keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Single-Player Games to Play With Friends: 12 Great Picks

Card No. 06·83984 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

Yes, you should absolutely play single-player games with friends, and this article explains why it works, how to set it up, and which games are best for it. While the term “single-player” usually means one person plays alone, many of these games become dramatically more fun when a group takes turns, shares the controller, or plays together in the same room. This guide covers the background of this play style, how to organize it, how to pick the right game, common problems and solutions, and a list of 12 recommended titles.

Why Play Single-Player Games With Friends?

The idea sounds contradictory, but it has a long history. Before online multiplayer was common, friends gathered around one TV to play story-driven games like The Legend of Zelda or Final Fantasy, passing the controller after each death or each chapter. This “pass-the-controller” style creates a shared experience that is different from playing alone or playing competitive multiplayer. You get the emotional highs and lows of a story together, you discuss choices as a group, and you share the excitement of solving puzzles or beating a tough boss. It also makes longer games feel less lonely and more social, and it can introduce friends to genres they would not try on their own.

How It Works: Formats and Rules

There are several ways to play a single-player game as a group. The most common is turn-based sharing: each person plays for a set amount of time (e.g., 20 minutes) or until they die, then passes the controller. Another format is role-based play, where one person controls movement, another handles combat, and a third manages inventory or dialogue choices. Some games naturally support this because they have distinct mechanics. A third option is co-piloting, where everyone discusses every decision before the player acts, making it a collaborative storytelling session. For games with branching narratives, you can also vote on major choices. The key is to agree on rules beforehand, such as how long each turn lasts and whether you can rewind if someone makes a mistake.

How to Choose the Right Game

Not every single-player game works well for group play. Look for games with a strong story, clear objectives, and a pace that allows discussion. Avoid games that require intense concentration or have long stretches of quiet exploration, as those can bore spectators. Good choices include:

  • Story-driven adventures like Life is Strange or The Walking Dead – choices and dialogue are perfect for group voting.
  • Puzzle games like The Witness or Portal – everyone can contribute ideas.
  • Horror games like Resident Evil or Outlast – the fear is more fun when shared.
  • Action-adventure games like God of War or Uncharted – spectacle keeps everyone engaged.
  • RPGs like Persona 5 or Disco Elysium – long, but great for role-based control.

Consider the group’s attention span. If you have 4+ players, shorter games or games with frequent checkpoints work better. Also think about the difficulty – a game that is too hard can frustrate everyone, while one that is too easy may bore the spectators.

12 Great Single-Player Games for Group Play

Here is a list of well-regarded games that work particularly well when played with friends, based on their design and community feedback:

  1. Until Dawn – A horror game where every character’s survival depends on quick-time events and choices. Perfect for passing the controller every chapter.
  2. Detroit: Become Human – A narrative game with many branching paths. Great for voting on decisions.
  3. Heavy Rain – Another narrative thriller, similar to Detroit, with a gripping mystery.
  4. The Stanley Parable – A short, funny game about choices and narration. It’s hilarious to argue over what to do.
  5. Firewatch – A walking-simulator with a compelling story and dialogue choices. Good for a relaxed evening.
  6. What Remains of Edith Finch – A collection of short stories, each with a unique mechanic. Great for taking turns every 15 minutes.
  7. Return of the Obra Dinn – A logic puzzle game where you deduce how each crew member died. The whole group can work together.
  8. Outer Wilds – An exploration game about a time loop. Everyone can suggest where to go next.
  9. Hades – A roguelike with a great story. Each run is short, so passing after a death works perfectly.
  10. Celeste – A challenging platformer. Pass the controller on each death; the group will cheer when someone finally clears a hard room.
  11. Dark Souls – Not for everyone, but the difficulty creates shared triumphs. Pass after each death.
  12. Zelda: Breath of the Wild – Open-world exploration with no time pressure. Let each player explore for 30 minutes.

Common Problems and How to Solve Them

One common issue is backseat gaming – spectators telling the player what to do, which can be annoying. Set a rule: only the active player makes decisions, but they can ask for advice. Another problem is uneven play time – if one player is much better, they may hog the controller. Use a timer or a death-based rotation. Spoilers are also a concern if someone has already played the game; ask them to stay quiet about future events. Finally, save management can be tricky – make sure you save at the end of each turn so no one loses progress. If a player wants to continue alone later, create a separate save file.

Comparisons: Single-Player vs. Multiplayer vs. Co-Op

Traditional multiplayer games (like Call of Duty) are competitive and fast-paced, which is fun but can be stressful. Co-op games (like It Takes Two) require everyone to play simultaneously, which is great but limits the group to the number of controllers. Single-player-with-friends offers a middle ground: it is relaxed, can accommodate any group size, and works with games that were not designed for multiplayer. It also allows you to experience games that have no multiplayer mode at all. The downside is that only one person is active at a time, so it requires a patient group. For some, that is a feature – it forces everyone to watch and engage with the story rather than just react.

Costs and Setup

The cost is essentially the price of the game itself, since you only need one copy and one console or PC. Many of these games are available on multiple platforms, and some are included in subscription services like PlayStation Plus or Xbox Game Pass. You may also need a second controller if you want to swap, but that is optional. If you are playing online with friends who are not in the same room, you can use screen-sharing features like Steam Remote Play Together or Discord streaming, which allow others to watch and even take control in some cases. That setup is free and works with most games.

Safety and Etiquette

This is a social activity, so the main “safety” concerns are about comfort and respect. Make sure everyone is comfortable with the game’s content – some horror or violent games may not suit all players. Agree on a time limit so no one feels forced to stay. Also, be mindful of motion sickness if the game has fast camera movement; take breaks. Finally, avoid playing spoiler-heavy games with someone who cares a lot about experiencing the story fresh – instead, let them take the lead on decisions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you play any single-player game this way?

Technically yes, but games that are heavily text-based or have long cutscenes may bore spectators. Games with frequent action, puzzles, or choices work best. Try to pick games that are visually engaging and have a good pace.

What if one player is much better than the others?

Use a timer instead of death-based rotation. For example, each player gets 15 minutes regardless of how well they do. This ensures everyone gets equal time and prevents frustration.

How do you handle games with multiple save files?

Create a separate save slot for the group playthrough. That way, if someone wants to play alone later, they can start a new game without overwriting the group’s progress. Always save at the end of each turn.

Is this the same as “couch co-op”?

No. Couch co-op usually means multiple people play simultaneously on the same screen, like in Mario Kart or Overcooked. This is more like “pass-the-controller” or “shared single-player,” which is a different experience.

Can we play this way online with friends?

Yes. Use Steam Remote Play Together, Discord screen sharing, or console streaming features. The host plays, and others watch and can suggest actions. Some services allow the viewer to take control, which works well for turn-based games.

What is the best game to start with?

Until Dawn or The Stanley Parable are great starters because they are short, story-driven, and have clear decision points. They immediately show how fun group play can be. For a longer experience, Detroit: Become Human is a solid choice.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →