Google treats hyphens in URLs as word separators, while underscores are not recognized as separators, meaning hyphens are the recommended choice for SEO. However, neither hyphens nor underscores are direct ranking factors; they influence how Google interprets your URL, which can indirectly affect click-through rates and user experience.
Background: How Google Reads URLs
Google’s web crawler parses URLs to understand the content of a page. In 2006, Matt Cutts, then a Google engineer, explicitly stated that Google treats hyphens as word separators but does not treat underscores that way. This means a URL like best-coffee-mugs is read as “best coffee mugs,” while best_coffee_mugs is read as “bestcoffeemugs” — one long word. This distinction affects how well your URL keywords match search queries, but it is not a direct ranking factor in Google’s core algorithm.
Google’s official documentation on URL structure recommends using hyphens to separate words, but it also notes that “if your site has a reasonable number of URLs that are considered duplicate or similar, you can use the URL parameter tool to tell Google how you want them treated.” This shows that URL structure is more about crawlability and indexation than about boosting rankings.
How Hyphens and Underscores Affect SEO
While not a ranking factor, URL structure influences SEO in several indirect ways:
- Keyword visibility: Hyphens separate words, making it easier for search engines to identify individual keywords in the URL. This can help with anchor text and snippet display.
- User experience: URLs with hyphens are easier for people to read and share. A clean URL like
/best-coffee-mugs/is more trustworthy than/best_coffee_mugs/. - Click-through rate (CTR): A readable URL can improve CTR in search results, which is a user engagement signal that may indirectly impact rankings.
- Canonicalization: Using hyphens consistently avoids duplicate content issues that can arise from mixing separators.
In contrast, underscores can cause problems: Google may treat the entire string as one word, missing the individual keywords. For example, best_coffee_mugs might be seen as “bestcoffeemugs,” which is less likely to match a search for “best coffee mugs.”
Emojis in URLs: A Different Story
Emojis in URLs are rare and generally not recommended for SEO. While Google can technically read emojis in URLs (they are converted to punycode for internationalized domain names), they are not treated as word separators. An emoji is just a character, not a space. Moreover, emojis can cause usability issues: they may not display correctly on all browsers, and they are difficult to type or share. Google’s guidelines do not mention emojis as a factor, but they are clearly not a best practice for URL structure.
In practice, you almost never see emojis in URLs on major websites. They are more common in social media handles or short links, but for a standard webpage, they add no SEO value and can harm user trust.
How to Choose the Right URL Separator
For most websites, the choice is clear: use hyphens. Here are practical guidelines:
- Use hyphens to separate words in URLs:
/best-coffee-mugs/. - Avoid underscores, spaces, and other special characters.
- Keep URLs short and descriptive, but don’t stuff keywords.
- Use lowercase letters to avoid case-sensitivity issues.
- If you already have underscores, consider redirecting to hyphenated versions, but do this carefully to avoid losing link equity.
For dynamic URLs with parameters, use hyphens for static parts and query strings for parameters. For example, /products?category=coffee is fine; do not use underscores in the parameter names either.
Common Problems and Misconceptions
One common misconception is that hyphens or underscores directly boost rankings. They do not. Google’s John Mueller has repeatedly stated that URL structure is a “very minor” factor, if any. The real benefit is in how users and search engines perceive your URL.
Another issue is that some content management systems (CMS) automatically generate URLs with underscores. For example, older versions of WordPress used underscores in permalinks by default. If you inherit such a site, you can change the permalink structure to use hyphens, but you must set up 301 redirects to avoid broken links.
Emojis in URLs can also cause technical problems: they are percent-encoded, making URLs long and ugly. For example, an emoji like 😀 becomes %F0%9F%98%80, which is not user-friendly. This can hurt CTR and shareability.
Comparisons: Hyphens vs Underscores vs Emojis
Here’s a quick comparison based on SEO best practices:
- Hyphens: Recognized as word separators by Google. Best for readability and SEO.
- Underscores: Not recognized as separators. They merge words, hurting keyword visibility. Not recommended.
- Emojis: Not separators, cause encoding issues, and look unprofessional. Avoid them.
In terms of user perception, hyphens are the clear winner. They are familiar, easy to type, and universally supported. Underscores are often associated with programming or technical jargon, and emojis are seen as informal or gimmicky.
Costs and Effort of Changing URLs
If you decide to change your URL structure from underscores to hyphens, there is a cost: you need to implement 301 redirects from old URLs to new ones. This is a technical task that requires access to your server or CMS. The effort is usually worth it if you have a large site with many underscores, but for small sites, the impact on SEO may be negligible.
There is no monetary cost to using hyphens, but there is an opportunity cost if you ignore best practices. A poorly structured URL can reduce CTR and make your site look less trustworthy, which can indirectly affect rankings.
Alternatives and Best Practices
Beyond hyphens, there are other URL best practices to consider:
- Use descriptive slugs that summarize the page content.
- Remove stop words like “and,” “or,” “but” when they don’t add value.
- Avoid dates or numbers that change frequently, unless they are relevant.
- Use a consistent structure across the site.
- Consider using subdirectories instead of subdomains for better consolidation of link equity.
Remember, the goal is to create URLs that are easy for both users and search engines to understand. Hyphens are the standard, but the most important thing is to be consistent and descriptive.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Google treat underscores as separators?
No, Google does not treat underscores as word separators. Since 2006, Google has officially stated that underscores are not recognized as separators, so best_coffee_mugs is treated as “bestcoffeemugs.” This can reduce the SEO value of keywords in your URL.
Are hyphens or underscores better for SEO?
Hyphens are better because they are recognized as word separators, making URLs more readable and helping search engines identify individual keywords. Underscores are not recommended for SEO purposes.
Can emojis in URLs improve SEO?
No, emojis do not improve SEO. They are not treated as separators, they cause encoding issues, and they can make URLs look unprofessional. It is best to avoid emojis in URLs entirely.
Should I change my URLs from underscores to hyphens?
If you have a significant number of URLs with underscores, it may be worth changing them to hyphens and setting up 301 redirects. However, for small sites, the impact is minimal, and the effort may not be justified.
Do hyphens in URLs affect rankings directly?
No, hyphens are not a direct ranking factor. They influence how Google reads and displays your URL, which can affect CTR and user experience, but they do not directly boost rankings.
What is the best URL structure for SEO?
The best URL structure is short, descriptive, and uses hyphens to separate words. It should be easy for users to read and share, and it should accurately reflect the content of the page.
Related
Formula used
Each line is one input (in, sel, list) or one result (out: label, unit, formula, decimals). How the calculators work
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Infinity Essence in Sailor Piece: Farming and Uses
- Apollo.io Alternatives for Sales Prospecting
- Deploy AI Agents in a Service Desk With Human Oversight
- AIM and Yahoo Profiles: When Did You Last Look?
- Best Smartwatch Under ₹5,000 in India: What to Buy
- Chat History vs Saved Memory in AI Assistants