Counterfeit Pokémon Red and Blue cartridges are common, especially online. This guide shows you how to spot a fake by checking the cartridge shell, label, circuit board, and save behavior. You’ll need a tri-wing screwdriver (or a small Phillips head if you’re careful) to open the cartridge for the most reliable check.
What You’ll Need
- The cartridge itself
- A tri-wing screwdriver (size Y1 or Y2) – standard Phillips often won’t fit the security screws
- A magnifying glass or smartphone camera with zoom
- A flashlight or bright light
- Optional: a Game Boy or a compatible handheld to test the game
Step-by-Step
- Examine the cartridge shell color. Authentic Pokémon Red and Blue cartridges are a translucent, deep red or blue plastic – not opaque, not dark black. Hold it up to a bright light: light should pass through the plastic, showing a rich, clear color. Fakes are often opaque, darker, or a slightly off shade (e.g., purple-ish red).
- Check the cartridge label for quality. The authentic label is glossy, with sharp, vibrant colors. The Pokémon logo should be crisp, and the “Game Boy” logo at the top should be clearly visible. Look for the official Nintendo “Official Seal of Quality” – it should be present and not blurry. On the bottom left of the label, there is a small, embossed (raised) number – usually a two-digit code like “00” or “01”. On a fake, the label is often matte, colors look washed out, and the embossed number is missing or printed flat.
- Inspect the back of the cartridge. The back should have a series of small, molded text: “Nintendo” in the top left, and “PAT. PEND.” or “PATENTS PENDING” in the middle. The text should be crisp and clearly legible. Fakes often have blurry, shallow, or missing text. Also, the back should be the same translucent color as the front – if it’s a different shade or opaque, that’s a red flag.
- Look at the cartridge pins (the metal contacts). On the bottom of the cartridge, you’ll see a row of gold or silver pins. Authentic cartridges have a clean, uniform row of pins. Fakes may have uneven spacing, visible solder points, or a different number of pins (authentic Game Boy games have 32 pins).
- Open the cartridge (the definitive test). Use a tri-wing screwdriver to remove the screw on the back. Authentic cartridges use a tri-wing screw – if you see a standard Phillips head, it’s almost certainly a fake (or a shell replacement). Once open, look at the circuit board:
– Authentic: The board is a dark green or dark brown, with a small battery (CR1616 or CR2025) for save data, and a clearly visible Nintendo logo or “Nintendo” text printed on the board. The board should have a specific layout with a large rectangular chip (the game ROM) and a smaller chip (the RAM).
– Fake: The board is often a lighter green, may have a glob-top (a black blob of epoxy instead of a chip), or may lack a battery entirely (meaning the game cannot save). Fakes often have no Nintendo marking, or the text looks cheaply printed. - Test the game in a console. If you have a Game Boy, insert the cartridge and power it on. Authentic games will show the “Nintendo” logo with a distinctive “ding” sound, then the Pokémon logo with a “whoosh” sound. Fakes may show a glitchy logo, skip the intro, or not boot at all. Also, try saving the game – if it doesn’t save or the save disappears after turning off, it’s fake (or the battery is dead, which is common on authentic games after 20+ years).
- Check the weight and feel. Authentic cartridges have a solid, dense feel. Fakes are often noticeably lighter because they use cheaper, thinner plastic and simpler boards. This is a subjective test, but combined with the others, it helps.
Common Mistakes
- Judging authenticity by the label alone – many fakes have very good label reproductions. Always combine label checks with shell and board checks.
- Assuming a working game is authentic – many fakes are fully playable and even save, but they’re still counterfeit and worth much less.
- Using a Phillips screwdriver and stripping the screw – if you don’t have a tri-wing, don’t force it; you’ll damage the cartridge.
- Forgetting to check the back of the cartridge – the back text is a quick giveaway that many fakes get wrong.
- Thinking a dead battery means it’s fake – authentic games from 1996-1999 have batteries that may have died. A dead battery on an otherwise authentic cartridge is normal, not a sign of a fake.
Tips
- Buy from reputable sellers with clear photos of the front, back, and (ideally) the opened board. If the seller won’t show the board, ask for a photo.
- Compare with a known authentic cartridge if you have one – side-by-side, differences become obvious.
- Use a bright light to check the translucency – this is one of the fastest tests.
- Remember that Pokémon Blue is a slightly different shade of blue than the later Pokémon Crystal (which is a lighter, more translucent blue). Don’t confuse them.
- If you’re buying online, look for the “embossed number” on the label – it’s a small raised digit that is very hard to fake.
Troubleshooting
- The game doesn’t save: If the cartridge is authentic, the battery is likely dead. You can replace the battery (CR1616 or CR2025) with a soldering iron – a common fix. If the cartridge is fake, it may lack a battery entirely, and you cannot fix that.
- The game won’t boot: Clean the pins with a cotton swab and isopropyl alcohol. If it still won’t boot, the cartridge may be fake or damaged. Check the board for any obvious damage.
- The label looks perfect but the cartridge is fake: Some fakes use high-quality label reproductions. Always open the cartridge – the board is the most reliable indicator.
- The screw is stripped: If you can’t remove the screw, try a slightly larger tri-wing bit, or use a rubber band between the screwdriver and the screw for extra grip. If that fails, you may need to carefully drill out the screw (risky).
- You’re not sure if the shell is translucent: Hold it up to a strong light or shine a flashlight through it. Authentic plastic is clearly translucent; fakes are often opaque.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are all Pokémon Red/Blue cartridges the same color?
No. Pokémon Red is a deep red, and Pokémon Blue is a deep blue. Both are translucent. Some later reprints (like the 1999 “Player’s Choice” edition) have a slightly different label but the same shell color.
Do authentic cartridges have a battery?
Yes, all authentic Game Boy Pokémon games have a battery to power the save RAM. If there’s no battery, it’s fake (or a very rare prototype).
Can a fake cartridge damage my Game Boy?
Generally, no. Fakes are electrically similar, but they may be poorly made and could cause glitches. They won’t usually damage the console, but they’re not worth collecting.
Is the “Official Seal of Quality” a reliable indicator?
It’s a good sign, but fakes often include it. It’s not sufficient on its own – combine it with the shell and board checks.
What if the game saves but the label is slightly off?
It could be a reproduction cartridge with a real board, or a fake with a working save. Open it to check the board – if it has a Nintendo logo and proper chips, it’s likely authentic despite a replaced label.
Why is my cartridge so light?
Authentic cartridges have a certain weight due to the thick plastic and the board. Fakes are often lighter. If it feels flimsy, that’s a red flag.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Arctic Sea Ice Forecasts Disagree: What to Do
- MySQL Workbench to VPS: SSH Tunnel Setup
- Bluesky Beginners Guide: How to Get Started5.00 min/km
- LG V20 Won’t Turn On? Fixed
- Snagit vs Camtasia: Which One Do You Need?
- Scale a Small Business Without Losing Culture