keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

ASIC Vendor Evaluation: Step-by-Step Guide

Card No. 06·80497 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

This guide walks you through evaluating an ASIC (Application-Specific Integrated Circuit) vendor for a custom chip project. You’ll learn the key criteria to assess, the questions to ask, and the red flags to avoid, ensuring you select a partner capable of delivering a functional, reliable chip on schedule and within budget.

What You’ll Need

  • A clear specification of your chip: function, performance targets (speed, power, area), interface standards, and target process node.
  • A realistic budget and timeline for your project.
  • Your team’s technical expertise (or a plan to hire consultants) to review vendor proposals.
  • Access to standard industry resources: foundry process design kits (PDKs), EDA tool licenses, and IP block libraries.

Step-by-Step

  1. Define Your Requirements Thoroughly. Before contacting any vendor, write a detailed specification. Include functional requirements, performance metrics (clock speed, power consumption, I/O count), target process node (e.g., 28nm, 16nm, 7nm), package type, and required certifications (automotive, medical, etc.). The more precise you are, the better you can compare vendor proposals.
  2. Create a Longlist of Potential Vendors. Look for companies with experience in your chip’s domain (e.g., mixed-signal, RF, low-power IoT). Use industry directories, trade shows, and referrals. Aim for 5-10 candidates to start.
  3. Assess Technical Expertise. For each vendor, review their portfolio: Have they designed similar chips? What process nodes have they worked with? Do they have in-house expertise for your specific challenges (e.g., high-speed SerDes, analog blocks)? Ask for case studies or references from past clients.
  4. Evaluate Design Methodology and Tools. Inquire about their design flow: Do they use industry-standard EDA tools (Synopsys, Cadence, Mentor)? Do they have a robust verification strategy (e.g., UVM, formal verification)? Ask about their experience with your target foundry and process—this can significantly reduce risk.
  5. Check IP Availability and Licensing. If your chip requires standard IP (USB, PCIe, ARM cores), ask if the vendor has licensed these before. They may have existing relationships with IP vendors, which can save time and cost. Clarify licensing terms and any royalties.
  6. Review Project Management and Communication. Ask about their project management approach: What milestones do they use? How do they report progress? Who will be your primary point of contact? Ensure they are responsive and transparent in initial communications—this is a good indicator of future behavior.
  7. Request a Detailed Proposal. Ask each vendor for a fixed-price or time-and-materials quote, including a breakdown of phases: specification, design, verification, layout, tapeout, and post-silicon bring-up. Include expected timelines and deliverables for each phase.
  8. Conduct Technical Interviews. Arrange calls or meetings with the actual design engineers who would work on your project, not just sales representatives. Ask about their experience with similar challenges, how they handle design trade-offs, and their familiarity with your target foundry.
  9. Evaluate Financial Stability and Longevity. Check the vendor’s financial health—have they been in business for a significant time? Do they have a stable client base? A vendor that goes bankrupt mid-project can be catastrophic. Look for signs of long-term commitment.
  10. Check References and Past Performance. Contact past clients, especially those with similar projects. Ask about the vendor’s adherence to schedule, communication quality, how they handled design issues, and whether the chip worked first time or required re-spins.
  11. Review Contractual Terms Carefully. Have a legal expert review the contract. Pay attention to: intellectual property ownership, liability for design errors, warranty terms, and payment milestones. Ensure there are clear penalties for missed deadlines.
  12. Make a Decision Based on a Weighted Scorecard. Create a scoring matrix with criteria like technical expertise, communication, cost, timeline, and IP availability. Assign weights based on your priorities. Score each vendor objectively and choose the one with the highest score, not necessarily the lowest bid.

Common Mistakes

  • Choosing the cheapest bid. ASIC development is complex; a low bid often means hidden costs or less experienced engineers.
  • Not verifying process experience. A vendor experienced in 65nm may struggle with 7nm—different challenges in design, verification, and manufacturing.
  • Overlooking post-silicon support. The chip doesn’t end at tapeout; you need help with bring-up, debugging, and production test. Ensure the vendor offers these services.
  • Ignoring communication red flags. If a vendor is slow to respond during evaluation, they’ll be worse during the project.
  • Not checking IP licensing terms. Some IP licenses are per-project or have royalties that can blow your budget.

Tips

  • Start with a small pilot project. If possible, engage the vendor for a small test chip or a feasibility study before committing to the full ASIC.
  • Visit the vendor’s facility. Seeing their design tools, test equipment, and team in person can provide valuable insights.
  • Ask about their failure analysis process. A good vendor will have a systematic approach to diagnosing and fixing issues.
  • Get everything in writing. Verbal promises are not binding; ensure all commitments are documented in the contract.
  • Consider a second-source strategy. If your chip will be high-volume, having a backup vendor or a foundry with multiple fabs can mitigate supply chain risks.

Troubleshooting

If the evaluation process hits a snag, here’s what to do:

  • Vendor is not responding to questions. Escalate to their management or consider this a red flag. Communication issues early on are unlikely to improve.
  • Proposals are vague or inconsistent. Ask for a detailed breakdown of tasks, deliverables, and timelines. If they can’t provide this, they may not fully understand the project.
  • You discover a vendor has a conflict of interest. For example, they also design a competing chip. This could compromise your IP confidentiality. Discuss with them how they will protect your design, or move on.
  • Your budget is insufficient for all qualified vendors. Re-evaluate your requirements: can you reduce functionality, use a more mature process node, or accept a longer timeline? Sometimes a phased approach helps.
  • You’re unsure about a vendor’s technical claims. Ask for specific examples of similar designs, and contact the clients. If they refuse, that’s a warning sign.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does ASIC development typically take?

It depends on complexity, but a typical ASIC from specification to tapeout can take 12-24 months. Post-silicon validation and production ramp can add another 6-12 months.

What is a typical ASIC development cost?

Costs vary widely: from a few hundred thousand dollars for a simple 180nm chip to tens of millions for a complex 7nm SoC. The cost includes NRE (non-recurring engineering), mask costs, and packaging.

Can I use a vendor in a different country?

Yes, but consider time zone differences, language barriers, and IP protection laws. Many companies successfully work with offshore vendors, but communication and legal protections are critical.

What is a ‘re-spin’ and why should I care?

A re-spin is a second tapeout after finding bugs in the first silicon. It’s costly and time-consuming. A good vendor with robust verification reduces the risk of re-spins, but they can still happen.

How do I protect my IP during the evaluation?

Have all vendors sign an NDA before sharing any sensitive information. Ensure the NDA covers your design specifications, architecture, and any proprietary algorithms.

What if the vendor goes out of business?

Include clauses in the contract that require delivery of all design files, scripts, and documentation at regular intervals (e.g., at each milestone). This ensures you can take the design to another vendor if needed.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →