Loom vs Scribe: Which Matches Your Workflow?

Loom and Scribe both record your screen, but they answer different questions. Loom captures a video of you talking through a task, while Scribe auto-generates a step-by-step written guide with screenshots as you perform the task. Choose Loom when you want to explain context or walk someone through a decision; choose Scribe when you need a repeatable, documented procedure.

What Loom Is Best At

Loom is a video messaging tool. You record your screen, your face (optional), and your voice. It is ideal for:

Explaining a bug or a design decision with tone and nuance.
Giving feedback on a document or a design file.
Walking a new hire through a workflow that requires judgment, not just clicks.
Asynchronous stand-up updates where you want to show your screen.

The key advantage is context. A video can convey hesitation, emphasis, and side comments that a written guide cannot. It also feels more personal, which helps remote teams build rapport.

What Scribe Is Best At

Scribe is a documentation tool. You install a browser extension or desktop app, press record, and perform a task. Scribe captures your clicks and keystrokes, then generates a step-by-step guide with annotated screenshots. It is ideal for:

Standard operating procedures (SOPs) that must be followed exactly.
Onboarding documentation for software your team uses daily.
Compliance or audit trails where you need a clear, reproducible process.
Handoffs where the recipient needs to do the task themselves, not just watch.

The main advantage is precision. Each step is a numbered action with a screenshot. There is no ambiguity about what to click. Scribes are also searchable and easy to edit, which makes them living documents.

How to Choose for Your Agency

Your agency’s size, client type, and team culture matter. Here is a practical decision framework:

Ask what the recipient will do with the recording. If they will watch once and then act, Loom works. If they will reference it repeatedly, Scribe is better.
Consider the shelf life. A Loom video explaining a one-off client meeting is fine. A Scribe documenting your monthly reporting process will be used for years.
Think about editing. Loom videos are hard to edit; a mistake means re-recording. Scribes can be edited like a word document, and you can re-capture individual steps.
Evaluate your team’s comfort. Some people freeze on camera. Scribe removes that pressure entirely.
Check your storage. Video files are large. If your agency uses a shared drive with limited space, Scribe is more economical.

Many agencies use both: Loom for client communication, Scribe for internal processes. That is a reasonable approach if you have the budget.

Common Problems and Misconceptions

A frequent misconception is that Scribe is a screen recorder like Loom. It is not. Scribe does not record video; it records actions. If you want to show a video of a process, Scribe will not do that. Conversely, if you need a written guide, Loom will not generate one automatically.

Another issue is that Loom videos can become outdated quickly. If your software changes, the video may show old screens. Scribes can be updated by re-recording a single step, but Loom requires a full re-record. Also, Loom videos are not searchable within the video; you have to rely on titles and descriptions. Scribes are full-text searchable, which is a huge advantage for large documentation libraries.

Costs and Storage

Both tools have free tiers with limitations. Loom’s free plan caps video length (typically 5 minutes) and stores a limited number of videos. Scribe’s free plan allows a limited number of Scribes per month. Paid plans remove these limits and add features like custom branding, password protection, and viewer analytics. For an agency, the cost is usually justified if the tool saves even a few hours per month. Scribe documents are tiny, often under 1 MB.

Alternatives to Consider

If you need video, alternatives include ScreenPal (formerly Screencast-O-Matic), OBS Studio (free and open-source), and Clipchamp (built into Windows). For documentation, Tango is a direct Scribe competitor, and Notion has a built-in “capture” feature for creating step-by-step guides. For a more manual approach, you can use a screenshot tool like Snagit and paste images into a Word or Google Doc. Each has trade-offs in price, ease of use, and editing capability.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use Loom to create a written guide?

Not automatically. Loom provides a transcript of your video, but it is not formatted as a step-by-step guide. You would have to manually copy the transcript and add screenshots. Scribe does this automatically.

Can Scribe record my voice?

No, Scribe does not record audio. It only captures screenshots and clicks. If you need voice narration, use Loom or a separate audio recorder.

Which tool is better for client-facing tutorials?

It depends on the client. If the client prefers to watch a video, Loom is better. If they want a PDF they can print or share internally, Scribe is better. Some agencies provide both: a Scribe for the steps and a Loom for the “why.”

Do these tools work on both Mac and Windows?

Yes, both Loom and Scribe have desktop apps for macOS and Windows, and both have browser extensions for Chrome and Edge. Scribe also has a mobile app for iOS and Android, while Loom’s mobile app is more limited.

Can I password-protect a Loom or Scribe?

Both offer password protection on paid plans. On free plans, videos and Scribes are viewable by anyone with the link, so be careful with sensitive client data.

Which tool is easier to edit?

Scribe is easier to edit because you can change text, reorder steps, and replace screenshots. Loom allows trimming the beginning and end of a video, but you cannot edit out a mistake in the middle without re-recording.

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →