keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Google Denies DuckDuckGo Incognito Claim: Facts

Card No. 06·75271 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

Google has denied a claim that its Chrome Incognito mode secretly tracks users, a controversy that resurfaced after a 2024 class-action settlement. The denial centers on what Incognito actually does: it stops browsing history, cookies, and site data from being saved on your device, but it does not make you anonymous to websites, internet service providers, or Google itself. This article explains the exact claim, Google’s response, how Incognito really works, and what the settlement means for you.

The Claim and Google’s Denial

The claim, central to a 2020 class-action lawsuit (Brown v. Google), was that Google misled users by implying Incognito mode offered total privacy. Plaintiffs argued that Google continued to collect browsing data through its analytics, advertising cookies, and other trackers even when users were in Incognito. In 2024, Google agreed to a $5 billion settlement, but it did not admit wrongdoing. Google’s official denial is that Incognito never promised full anonymity—it only promised that your local device wouldn’t save your history. The company maintains that its privacy disclosures, which appear on every Incognito tab, clearly state that “you’re going incognito” and that “your activity might still be visible to websites you visit” and to your employer or school. The denial is therefore about the scope of the claim: Google says it never claimed to block all tracking, only local history.

What Incognito Mode Actually Does

When you open an Incognito window in Chrome, the browser creates a temporary session that isolates your browsing from your normal profile. Here’s what it does and doesn’t do:

  • Does: Prevents Chrome from saving your browsing history, cookies, site data, or form inputs on your device.
  • Does: Deletes cookies and site data when you close all Incognito windows.
  • Doesn’t: Hide your IP address from websites or your internet service provider.
  • Doesn’t: Stop websites from using their own analytics or advertising trackers.
  • Doesn’t: Stop Google from collecting data if you’re signed into a Google account while using Incognito.

In short, Incognito is a local privacy feature, not an anonymity tool. It’s like using a public computer: the next person won’t see your history, but the websites you visited still know you were there.

Why Users Thought It Was More Private

The confusion stems from the name and the messaging. “Incognito” suggests hidden identity, and the splash screen that says “you’ve gone incognito” implies a higher level of privacy. Many users assumed that meant no data collection whatsoever. Google’s own privacy disclosures, however, have always been more nuanced. For example, the Incognito start page states: “Your activity might still be visible to websites you visit” and “Your downloads, bookmarks, and reading list items will be saved.” The lawsuit argued that these disclosures were insufficient because they didn’t explicitly say that Google itself would still collect data. A 2019 study by the University of Chicago and Leuven found that Incognito did not prevent Google from tracking users through its analytics and advertising cookies, which fueled the claim.

The Legal Settlement and What It Means

In December 2024, Google agreed to a $5 billion settlement to resolve the class action. The settlement, which is pending court approval, would require Google to:

  • Pay damages to users who used Incognito mode between June 1, 2016, and April 30, 2024.
  • Update its Incognito disclosures to be clearer about data collection.
  • Allow users to block third-party cookies in Incognito by default for five years.

Google did not admit liability. The settlement is a compromise: users get compensation and clearer disclosures, but Google avoids a trial that could have forced it to change its core advertising model. For the average user, the practical takeaway is that Incognito is not a shield against tracking, and the settlement doesn’t change that—it only makes the limitations more transparent.

How Incognito Compares to Other Private Browsing Modes

Incognito is not unique. All major browsers have a similar private mode:

  • Firefox Private Browsing: Blocks some trackers by default, but still doesn’t hide your IP address.
  • Safari Private Browsing: Similar to Chrome, but Safari’s Intelligent Tracking Prevention is more aggressive at blocking cross-site trackers.
  • Edge InPrivate: Similar to Chrome, with optional tracking prevention.
  • Brave Private Window: Blocks most trackers and ads by default, making it closer to a true privacy tool.

None of these modes make you anonymous. To truly hide your activity from websites and your ISP, you need a VPN (which hides your IP) or the Tor Browser (which anonymizes your traffic through multiple relays).

Common Misconceptions and Real Risks

Many people believe Incognito protects them from malware, viruses, or their employer. It doesn’t. It also doesn’t prevent your school or workplace from monitoring your activity if you’re on their network. Another misconception is that Incognito stops Google from logging your searches. If you’re signed into a Google account, your searches are saved to your account’s activity log, even in Incognito. To avoid that, you must sign out of your Google account and use a different search engine. The real risk of relying on Incognito is a false sense of security: you might share sensitive information on a site that’s actually tracking you, thinking you’re anonymous.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Incognito mode hide my IP address?

No. Your IP address is visible to every website you visit, your internet service provider, and any network administrator. Incognito only prevents your browser from saving history and cookies locally.

Can my employer see my Incognito browsing on a work computer?

Yes. If you’re using a company-owned device or a corporate network, your employer can use monitoring software to see your activity, regardless of Incognito mode. Incognito doesn’t hide your traffic from your network administrator.

Will the $5 billion settlement give me money?

If you used Incognito mode in Chrome between June 1, 2016, and April 30, 2024, you may be eligible for a share of the settlement. The exact amount per person hasn’t been determined, and you’ll need to file a claim once the settlement is approved. Watch for official notices from the court.

Does Incognito stop Google from collecting my data?

No. If you’re signed into a Google account, Google can still associate your browsing activity with your account. Even if you’re not signed in, Google’s analytics and advertising cookies on websites can collect data about your visit. Incognito only prevents that data from being stored on your device.

What’s the difference between Incognito and a VPN?

Incognito is a browser feature that prevents local history and cookies. A VPN is a separate service that encrypts your internet connection and hides your IP address from websites. A VPN provides more privacy from your ISP and websites, but it doesn’t clear your history or cookies. For maximum privacy, you can use both, but remember that a VPN provider may still log your activity.

Is there a way to make Incognito truly private?

You can increase privacy by signing out of all Google accounts, using a privacy-focused search engine like DuckDuckGo, and enabling Chrome’s “Block third-party cookies” setting. However, even then, websites you visit will see your IP address and may use first-party trackers. For true anonymity, use Tor Browser.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →