hill (1999) – the fog and darkness were used to hide the PlayStation’s draw distance. A modern remake with clear visuals removes the sense of dread.
- Super Mario 64 (1996) – the analog stick’s limited range was part of the challenge. Modern controllers are more precise, but the game’s level design assumes the old stick’s behavior.
- GoldenEye 007 (1997) – the dual-analog control scheme was not standard yet; the game used a single analog stick for movement and the C-buttons for looking. A remake would need to modernize the controls, which changes the feel completely.
When a Remake Is Actually a New Game
Some “remakes” are so different that they are effectively new titles using an old name. This can be fine, but it creates confusion about what the original was. For example, Resident Evil 2 (2019) is a masterful horror game, but it plays very differently from the 1998 original. The fixed camera angles and tank controls are gone, replaced by an over-the-shoulder view. The remake is a great game, but it does not allow new players to understand why the original was revolutionary. The same applies to Shadow of the Colossus (2018) – it is a graphical upgrade, but the controls and physics remain from 2005, which feels clunky to modern players. The remake is not bad, but it does not recreate the original’s impact.
How to Decide If a Game Should Be Remade
There is no universal rule, but a few questions help determine whether a remake is justified:
- Does the original have a flaw that a remake can fix without changing the core design? (e.g., Metroid: Zero Mission added a map and better controls to the original Metroid without altering the exploration formula.)
- Is the original’s technology so dated that it is unplayable for modern audiences? (e.g., Resident Evil (1996) – the fixed camera and tank controls are hard to master, but they are also part of the game’s identity.)
- Will the remake preserve the original’s story and themes? If the remake changes the plot, it is not a remake; it is a reimagining.
- Does the original still have an active community? If yes, a remake may split the fanbase.
Alternatives to Remakes
Instead of remaking a classic, developers have several options that preserve the original:
- Remasters: Upgrading resolution, textures, and frame rate while keeping the same code and gameplay. This is the safest option, as seen with Halo: Combat Evolved Anniversary (2011).
- Re-releases with quality-of-life options: Adding a map, save anywhere, or control remapping, but leaving the core game untouched.
- Spiritual successors: Creating a new game that explores similar themes or mechanics without using the old name. Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night (2019) is a spiritual successor to Castlevania: Symphony of the Night (1997).
- Preservation: Keeping the original playable on modern systems through emulation or official ports.
Common Problems with Remakes
Even when a remake is well-made, it often faces criticism:
- Lost atmosphere: Modern graphics can make a game look better but feel less immersive. The original Silent Hill used fog to hide loading; the remake would need to add fog artificially, which looks odd.
- Changed voice acting: Recasting characters can alienate fans. The Resident Evil 3 remake (2020) changed Jill Valentine’s voice actor, and many fans felt the new performance lacked the original’s charm.
- Expanded content that dilutes pacing: Adding side quests and open-world elements to a linear game can ruin the rhythm. The Final Fantasy VII remake added hours of filler, which some players found tedious.
- Difficulty balancing: Old games were often brutally hard due to limited continues. A remake that makes the game easier may be more accessible, but it removes the sense of achievement.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do people want remakes of games that are already good?
Nostalgia is a powerful motivator. Players want to revisit a beloved world with modern graphics and controls. However, the original game’s design is often tied to its era, and changing it can ruin the experience. A remake is not a replacement; it is a new interpretation.
Are remasters better than remakes?
For preserving the original experience, yes. A remaster keeps the gameplay and story intact, only improving technical aspects like resolution and frame rate. A remake changes the game, which can be good or bad, but it is not the same game. If you want to play the original, a remaster is the safer choice.
Can a remake ever be better than the original?
Yes, but it requires the developers to understand what made the original special and then improve on it without losing that essence. Resident Evil 2 (2019) is often cited as a remake that surpassed the original in terms of horror and pacing, but it still changed the gameplay significantly. The key is that the remake must stand on its own, not just be a graphical update.
Why don’t developers just re-release the original with modern controls?
Some do, but it is not always possible. The original code may be lost, or the hardware-specific features (like the N64’s controller) are hard to emulate. Also, marketing a re-release is harder than marketing a new game. A remake generates more hype and sales, even if it is riskier.
What is the difference between a remake and a reimagining?
A remake typically follows the same story and structure, updating graphics and controls. A reimagining takes the core concept and creates a new story or gameplay. For example, Final Fantasy VII Remake is a reimagining because it changes the plot and battle system. A true remake would be closer to the original, like Crash Bandicoot N. Sane Trilogy (2017), which is a remaster with improved graphics but the same levels and physics.
Are there any games that should be remade?
Yes, but they are usually games with a good concept but poor execution due to technical limitations. For example, Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic (2003) has a great story but dated combat. A remake could improve the combat without changing the narrative. However, even this is risky, as the original’s charm comes from its writing, not its mechanics.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Why Wait for Galaxy S25 Ultra? Key Reasons
- Incognito Mode: Why You Should Browse With It More
- General Motors EVs: Models You Should Know
- Ecovacs Deebot N30 Family: Models, Features, and Buying Guide
- Resident Evil 9: What I Want and Don’t Want From It
- LibreOffice Finally Got the Feature That Makes It Easier to Recommend