keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Compare Credit Ratings Across Agencies

Card No. 06·81909 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

Comparing credit ratings from different agencies helps you understand an issuer’s creditworthiness beyond a single letter grade, since each agency uses its own scale and criteria. This guide explains how to read and compare ratings from the three major agencies—S&P, Moody’s, and Fitch—so you can make informed decisions about bonds or other debt investments. You’ll need access to current ratings from at least two agencies for the same issuer.

What You’ll Need

  • Current credit ratings for the same issuer from at least two of the major agencies (S&P, Moody’s, Fitch).
  • A rating scale comparison chart (many financial sites provide these).
  • Knowledge of the issuer’s sector (corporate, sovereign, municipal) to interpret sector-specific nuances.
  • Optional: a spreadsheet to track ratings over time.

Step-by-Step

  1. Identify the issuer and the specific debt issue. Ratings can differ by bond maturity, seniority, and currency. Make sure you’re comparing the same type of debt (e.g., senior unsecured USD bonds) for the same issuer.
  2. Gather the current ratings. Visit the agencies’ websites or use a financial data platform. Note the rating, the outlook (positive, stable, negative), and the date of the rating action.
  3. Map each rating to its corresponding letter grade. Write down the exact rating from each agency. For example, S&P might be ‘AA-‘, Moody’s ‘Aa3’, and Fitch ‘AA-‘.
  4. Use a comparison chart to align the scales. Find a chart that shows the equivalent ratings across agencies. For instance, S&P’s ‘AA-‘ is equivalent to Moody’s ‘Aa3’ and Fitch’s ‘AA-‘. This step converts different symbols into a common language.
  5. Check the outlook and watch list status. An outlook (positive/negative/stable) indicates the likely direction of the rating over the next 6-24 months. A ‘CreditWatch’ or ‘Rating Watch’ means a possible near-term change. Compare these across agencies to see if one is more bearish or bullish.
  6. Evaluate the notches. If one agency rates the issuer higher or lower by one or more notches, investigate why. Look for the agency’s published rationale—it may cite different debt levels, cash flow projections, or governance factors.
  7. Consider the rating history. Look at how each agency’s rating has changed over the past few years. A stable rating with a positive outlook from one agency may be more meaningful than a recent downgrade from another.
  8. Synthesize the information. Decide how to weight the ratings. Some investors use the lowest rating (most conservative), some the average, and some the highest. Your choice depends on your risk tolerance and investment strategy.

Common Mistakes

  • Comparing different debt types. A company’s senior secured bonds may be rated ‘AA’, while its subordinated bonds are ‘A’. Comparing these across agencies is meaningless.
  • Ignoring the outlook. Two agencies may have the same rating, but one has a negative outlook, signaling a potential downgrade. Overlooking this can lead to surprises.
  • Assuming all ‘A’ ratings are equal. An ‘A’ from S&P is not the same as an ‘A’ from Moody’s (which uses ‘A2’). Always use a conversion chart.
  • Not checking the rating date. Ratings change. Using an outdated rating from one agency and a current one from another gives a false comparison.
  • Overlooking sovereign ceiling effects. For corporate issuers, the sovereign rating of the country can cap the corporate rating. If one agency has a different sovereign rating, it may explain a divergence.

Tips

  • Use a reliable conversion chart. Many financial websites and textbooks provide a table that maps S&P, Moody’s, and Fitch ratings side by side. Bookmark one for quick reference.
  • Read the rating rationale reports. Agencies publish short summaries explaining the key drivers. These help you understand why ratings differ.
  • Track changes over time. Create a simple spreadsheet with columns for each agency’s rating, outlook, and date. Update it quarterly to spot trends.
  • Remember that ratings are opinions. They are not guarantees of creditworthiness. Use them as one input in your analysis, not the sole basis for an investment decision.

Troubleshooting

  • Ratings are missing for one agency. Some issuers only seek ratings from one or two agencies. In that case, you can’t compare directly. You may look at a comparable issuer or use a shadow rating from a third-party model, but clearly note the limitation.
  • Ratings seem wildly different. First, double-check that you’re looking at the same debt issue. If they still differ by more than one notch, read the agencies’ rationales. Often the difference stems from different views on the issuer’s liquidity or governance.
  • You can’t find a conversion chart. Most major financial news sites have one. Alternatively, you can memorize the key equivalences: AAA/Aaa, AA+/Aa1, AA/Aa2, AA-/Aa3, A+/A1, A/A2, A-/A3, BBB+/Baa1, etc.
  • Outlooks are contradictory. One agency may have a positive outlook while another has a negative one. This is rare but possible. Look at the dates and the reasons. The more recent action usually reflects the most current view.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do ratings differ between agencies?

Agencies use different methodologies, weight factors differently, and may have access to different information. They also make judgment calls, so minor differences are normal.

Which agency is the most accurate?

No agency has a perfect track record. Historically, all three have been criticized for being slow to downgrade during crises. It’s best to consider all ratings and the underlying analysis rather than relying on one agency.

What does a ‘notch’ mean in rating terms?

A notch is one step in the rating scale, e.g., from ‘AA’ to ‘AA-‘ or from ‘Aa2’ to ‘Aa3’. It represents a small change in perceived credit risk.

Should I use the lowest rating or the average?

It depends on your risk tolerance. Conservative investors often use the lowest rating to stress-test. Others average the ratings to get a middle view. There’s no universal rule.

Can I compare ratings for different types of debt (e.g., bonds vs. loans)?

Yes, but only if they have the same priority and collateral. Senior secured debt will have a higher rating than subordinated unsecured debt, so you must compare like with like.

How often are ratings updated?

Ratings are reviewed regularly (often annually) and can change at any time if a major event occurs. Outlooks are updated more frequently. Always check the ‘last review date’ on the rating.

By following these steps, you can confidently compare ratings across agencies and use them effectively in your credit analysis.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →