Some games hide their true ending, extra chapters, or final credits behind a second (or third) playthrough. This article lists the main types of games that require multiple completions, explains why developers do it, and gives concrete examples you can check yourself.
Why Some Games Force a Second Playthrough
Developers add multiple playthroughs for several reasons. The most common is to unlock the “true” ending after you have seen the normal one. Another is to let you carry over your character or items into a harder difficulty, which changes the story or adds new bosses. Some games simply have branching paths that are impossible to see in one run, so you must replay to experience every branch.
This design is not new. Arcade games from the 1980s often loop endlessly, but the first widely known “beat it twice” title is probably The Legend of Zelda (1986), which added a second quest after you finished the first. Since then, many genres have adopted the idea, from visual novels to action RPGs.
New Game+ and True Endings
The most common mechanism is New Game+ (NG+). After you finish the game, you can start over with your levels, weapons, or money. Some games only unlock the final chapter or the real final boss on this second run. For example:
- Chrono Trigger (1995) has multiple endings, but you can only get the best one on a New Game+ run.
- NieR: Automata (2017) requires you to play through the game three times as different characters to see the full story and the true ending.
- Dark Souls II (2014) lets you reach new areas and fight different bosses in NG+ that are not present in the first playthrough.
In these cases, the first playthrough is essentially a tutorial for the real challenge. The game expects you to have learned the mechanics, so the second run is balanced around your knowledge.
Branching Paths and Character Routes
Visual novels and story-driven RPGs often have multiple routes that lock you out of certain scenes. To see everything, you must replay and make different choices. A famous example is Zero Escape: Virtue’s Last Reward (2012), where you need to complete all branches to unlock the true ending. Similarly, Undertale (2015) requires a second playthrough to get the “Genocide” route, which is drastically different from the neutral ending.
Some games label these separate routes as “scenarios” rather than playthroughs. For instance, Resident Evil 2 (1998 and 2019) has a second scenario where you play as the other character, and you only get the true ending after finishing both.
Multiple Endings That Require Replay
Even when a game does not have a formal New Game+, it may still ask you to replay to see all endings. Many games save your progress and let you jump back to a branching point, but others force a full restart. Examples include:
- Heavy Rain (2010) has dozens of endings, and you cannot see them all in one playthrough because choices lock out others.
- Detroit: Become Human (2018) has a flowchart that shows missing scenes, but you must replay chapters to fill them.
- Fire Emblem: Three Houses (2019) has four different story routes, each requiring a separate playthrough to fully understand the war.
In these games, the “complete” state is not a single ending but a full gallery or achievement list. Some players enjoy this, while others find it tedious.
How to Know If a Game Needs Multiple Runs
Before you start, check the game’s official description or a guide. Look for phrases like “multiple endings,” “New Game+,” or “chapter select.” Also, check the trophy/achievement list: if there are achievements for “get ending B” or “finish on hard mode,” you will likely need more than one run. Another clue is the presence of a chapter select that locks after the credits—if it unlocks, you may be able to replay chapters without starting over.
If you want to avoid spoilers, you can simply play once and then decide. Many games are designed so that the first playthrough is satisfying on its own, and the second is for completionists.
Common Problems and Misconceptions
A common misconception is that “finishing more than once” always means the same story with a different ending. In reality, some games change the entire second half, add new dungeons, or even change the genre. For example, NieR: Automata’s second playthrough is from a different character’s perspective, and the third is a direct continuation that resolves the story.
Another issue is save file corruption or losing your New Game+ data. Always back up your saves if the game supports it. Also, some games do not carry over everything—check what carries over before you start NG+ (e.g., Dark Souls carries all items, but God of War (2018) does not carry some story items).
Costs and Time Considerations
Multiple playthroughs can double or triple your playtime. A 30-hour game becomes 90 hours if you need three runs. This is a significant time investment, but many players find it worth it for the story. Some games offer a “chapter select” that reduces the time, but not all do. If you are short on time, look up a guide to see if you can get the true ending on the first run by meeting certain conditions (e.g., Chrono Trigger has a specific sequence that unlocks the true ending on a fresh file, but it is obscure).
There is no monetary cost beyond the initial purchase—the extra content is already on the disc. However, some games sell “New Game+” as DLC, which is a separate purchase. Always check the store page before assuming it is included.
Alternatives to Multiple Playthroughs
If you dislike replaying, look for games that offer a “chapter select” after the first completion, or that let you see all endings through a single save file. Some games, like The Witcher 3 (2015), have a single ending that is determined by choices, but you can reload a save to see other endings without a full replay. Others, like Life is Strange (2015), have a rewind mechanic that lets you undo choices.
Also, many games now include an “auto-save” system that creates a point before the final choice, so you can reload and see the other ending in minutes. If that is not enough, consider watching the other endings on YouTube—it is faster and still gives you the story.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I really need to finish the game more than once to get 100% completion?
Usually yes, if the game has multiple endings or New Game+ content. Check the achievement list—if there are achievements for “get all endings,” you will need multiple runs. Some games count 100% as just the main story, but most completionists include all endings.
Can I see the true ending on my first playthrough?
Sometimes, but it is rare. Most games require a New Game+ for the true ending because it is balanced around your upgraded character. A few games, like Chrono Trigger, have a hidden method to get the true ending on a fresh file, but it is not obvious.
Does New Game+ make the game harder?
Usually yes. Enemies have more health and deal more damage, and sometimes new enemy types appear. The game assumes you have better gear and skills, so the difficulty scales up. Some games let you choose the difficulty for NG+, so you can keep it easy if you want.
What carries over into New Game+?
It depends on the game. Common carry-overs include character level, equipment, money, and unlocked abilities. Story items and key quest items usually do not carry over. Check the game’s manual or a wiki for the exact list.
Are there any games that require more than two playthroughs?
Yes. NieR: Automata requires three, Fire Emblem: Three Houses has four routes, and Zero Escape: Virtue’s Last Reward requires many playthroughs to see all branches. Some visual novels have dozens of endings, but you can often use a flowchart to jump to branches.
Is it worth it to play a game multiple times?
If you love the gameplay and story, yes. Many players find that a second playthrough reveals details they missed. However, if you are only doing it for a trophy, consider whether the time investment is worth it. There is no shame in watching the other endings online.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Why Wait for Galaxy S25 Ultra? Key Reasons
- Incognito Mode: Why You Should Browse With It More
- Ecovacs Deebot N30 Family: Models, Features, and Buying Guide
- Resident Evil 9: What I Want and Don’t Want From It
- General Motors EVs: Models You Should Know
- LibreOffice Finally Got the Feature That Makes It Easier to Recommend