Incogni vs DeleteMe: Which Data Removal Service Wins?

Incogni and DeleteMe are both data removal services that scrub your personal information from people-search sites and data brokers, but they differ in price, coverage, and how much control you get. Incogni is the cheaper, more automated option, while DeleteMe offers more transparent reporting and a longer track record. This article compares both services directly so you can decide which one fits your privacy needs and budget.

Background: What Are Data Brokers and Why Remove Yourself?

Data brokers are companies that collect personal information from public records, social media, surveys, and other sources, then sell that data to advertisers, background check providers, or anyone willing to pay. People-search sites like Whitepages, Spokeo, and BeenVerified are the consumer-facing side of this industry. They publish your name, age, address, phone number, relatives, and sometimes more, making it easy for strangers to find you.

Data removal services automate the process of sending opt-out requests to these sites on your behalf. Instead of manually visiting dozens of websites, filling out forms, and verifying emails, the service handles it for you. Both Incogni and DeleteMe do this, but they approach it differently.

How Incogni Works

Incogni, launched in 2021 by the VPN company Surfshark, is a fully automated service. You sign up, grant it permission to act on your behalf, and it continuously sends removal requests to a growing list of data brokers. You don’t need to pick which sites to target; Incogni handles everything in the background.

Key features of Incogni:

• Automated process: No manual work beyond initial signup.
• Coverage: Claims to cover 100+ data brokers (as of early 2025).
• Pricing: Around $6.49 per month billed annually, or $12.95 month-to-month.
• Removal reports: You get a dashboard showing which requests were successful and which are pending.
• Legal basis: Uses GDPR and CCPA/CPRA rights to force removal.

The main appeal of Incogni is its low price and hands-off approach. You set it and forget it, and the service keeps working as long as you subscribe.

How DeleteMe Works

DeleteMe, operated by Abine Inc., has been around since 2010, making it one of the oldest consumer data removal services. It also automates opt-outs but gives you more visibility into what’s being removed and where.

Key features of DeleteMe:

• Manual oversight: You can see exactly which sites are being targeted and which removals succeeded.
• Coverage: Claims to cover 40+ data brokers (as of early 2025).
• Pricing: Around $10.75 per month billed annually, or $19.95 month-to-month.
• Reports: Sends you a detailed report every quarter (or more often on higher tiers).
• Add-ons: Offers paid extras like removing your info from Google search results and managing your kids’ data.

DeleteMe is often praised for its transparency. You know exactly what’s happening, and their customer support is more responsive according to user reviews. But that comes at a higher cost.

Incogni vs DeleteMe: Direct Comparison

Here’s a side-by-side look at the main differences:

• Price: Incogni is cheaper, especially on annual plans. DeleteMe costs roughly 65% more per year.
• Coverage: Incogni claims to cover more data brokers (100+ vs 40+), but DeleteMe’s list is more established and includes some sites Incogni doesn’t handle.
• Automation vs. control: Incogni is fully automated with minimal user input. DeleteMe offers more detailed reports and lets you request removals from specific sites if needed.
• Track record: DeleteMe has been operating since 2010, so it has more experience and a longer history of customer satisfaction. Incogni is newer but backed by Surfshark’s resources.
• Extra features: DeleteMe offers add-ons like search engine removal and child protection. Incogni keeps it simple with just the core service.

Both services have similar opt-out success rates, but neither can guarantee 100% removal because data brokers constantly re-add your information. You need to maintain the subscription to keep your data clean.

How to Choose Between Incogni and DeleteMe

Your choice depends on your priorities:

• Budget-conscious: If you want the lowest cost and don’t mind less reporting, go with Incogni.
• Transparency and control: If you want to see exactly what’s being removed and have the option to intervene, DeleteMe is better.
• Coverage breadth: If you want the widest net, Incogni claims more brokers, but verify their current list on their website.
• Long-term reliability: If you prefer a company with a longer track record, DeleteMe has been around longer.

Also consider that you can use both services together, but that’s probably overkill. Most people only need one.

Common Problems and Misconceptions

One common misconception is that these services remove you from the internet entirely. They don’t. They only target data broker sites, not social media profiles, public court records, or government databases. Your information will still appear in some places.

Another issue is that removal isn’t permanent. Data brokers re-add information after a few months, which is why you need an ongoing subscription. If you cancel, your data will gradually reappear.

Some users also complain that Incogni’s customer support is slow to respond, while DeleteMe’s is more accessible. However, both companies have improved their support over time. It’s worth checking recent reviews before committing.

Finally, be aware that these services require you to grant them permission to act on your behalf. This means you’re trusting them with your personal information. Both companies have privacy policies explaining how they handle your data, but you should read them before signing up.

Alternatives to Incogni and DeleteMe

If you’re not ready to pay for a service, you can manually opt out of data brokers for free. There are guides online that list the major sites and step-by-step instructions for removing yourself. This takes time and effort, but it costs nothing.

Other paid alternatives include:

• PrivacyBee: Similar to Incogni, offers automated removals with a focus on transparency.
• Kanary: Another automated service that also monitors social media.
• DeleteMe’s competitors: Some VPN companies offer data removal as an add-on, like Surfshark’s Incogni or NordVPN’s data removal feature.

Each service has its own pricing and coverage, so compare them based on your needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Incogni legit?

Yes, Incogni is a legitimate service backed by Surfshark, a well-known VPN provider. It operates under GDPR and CCPA/CPRA, which give you the right to request deletion of your data. However, it’s not a magic bullet; it can’t remove you from all websites, only those it covers.

Does DeleteMe actually work?

Yes, DeleteMe has been working since 2010 and has a solid reputation. It successfully removes your info from many data brokers, but it can’t guarantee 100% removal because some sites are slow to comply or re-add data. You need to keep the subscription active to maintain results.

Can I cancel Incogni or DeleteMe anytime?

Yes, both services allow you to cancel anytime, but if you paid for an annual plan, you typically won’t get a refund for the remaining months. Check their terms of service for specific cancellation policies.

Which service covers more data brokers?

As of early 2025, Incogni claims to cover over 100 data brokers, while DeleteMe covers about 40. However, the actual number of sites that successfully remove your data may vary. Incogni’s list is broader, but DeleteMe’s list includes some niche sites.

Will my data stay removed if I cancel?

No. Once you cancel, data brokers will gradually re-add your information as they collect new data. To keep your info off these sites, you need to maintain an active subscription or manually re-opt-out periodically.

Related

• Kubuntu Keyboard Shortcuts: The Full List
• Monitor for Work: 8 Features That Matter
• Smart Speakers: Which Brands Collect Minimal Data?