Kubernetes and OpenStack solve different problems: Kubernetes orchestrates containerized applications across a cluster of machines, while OpenStack manages the underlying virtualized infrastructure (compute, storage, networking) as a private or public cloud. You typically use OpenStack to build the cloud itself, and Kubernetes to run applications on top of it—though they overlap in some areas and can be used together or separately.
Background: Where Each Came From
OpenStack began in 2010 as a joint project by Rackspace and NASA to create open-source software for running cloud computing services on standard hardware. It provides the building blocks of a cloud: Nova for virtual machines, Swift for object storage, Cinder for block storage, Neutron for networking, and Keystone for identity. It is often described as an “infrastructure-as-a-service” (IaaS) platform—you request a VM, a network, and a storage volume, and OpenStack provisions them.
Kubernetes, first released by Google in 2014, is a container orchestration platform. It automates deployment, scaling, and management of containerized applications (usually Docker or containerd). It is a “container-as-a-service” (CaaS) or platform layer—you give it a set of containers and desired state, and it decides where to run them, restarts them if they fail, and scales them up or down. It has become the de facto standard for running microservices and cloud-native applications.
How They Work: Core Differences
The key distinction is the layer of abstraction each operates at. OpenStack abstracts physical hardware into virtual resources. When you use OpenStack, you interact with APIs that create VMs, attach storage, and configure networks. Each VM has its own operating system, and you manage it like a traditional server (though it’s virtual).
Kubernetes abstracts the cluster of machines (physical or virtual) into a pool of resources. You don’t care which node runs your container; you declare the desired state (e.g., “run 3 replicas of this web server”) and Kubernetes constantly works to match that state. It handles networking between containers, service discovery, load balancing, and rolling updates.
In practice, many organizations run Kubernetes on top of OpenStack. OpenStack provides the VMs, and Kubernetes runs on those VMs. This gives you both self-service infrastructure and application orchestration. Alternatively, you can run Kubernetes directly on bare metal, skipping OpenStack entirely.
When to Choose OpenStack
Choose OpenStack when you need to provide infrastructure to many teams or customers—like a private cloud for a large enterprise or a public cloud provider. It is suitable if you need:
- Self-service provisioning of VMs, storage, and networks with quotas and role-based access control.
- Multi-tenancy: separate projects or customers with isolated resources.
- Legacy applications that require VMs (full OS, not containers).
- Integration with existing hardware, such as specific storage arrays or SDN controllers.
OpenStack is complex to install and maintain. It has many components, and upgrading them is notoriously difficult. It is not something a small team typically deploys unless they have dedicated cloud engineering resources.
When to Choose Kubernetes
Choose Kubernetes when you are building new, cloud-native applications that are designed as microservices. It is ideal for:
- Applications that need to scale horizontally (add more instances) based on load.
- Teams that want to deploy frequently and reliably with automated rollbacks.
- Environments where you want to abstract away the underlying servers entirely.
- Hybrid or multi-cloud strategies, since Kubernetes runs the same way on any cloud or on-premises.
Kubernetes also has a steep learning curve. It introduces concepts like pods, services, deployments, and ingress—each with its own configuration. However, managed Kubernetes offerings (like EKS, AKS, GKE) reduce the operational burden by handling the control plane for you.
Common Misconception: They Are Mutually Exclusive
A common misconception is that you must choose one or the other. In reality, they are complementary. OpenStack can provide the VMs on which Kubernetes runs. This is a popular architecture for private clouds because it gives you the flexibility of VMs for other workloads and a consistent platform for containers. Conversely, you can run OpenStack itself in containers on Kubernetes (using the OpenStack-Helm or Kolla-Kubernetes projects), though that is more experimental.
Cost and Operational Considerations
Costs are not just monetary—they include operational overhead. OpenStack requires significant expertise to deploy and maintain. You need to manage multiple services (Nova, Neutron, Cinder, etc.) and their dependencies. Upgrades are risky and often require careful planning. The hardware requirements are also substantial: you need multiple controllers and compute nodes with high availability.
Kubernetes, on the other hand, is easier to install (kubeadm, kind, or managed services) but still requires expertise to operate in production. You must manage etcd, networking, security policies, and upgrades. However, the community and tooling are more mature, and managed services reduce the burden significantly. For small teams, a managed Kubernetes service is often the most cost-effective way to get container orchestration.
How to Decide: A Practical Checklist
To decide, ask yourself these questions:
- Are your applications already containerized? If yes, Kubernetes is likely the right choice.
- Do you need to provide VMs to other teams? If yes, OpenStack is the answer.
- Do you have the staff to run a private cloud? If not, consider a public cloud or managed Kubernetes.
- Are you running legacy apps that can’t be containerized? You’ll need VMs—OpenStack or a hypervisor.
- Do you want a single platform for both VMs and containers? OpenStack plus Kubernetes gives you that.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can Kubernetes run on OpenStack? Yes, it is a common pattern. You create VMs in OpenStack and then install Kubernetes on them. OpenStack even has a Magnum service that can automatically deploy Kubernetes clusters.
Is OpenStack a container platform? No, OpenStack is an IaaS platform. It can provision VMs that run containers, but it does not orchestrate containers itself. That is Kubernetes’ job.
Which is easier to learn? Kubernetes has a gentler learning curve for developers, but a steeper one for operators. OpenStack is more complex to set up and manage, but its concepts (VMs, networks, storage) are familiar to traditional sysadmins.
Can I use them together? Absolutely. Many enterprises use OpenStack as the underlying cloud and Kubernetes as the application platform. This gives you both self-service VMs and container orchestration.
Is OpenStack dead? No, it is still actively developed and used, especially in telecom and large enterprises. However, its growth has slowed as public cloud adoption increased. Kubernetes has seen much faster adoption.
Which is better for a small business? For a small business, Kubernetes (especially managed) is usually more practical. OpenStack requires significant infrastructure and expertise that most small teams don’t have.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Arctic Sea Ice Forecasts Disagree: What to Do
- MySQL Workbench to VPS: SSH Tunnel Setup
- Bluesky Beginners Guide: How to Get Started5.00 min/km
- LG V20 Won’t Turn On? Fixed
- Snagit vs Camtasia: Which One Do You Need?
- Scale a Small Business Without Losing Culture