keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

MPLS vs SD-WAN: How to Choose

Card No. 06·78521 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

Choosing between MPLS and SD-WAN comes down to one central question: does your network traffic mostly flow between fixed offices, or does it increasingly involve cloud services and remote users? If your traffic is predominantly office-to-office, MPLS still works well; if a significant share of traffic is headed to the internet or cloud, SD-WAN is usually the better fit. Below is a detailed comparison of how each technology works, what they cost, and how to match them to your organization’s needs.

What MPLS Is and How It Works

MPLS (Multiprotocol Label Switching) is a private WAN technology that carriers have offered for decades. Instead of routing each packet based on the destination IP address, MPLS attaches short labels to packets at the edge of the network. Routers inside the carrier’s backbone forward packets based on those labels, which allows traffic to follow predetermined paths. That label-based forwarding gives MPLS two big advantages: predictable performance and strong traffic isolation. Because the carrier provisions a fixed amount of bandwidth for your circuits, latency and packet loss are typically stable, and your traffic never shares a queue with public internet traffic.

MPLS circuits are usually sold as point-to-point or any-to-any connections between your offices. You buy a specific bandwidth (for example, 50 Mbps) at each site, and the carrier guarantees that capacity. This is why MPLS is often described as a “guaranteed” WAN: the SLA (service-level agreement) covers latency, jitter, and packet loss. For real-time voice and video between offices, that guarantee is valuable.

What SD-WAN Is and How It Works

SD-WAN (Software-Defined Wide Area Network) is a newer approach that uses software to manage traffic over any mix of transport links—broadband internet, LTE/5G, or even MPLS. An SD-WAN appliance at each site establishes secure tunnels (usually IPsec) to the other sites or to cloud gateways. The central controller or orchestrator defines policies that decide which path each type of traffic uses. For example, voice traffic might be sent over a low-latency MPLS link, while bulk file transfers go over cheap broadband.

SD-WAN does not guarantee bandwidth in the same way MPLS does. It relies on the underlying links, which are often ordinary internet connections. However, SD-WAN compensates with active monitoring and path selection: if one link degrades, the appliance shifts traffic to another link in milliseconds. This makes SD-WAN more resilient to a single failed circuit, but it cannot create bandwidth that does not exist.

Key Differences at a Glance

  • Traffic routing: MPLS forces all traffic through the carrier’s backbone; SD-WAN can route each flow independently over any available link.
  • Cloud access: MPLS typically backhauls internet traffic to a central hub, adding latency; SD-WAN breaks out directly to the internet at each site, reducing latency.
  • Cost: MPLS circuits are more expensive per Mbps, especially for international links; SD-WAN over broadband is often a fraction of the cost.
  • Deployment time: MPLS can take weeks or months to provision; SD-WAN can be deployed in days by plugging in an appliance and connecting to the controller.
  • Flexibility: MPLS bandwidth is fixed at purchase; SD-WAN can use multiple links and adjust as needs change.
  • Security: MPLS is inherently private; SD-WAN adds encryption (IPsec) over public links, which is secure but requires proper configuration.

How to Choose: A Decision Framework

There is no universal answer, but you can narrow it down by answering a few questions:

  1. Where does your traffic go? If 80% of your traffic is to the internet or SaaS apps (Office 365, Salesforce, Zoom), SD-WAN is almost always better because it allows direct internet breakout. If most traffic is between your own data centers, MPLS may be simpler and more predictable.
  2. What is your latency tolerance? For real-time voice and video, MPLS offers a guaranteed SLA. SD-WAN can also support real-time traffic, but you need enough bandwidth on your best link and a good implementation of QoS and forward error correction.
  3. How fast do you need to deploy? If you are opening a new office next month, SD-WAN can be up in days with a simple internet connection. MPLS requires a carrier visit and circuit provisioning, which can take 30–90 days.
  4. What is your existing equipment? If you already have MPLS and it works well, you can keep it and add SD-WAN for cloud traffic. Many organizations run a hybrid: MPLS for critical office-to-office traffic, SD-WAN for internet and cloud.

Common Problems and Misconceptions

A frequent misconception is that SD-WAN is always faster than MPLS. In reality, SD-WAN is only as fast as the underlying links. If you buy 100 Mbps broadband and your MPLS is 50 Mbps, SD-WAN can carry more traffic, but if the broadband is congested, performance drops. Another misconception is that MPLS is obsolete. It is not—many enterprises still use MPLS for core connectivity, especially in regions where broadband is unreliable.

Another common problem is that SD-WAN vendors oversell “self-healing” capabilities. While SD-WAN can failover between links, it cannot fix a link that is completely down if you have only one internet connection. You need at least two diverse links for redundancy. Also, SD-WAN does not replace your firewall; you still need security at the edge.

Cost Comparison and ROI

Cost is often the deciding factor. A typical MPLS circuit at 100 Mbps might cost $500–$1,500 per month depending on region and carrier. The same bandwidth over business broadband might cost $100–$300 per month. For 10 sites, that difference adds up to tens of thousands of dollars per year. However, MPLS costs include the SLA and managed service, which reduce the need for IT staff to troubleshoot. SD-WAN requires you to manage the appliances and the underlying internet connections, though many providers offer managed SD-WAN services for an additional fee.

The total cost of ownership should include hardware, licensing, management, and support, not just the monthly circuit fee.

Security Considerations

MPLS is a private network, so your traffic does not traverse the public internet. That gives a degree of inherent security, but it does not make you immune to attacks—your traffic is still visible to the carrier’s staff, and you still need firewalls and encryption for sensitive data. SD-WAN uses IPsec tunnels over the internet, which encrypts traffic in transit. That is generally considered secure, but the encryption adds a small amount of overhead. Also, SD-WAN often includes a stateful firewall and segmentation features, which can improve security compared to a flat MPLS network.

One important caution: do not assume SD-WAN is secure just because it is encrypted. You must configure access controls, update firmware, and monitor for threats. The security of your WAN depends more on your team’s practices than on the technology.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use SD-WAN over MPLS?

Yes, many organizations do exactly that. SD-WAN can use MPLS as one of its transport links, alongside broadband and LTE. This gives you the reliability of MPLS for critical traffic and the cost savings of broadband for less sensitive traffic. It is a common hybrid deployment.

Is SD-WAN cheaper than MPLS?

Generally, yes, because SD-WAN can run over inexpensive broadband internet connections. The monthly circuit cost is often 50–80% lower than MPLS for the same bandwidth. However, you may need to buy SD-WAN appliances and possibly a management subscription, which adds upfront and recurring costs. Over a 3-year period, SD-WAN is usually still cheaper.

Does SD-WAN replace my firewall?

No. SD-WAN appliances often include basic firewall features, but they are not a substitute for a full next-generation firewall. You should still deploy a firewall at each site or in the cloud to enforce security policies, inspect traffic, and block threats.

What is the biggest downside of MPLS?

The biggest downside is cost and inflexibility. MPLS circuits are expensive, especially for high bandwidth, and provisioning takes time. Also, MPLS typically backhauls internet traffic to a central location, which adds latency for cloud apps. That is why many companies are moving away from MPLS for internet-bound traffic.

How long does it take to deploy SD-WAN?

In a simple branch deployment, you can have SD-WAN running in a few hours: connect the appliance to the internet, register it with the controller, and apply policies. For a full rollout across many sites, it may take weeks, but that is still much faster than MPLS, which can take 30–90 days per circuit.

Do I need to keep MPLS if I move to SD-WAN?

Not necessarily. Many organizations replace MPLS entirely with SD-WAN over broadband and LTE. However, if you have strict latency requirements or operate in regions with poor internet infrastructure, keeping MPLS as a backup or primary link for critical traffic can be wise. The decision depends on your specific reliability needs.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →