keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Did Google Drop Its ‘Don’t Be Evil’ Motto?

Card No. 06·72902 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

Yes, Google removed “Don’t be evil” from its Code of Conduct in 2018, and it was quietly replaced with “Do the right thing.” The phrase had been the company’s informal motto since 1999, but it was officially dropped when Google reorganized under a new parent company, Alphabet, and revised its corporate documents. This article explains exactly when and how the motto disappeared, why it mattered, and what it means for the company today.

The Origins of “Don’t Be Evil”

“Don’t be evil” was coined in 1999 by Paul Buchheit, one of Google’s first engineers and the creator of Gmail. The phrase was intended as a moral compass for a young company that wanted to distinguish itself from rivals like Microsoft, which was then facing antitrust scrutiny. It appeared in Google’s 2004 IPO letter, where founders Larry Page and Sergey Brin wrote: “Don’t be evil. We believe strongly that in the long term, we will be better served—as shareholders and in all other ways—by a company that does good things for the world even if we forgo some short term gains.”

The motto was never a legally binding rule; it was a cultural statement. Employees often cited it in internal debates, and it became shorthand for Google’s self-image as a company that would not abuse its power. For years, it was printed on posters, T-shirts, and even in the company’s Code of Conduct.

When and How Google Dropped the Motto

The removal happened in April 2018, when Google updated its Code of Conduct. The new version replaced “Don’t be evil” with “Do the right thing.” The change was subtle—the opening line shifted from “Don’t be evil” to “Do the right thing,” and the rest of the document remained largely the same. Google did not announce the change; it was noticed by journalists and employees who compared the old and new versions of the document.

The timing was significant. In 2015, Google had restructured into Alphabet Inc., with Google becoming a subsidiary. The Code of Conduct that applied to Google employees was separate from Alphabet’s, but the motto had already been de-emphasized. By 2018, Google was facing internal protests over its work with the U.S. Department of Defense’s Project Maven, an AI program used for drone surveillance. Thousands of employees signed a petition demanding that Google not participate in warfare-related projects. The company eventually ended the Maven contract, but the motto’s removal was seen by many as a response to the growing tension between the company’s ideals and its business practices.

What “Do the Right Thing” Means Now

The new phrase, “Do the right thing,” is vaguer than “Don’t be evil.” It does not set a clear boundary; it asks employees to exercise judgment. Critics argue that this gives the company more room to interpret ethical questions in ways that favor business interests. Supporters say it reflects a more mature understanding that ethics are not always black and white.

In practice, the change did not alter Google’s legal obligations or its commitment to user privacy. The company still maintains a Code of Conduct with specific rules about conflicts of interest, confidentiality, and compliance with laws. But the symbolic shift was real: the old motto was a line in the sand, while the new one is a guideline.

Why the Removal Sparked Controversy

The removal was controversial because “Don’t be evil” had become a promise to users. When a company says it will not do evil, people expect it to avoid certain actions even if they are legal and profitable. The change was interpreted as a retreat from that promise, especially in the context of Project Maven and other government contracts.

Another factor was the 2018 testimony of Sundar Pichai, Google’s CEO, before the U.S. Congress. He was asked about the motto and said, “We have a code of conduct, and we make sure we follow it.” He did not defend the old phrase. The company also removed the motto from its “Ten things we know to be true” page, a list of corporate values that had included “You can make money without doing evil.”

What the Motto’s Removal Means for Users

For everyday users, the removal of the motto does not change how Google’s products work. Search, Gmail, Maps, and YouTube still function the same way. What it changes is the perception of Google’s corporate character. When a company’s stated values shift, users may wonder whether their data is being handled with the same care.

Google still publishes a Privacy Policy and a Transparency Report, and it still allows users to control ad personalization. But the motto’s removal is a reminder that corporate values can evolve. If you are concerned about privacy, it is worth reviewing Google’s current policies and adjusting your account settings accordingly.

Common Misconceptions About the Motto

One common misconception is that “Don’t be evil” was a legal contract. It was not. It was a cultural slogan, and removing it did not break any law. Another misconception is that the motto was removed because Google “became evil.” That is a subjective judgment; the company still has ethical guidelines, but they are less absolute.

Some people also believe that the motto was removed from all Google materials. In fact, it still appears in some older documents and in the “Alphabet” page’s code of conduct, but it is no longer the opening line. The phrase also lives on in popular culture and in the minds of users who remember the early Google.

Frequently Asked Questions

When exactly did Google remove “Don’t be evil”?

Google removed the phrase from its Code of Conduct in April 2018. The change was made quietly, without a public announcement, and was first noticed by journalists comparing the old and new versions of the document.

Why did Google change the motto?

The official reason was to update the language to reflect the company’s evolution. The change came amid internal debates over military AI projects and the company’s growing size. The new phrase, “Do the right thing,” is more flexible and less absolute.

Is “Don’t be evil” still used anywhere at Google?

The phrase still appears in some older Google materials and in the Code of Conduct for Alphabet, the parent company, but it is no longer the opening line of Google’s own Code of Conduct. It is also still used informally by some employees.

Did the removal affect Google’s business practices?

No. The removal was symbolic. Google’s actual policies and legal obligations did not change. The company still has a detailed Code of Conduct and privacy policies that govern its actions.

Can Google bring the motto back?

Yes, it could. The decision is entirely up to the company. There is no legal or technical barrier to reinstating the phrase. Whether it will do so is uncertain, but public pressure could influence that decision.

Conclusion

Google dropped “Don’t be evil” in 2018, replacing it with “Do the right thing.” The change was a symbolic shift, not a legal one, but it reflected a broader evolution in the company’s culture and business priorities. For users, the important thing is to judge Google by its actions, not its slogans. If you value privacy and ethics, stay informed about how the company handles your data and hold it accountable when it falls short.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →