keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Getting Over It vs Only Up: Which Climb Is Harder?

Card No. 06·81753 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

Getting Over It with Bennett Foddy and Only Up! are both notoriously difficult climbing games, but they punish players in very different ways. If you want the more demanding, skill-based challenge, Getting Over It is harder; if you want a longer, more frustrating endurance test with unfair falls, Only Up! is the tougher grind. This article breaks down both games so you can decide which brutal climb fits your tolerance for pain.

Background: Two Games, Two Philosophies

Getting Over It with Bennett Foddy released in 2017 as a standalone follow-up to the browser game Sexy Hiking. It’s a physics-based climbing game where you control a man in a cauldron using a hammer. The entire game is one continuous mountain, and any mistake can send you sliding back to the start. Bennett Foddy designed it as a meditation on frustration and achievement, with a narrator who comments on your suffering.

Only Up! came out in 2023 as a 3D platformer inspired by the Getting Over It formula. You play as a young astronaut named Jackie, climbing a surreal, ever-rising structure made of objects like pipes, floating islands, and even a giant crab. The game was built in Unreal Engine and gained massive popularity on Twitch and TikTok, partly because of its chaotic physics and frequent falls.

The key difference: Getting Over It is a 2D physics puzzle with a single, unforgiving mechanic. Only Up! is a 3D platformer with dozens of mechanics, including bounce pads, balloons, and even a jetpack. That variety makes Only Up! more accessible at first, but also more unpredictable.

How the Difficulty Works

Getting Over It’s difficulty comes from the hammer mechanic. You must swing the hammer to push yourself upward, and the physics are extremely precise. A slight over-rotation can send you flying backward. The game has no checkpoints, so a 20-minute climb can be undone in two seconds. The difficulty is pure skill: you can improve with practice, but there’s no luck involved.

Only Up! also has no checkpoints, but the challenge is different. The game’s physics are floaty and sometimes buggy. You might step on a leaf that launches you into the sky, or a collision glitch could throw you off the map. While skill matters, randomness plays a big role. Some players have fallen from near the top due to a sudden physics glitch, which feels unfair compared to Getting Over It’s consistent rules.

Which One Is Actually Harder?

If you define “harder” as requiring more precise, repeatable skill, Getting Over It wins. The learning curve is steep, and even experienced players can take 10+ hours to finish. The game demands perfect timing and spatial awareness. There’s no way to cheese it—you must master the hammer.

If you define “harder” as more frustrating and time-consuming, Only Up! takes the crown. The game is much longer (a full playthrough can take 20–30 hours for a first-timer), and the fall distance is often greater. Because the world is 3D, you can miss a jump by a pixel and plummet for minutes. The random physics glitches add a layer of unfairness that makes the climb feel Sisyphean.

In short: Getting Over It is harder in a controlled, skill-based way. Only Up! is harder in a chaotic, endurance-based way. Most players who finish Getting Over It can do so consistently; Only Up! finishers often say they’ll never touch it again.

Common Problems and Misconceptions

A common misconception is that Only Up! is a clone of Getting Over It. While it’s clearly inspired, the gameplay is fundamentally different. Getting Over It is a 2D puzzle; Only Up! is a 3D platformer. They share the “one mistake = restart” philosophy, but the skills required don’t transfer well.

Another misconception is that Getting Over It is purely about patience. In reality, patience alone won’t help you; you need precise technique. Many players spend hours stuck on the same section because they don’t understand the hammer’s physics. Only Up! is more forgiving in that you can often find an alternate route, but the sheer number of objects can be overwhelming.

Common problems in both games:

  • Getting Over It: The “orange hell” section near the end is notorious for causing rage quits.
  • Only Up!: The floating islands section has invisible collision boxes that can knock you off.
  • Both: No pause button (in Getting Over It, pausing is possible but risky; in Only Up!, the game doesn’t auto-pause).

How to Choose the Right Challenge for You

Consider what you want from a difficult game:

  • If you enjoy mastering a single, consistent mechanic, choose Getting Over It.
  • If you prefer a varied, visually interesting world with more randomness, choose Only Up!.
  • If you have limited time, Getting Over It can be beaten in a few hours (if you’re skilled); Only Up! requires a much longer commitment.
  • If you want to stream or make content, Only Up! has more chaotic moments that are fun to watch.
  • If you want a “fair” challenge where every death is your fault, Getting Over It is better.

Both games are available on PC. Getting Over It is also on mobile and Nintendo Switch, while Only Up! is PC-only (and was briefly removed from Steam in 2023 due to copyright issues, but it’s back).

Costs and Availability

Getting Over It typically costs around $8 on Steam, and it’s often on sale for less. Only Up! launched at $10, but its price has fluctuated due to its removal and re-listing. Both are relatively cheap for the hours of frustration they provide. If you’re on a budget, Getting Over It is the better value because it offers a more polished, complete experience.

Note that Only Up! was originally removed from Steam in September 2023 because the developer used copyrighted assets (like a model of the Eiffel Tower). It was re-listed later with some changes, but the version you buy now may differ slightly from the viral streams.

Safety and Mental Health Considerations

Both games are designed to frustrate you. That’s the point. But it’s important to recognize when frustration stops being fun. If you find yourself getting genuinely angry, take a break. The games don’t have a timer, so you can walk away and come back later. There’s no shame in using a guide or watching a speedrun to learn techniques.

Some players report that these games help them build patience and resilience. Others find them genuinely stressful. Listen to your own limits. If you’re prone to rage quitting or have a short temper, consider playing with a friend or muting the game’s audio (the narrator in Getting Over It can be condescending).

Frequently Asked Questions

Which game is more popular on Twitch?

Only Up! had a massive spike in viewership in 2023, partly because streamers like xQc and Sykkuno played it. Getting Over It has a more consistent, long-tail popularity, but it never reached the same peak. If you want to watch chaotic reactions, Only Up! is more entertaining; if you want to see masterful skill, Getting Over It speedruns are incredible.

Can you beat Getting Over It in one sitting?

Yes, skilled players can finish it in under 30 minutes. The world record is around 2 minutes, but that’s with perfect technique and years of practice. A first-timer should expect 5–15 hours. Only Up! takes longer—even good players need 3–5 hours for a first clear, and casual players can spend 20+ hours.

Is Only Up! a rip-off of Getting Over It?

It’s not a rip-off, but it’s clearly inspired. The core idea of “climb a mountain with no checkpoints” is the same, but the execution is different. Only Up! adds 3D movement, multiple mechanics, and a more colorful world. Bennett Foddy himself has acknowledged the inspiration, and he doesn’t seem upset about it.

Which game is better for speedrunning?

Getting Over It has a much more active speedrunning community because the game is short and the mechanics are precise. Only Up! speedruns exist, but they’re less popular because the game is longer and more random. If you want to chase records, Getting Over It is the better choice.

Do I need a good PC to run these games?

Getting Over It runs on almost anything, including low-end laptops. Only Up! uses Unreal Engine 5, so it requires a decent GPU. Check the system requirements before buying; if you have an older PC, Getting Over It is the safer bet.

Can I play these games with a controller?

Yes, both support controllers. Getting Over It is often easier with a mouse, but a controller works fine. Only Up! is designed for a controller, and the keyboard controls can be awkward. If you have a gamepad, use it for Only Up!.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →