Google has gotten several emoji designs wrong over the years, most notably the hamburger emoji (which had the cheese under the patty instead of on top) and the bagel emoji (which was missing cream cheese). These errors sparked public criticism and prompted Google to issue fixes, but the question of whether an emoji is “wrong” is more complex than it seems—it involves Unicode standards, platform interpretation, and user expectations.
The Hamburger Emoji Debacle
In 2017, a sharp-eyed Twitter user noticed that Google’s hamburger emoji (🍔) had the cheese placed under the meat patty, while the lettuce was on top. This might sound trivial, but for many, it violated an unwritten rule of burger construction: cheese melts onto the patty, so it should sit directly on top of the meat. Google’s design had the cheese below the patty, which made the burger look both unappetizing and structurally wrong.
The criticism went viral, and Google’s then-CEO Sundar Pichai personally responded, promising to “drop everything” to fix it. The company updated the emoji in 2018, moving the cheese to the top of the patty. This incident became a case study in how emoji design is not just about aesthetics—it’s about cultural expectations and even food logic.
The Bagel Emoji: Missing Cream Cheese
Another notable Google error was the bagel emoji (🥯), which was introduced in 2019 as part of Unicode 11. Google’s initial design showed a plain bagel with no cream cheese, while other platforms like Apple and Microsoft displayed a bagel with a schmear. For many users, a bagel without cream cheese is like a pizza without sauce—it’s incomplete. The omission was especially glaring because the emoji was added specifically after a public campaign by a Jewish teenager, and the lack of cream cheese felt like a missed cultural detail.
Google later updated the bagel to include cream cheese, but the initial oversight highlighted how emoji designers must balance simplicity with cultural accuracy.
Why Emoji Designs Differ Across Platforms
Emoji are not owned by any single company. The Unicode Consortium defines a set of characters and gives each a name and a general description, but it does not dictate the exact visual design. Each platform—Google, Apple, Microsoft, Samsung, and others—creates its own artwork. This means the same emoji can look very different depending on your device.
For example, the “face with tears of joy” (😂) looks similar everywhere, but the “slightly smiling face” (🙂) has subtle differences in eye shape and mouth curve. These variations are intentional, allowing platforms to express their own brand style. However, they also lead to inconsistencies: an emoji that looks happy on one phone might look sarcastic on another.
How Emoji Get Approved and Designed
Emoji are proposed by individuals or organizations and reviewed by the Unicode Emoji Subcommittee. The committee evaluates proposals based on expected usage, distinctiveness, and compatibility. Once approved, the emoji gets a code point and a name, but the visual design is left to each platform.
Designers at Google, Apple, and others then create the artwork. This is where errors can occur. For instance, the “woman with headscarf” emoji (🧕) was initially criticized for looking like a man in some designs, and the “person tipping hand” (💁) has been called out for its ambiguous gender. Google has had to revise several designs after public feedback.
Common Mistakes Users Notice
Beyond the hamburger and bagel, users have spotted other issues with Google’s emoji:
- Cheese wedge vs. Swiss cheese: Google’s cheese emoji (🧀) shows a wedge with holes, which some argue looks more like Swiss cheese, while others expect a plain slice.
- Pancakes vs. waffles: The pancake emoji (🥞) on Google looks like a stack of pancakes, but some users have pointed out that the butter pat on top is too large, making it look like a waffle.
- Fork and knife with plate: The “fork and knife with plate” emoji (🍽️) on Google sometimes appears without the plate, which defeats its purpose.
These may seem minor, but they show that emoji design is a delicate art. A single pixel can change the meaning.
How to Report or Request an Emoji Fix
If you spot an emoji that looks wrong on your device, you have a few options:
- Report it to the platform: Google, Apple, and others have feedback channels. For Google, you can use the Gboard app’s “Send feedback” option or the Android issue tracker.
- Submit a Unicode proposal: If you believe an emoji is missing or fundamentally misrepresented, you can submit a formal proposal to the Unicode Consortium. This is a lengthy process but can lead to new emoji or changes.
- Use Emojipedia: This site tracks emoji designs across platforms and often highlights discrepancies. You can see how an emoji looks on Google, Apple, Samsung, and more.
Remember, though, that what looks “wrong” to you might be a deliberate design choice. For example, Google’s “smiling face with horns” (😈) has a purple tint, while Apple’s is red. Neither is wrong—just different.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does Google’s hamburger emoji look different from Apple’s?
Each platform creates its own emoji artwork, so the same Unicode character can look different. Google’s hamburger has the cheese on top now, while Apple’s has always been that way. The differences are due to design choices, not errors.
Are emoji designs standardized?
No. Unicode standardizes the character and its meaning, but not the visual appearance. Each platform uses its own style guide. This is why an emoji can look different on Android vs. iOS.
Can I change the emoji style on my phone?
On Android, you can install third-party emoji fonts or use apps that replace the system emoji. On iPhone, you cannot change the system emoji without jailbreaking, which is not recommended.
Why do some emoji have different meanings on different platforms?
Because the visual design can change the interpretation. For example, the “smirking face” (😏) on Google looks more mischievous than on Apple. This can lead to miscommunication in texts.
How often does Google update its emoji?
Google typically updates its emoji set with each new Android version, usually once a year. However, minor design tweaks can happen in between.
Is there a way to see all emoji designs side by side?
Yes, Emojipedia.org shows emoji designs from all major platforms on a single page. You can compare Google, Apple, Microsoft, Samsung, and others for any emoji.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Unbox ASMR Codes: What They Are & How to Use5.00 min/km
- Repurposed Old Motorola Phone for Homelab?
- How to Evaluate AI Vendors for Data Security, Privacy & Compliance
- Best Ergonomic Mouse: Top Picks & Buying Guide
- What Google Knows About You: Data Explained
- Close Tabs on Mac: Shortcuts & Methods