Buying a retro game can be confusing because the same title often exists on multiple consoles, with different graphics, sound, and even gameplay. This guide helps you identify the definitive version of a classic game before you spend money, so you get the best experience for your collection or your TV.
What You’ll Need
- The name of the game you want to buy
- Access to the internet (for research)
- A list of consoles you own or plan to play on
- Optional: a budget for the purchase
Step-by-Step
- List every version of the game. Search for the game title on a database like MobyGames or Wikipedia. Note all platforms it was released on, including home consoles, handhelds, arcade, and later compilations or remasters.
- Identify the original release. Find out which platform the game was originally designed for. This is often the arcade version for 80s and early 90s games, or the lead console for later titles. The original usually sets the baseline for what the developers intended.
- Check for exclusive content. Some versions have extra levels, characters, or modes. For example, the Sega Genesis version of Altered Beast has a two-player mode that the arcade lacks. Look up each version’s features on fan wikis or dedicated retro gaming forums.
- Compare graphics and sound. Watch side-by-side comparison videos on YouTube. Pay attention to frame rate, color palette, and music quality. The 16-bit versions of many games (e.g., Street Fighter II on SNES vs. Genesis) differ significantly in these areas.
- Consider the controller and hardware. A game that requires six buttons (like fighting games) is often better on a console with a six-button controller (Sega Genesis) than one with a two-button pad (NES). Also, consider if the game uses special chips (e.g., Super FX on SNES) that affect performance.
- Look for known bugs or glitches. Search for “
bugs” or “ version differences”. Some versions have game-breaking glitches or slowdown that make them less enjoyable. The NES version of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles has a notoriously difficult water level, but that’s not a bug—just design. - Check for re-releases and compilations. Modern consoles often have the game in a collection (e.g., Castlevania Anniversary Collection). These may offer save states, rewind, and improved graphics. However, they may also have input lag or altered sound. Decide if you want the original cart or a modern convenience.
- Read community consensus. Visit retro gaming subreddits or forums like ResetEra and ask: “Which version of X is definitive?” You’ll get passionate opinions, but patterns will emerge. For many games, there is a clear favorite (e.g., Chrono Trigger on SNES vs. PS1 vs. DS).
- Weigh price vs. value. Once you know which version is best, check prices on eBay, PriceCharting, or local retro stores. If the best version is too expensive, consider a slightly inferior but cheaper alternative. For example, the Sega CD version of Earthworm Jim has better music, but the Genesis cart is much cheaper.
- Make your purchase. Buy from a reputable seller, check photos for label damage, and ensure the cartridge or disc is authentic (fake copies are common for popular games). If buying online, ask for a picture of the PCB if possible.
Common Mistakes
- Assuming the arcade version is always best. Some home ports are actually superior due to added content or better controls. For example, Mortal Kombat II on SNES has more colors than the arcade.
- Ignoring the region differences. PAL versions run slower (50Hz vs. 60Hz) and often have borders. Always prefer NTSC versions if you live in a region that can play them.
- Buying a remake thinking it’s the original. Remakes like Final Fantasy VII Remake are different games. Make sure you’re buying the version you actually want.
- Overvaluing graphics over gameplay. A version with slightly worse graphics but smoother controls may be more fun. For example, Contra on NES is considered better than the MSX2 version despite lower resolution.
Tips
- Use emulation to test before buying. Download an emulator and try the ROM (if you own the game legally) to see which version feels best. This can save you from a costly mistake.
- Check for fan patches. Some games have fan-made translations or bug fixes that make a previously inferior version the best choice. For example, the fan translation of Mother 3 is the only way to play it in English.
- Consider the display. If you have a CRT TV, the original console version will look great. If you have a modern HDTV, you might need an upscaler, which can affect the experience. Some re-releases handle scaling better.
- Look for the “Director’s Cut” or “Complete” editions. Games like Resident Evil: Director’s Cut or Street Fighter II: Turbo often add features that make them the definitive versions.
Troubleshooting
If you can’t find a clear consensus: Some games have no universally agreed-upon best version. In that case, choose based on your personal priorities (e.g., portability vs. graphics).
If the best version is too expensive: Look for a cheaper alternative that still plays well. For example, the Sega Genesis version of Aladdin is different from the SNES version, but both are good. Or wait for a re-release on modern consoles.
If you accidentally buy a fake cartridge: Check the label quality, the weight, and the pin connectors. If it’s fake, contact the seller for a refund. Many platforms protect buyers.
If the game doesn’t work on your TV: Older consoles output 240p/480i, which modern TVs often handle poorly. You may need a line doubler like the RetroTINK or an OSSC. Alternatively, buy a version on a modern console that outputs HDMI.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the arcade version always the best?
No. While arcade versions often have the best graphics, home ports can offer more content, better controls, or extra modes. For example, the SNES version of Street Fighter II Turbo has more characters than the arcade original.
Should I buy a cartridge or a disc?
Cartridges are more durable and load faster, but discs can hold more data and often have better audio. It depends on the console and your preference for physical media.
What is the difference between NTSC and PAL versions?
NTSC runs at 60Hz and PAL at 50Hz, so PAL games are slower and often have black borders. NTSC is generally preferred for retro gaming.
Are modern re-releases (like on Switch Online) better than original carts?
They offer convenience like save states and rewind, but may have input lag or altered sound. It’s a trade-off between authenticity and convenience.
How do I know if a cartridge is authentic?
Check the label for quality, the weight (real carts are heavier), and the PCB if possible. Fake carts often have poor print quality and use generic PCBs.
What if I only have a modern console?
Look for official compilations or digital re-releases. Many classics are available on the eShop, PSN, or Xbox Live. They may not be pixel-perfect but are often the easiest way to play legally.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Reliable Subaru vs New Honda Civic Cost
- Pokemon Bookmark Corner Designs & Pokemon GO DIY
- Forgotten Games That Created Your Favorite Genres
- Lexus vs Genesis Luxurious Compact SUV0.075 hp/lb
- Uber VW Robotaxi LA Launch Date
- Notebook vs Tablet: Which Saves You More Money?