keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Petrol vs Diesel Cars: UK Running Costs Compared

Card No. 06·79565 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

In the UK, diesel cars are generally cheaper to own and run than petrol cars if you cover high annual mileage, but petrol cars are cheaper for most drivers doing average or low mileage. This is because diesel fuel is usually slightly cheaper per litre, and diesel engines are more efficient, but they cost more to buy, insure, and maintain.

How Fuel Costs Compare

Diesel fuel typically costs a few pence less per litre than petrol, though the gap fluctuates with global oil prices and fuel duty changes. More importantly, diesel engines are around 15-20% more thermally efficient than petrol engines, meaning they extract more energy from each litre of fuel. A typical diesel car might achieve 55-65 mpg on a mixed commute, while an equivalent petrol car manages 40-50 mpg. Over a year of driving, this difference adds up significantly.

For example, if you drive 12,000 miles per year and petrol costs £1.45 per litre while diesel costs £1.40 per litre, the fuel cost for a petrol car at 45 mpg would be about £1,750, while a diesel at 55 mpg would cost about £1,390 – a saving of roughly £360 per year. That saving grows with higher mileage.

Purchase Price and Depreciation

Diesel cars are typically £1,500 to £3,000 more expensive to buy new than their petrol equivalents. The same applies to used cars, though the gap narrows with age. Depreciation is also a factor: diesels used to hold their value better, but recent changes in emission zones and anti-diesel sentiment have made petrol cars hold value more strongly in some segments. Over five years, a diesel may lose more of its initial value in percentage terms, but if you buy used, the higher upfront cost is already baked in.

Running Costs: Insurance, Tax, and Servicing

Insurance groups for diesel versions are often one or two groups higher than petrol, adding roughly 5-10% to your premium. Vehicle Excise Duty (road tax) depends on CO2 emissions – modern diesels often emit less CO2 than equivalent petrols, so they can be in a lower tax band, but older diesels (pre-2016) may face higher rates. Servicing costs are generally higher for diesels due to more complex components like diesel particulate filters (DPF) and turbochargers, plus they often require more frequent oil changes. Over 60,000 miles, a diesel might cost £300-£500 more in maintenance than a petrol.

Maintenance and Common Problems

Diesel engines have several components that petrol engines do not, and these can be expensive to fix. The DPF is a common issue – it needs regular long motorway runs to regenerate, and if it becomes blocked, replacement costs £1,000 or more. EGR valves and turbochargers also fail more often on diesels. Petrol engines are simpler and generally more reliable in short-stop city driving. However, modern petrols with turbochargers and direct injection have their own potential issues, such as carbon build-up on intake valves.

How to Choose: Mileage and Driving Style

Your annual mileage is the single biggest factor in deciding between petrol and diesel. As a rough guide:

  • Under 8,000 miles per year – petrol is usually cheaper overall
  • 8,000-12,000 miles – it’s close, but petrol may still edge it
  • Over 12,000 miles, especially with motorway driving – diesel often wins on total cost

Also consider your typical journey type. Diesel engines need to warm up to work efficiently and to regenerate the DPF, so they are not ideal for lots of short trips. If you mostly drive in cities or stop-start traffic, a petrol car is more practical and will likely have lower running costs.

Environmental and Regulatory Considerations

Diesel cars produce less CO2 than petrol, but they emit more nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter, which are harmful to air quality. Many UK cities have introduced Clean Air Zones or Ultra Low Emission Zones (ULEZ) that charge older diesel cars daily fees. For example, London’s ULEZ charges £12.50 per day for non-compliant vehicles, which can add up quickly if you drive into the zone regularly. If you live or work in such an area, this cost can easily outweigh any fuel savings from a diesel.

Alternatives: Hybrid and Electric

If you’re considering a new car, hybrids and electric vehicles (EVs) are increasingly competitive. A plug-in hybrid can offer very low running costs for short commutes, while an EV costs around 3-5 pence per mile in electricity versus 15-20 pence for petrol or diesel. However, EVs have a higher upfront cost and require access to charging. For many drivers, a hybrid is a good compromise, but if you do long motorway journeys, a modern diesel may still be the most cost-effective option.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is diesel cheaper than petrol per litre in the UK?

Historically, diesel was cheaper than petrol, but in recent years the prices have been very close, and sometimes petrol is cheaper. The difference is usually only 1-3 pence per litre, so it’s not a major factor in the overall decision.

How many miles per year makes a diesel worth it?

As a rule of thumb, you need to drive at least 12,000 miles per year to make the higher purchase price and maintenance costs of a diesel worthwhile. If you do a lot of motorway driving, the break-even point can be lower, around 10,000 miles.

Do diesel cars have higher repair costs than petrol?

Yes, generally. Diesel engines have more complex components like the DPF, EGR valve, and turbocharger, which can be expensive to repair or replace. Regular maintenance, such as oil changes, may also be more frequent and cost more.

Are diesel cars being banned in the UK?

There is no outright ban on diesel cars, but some cities have introduced charges for older, more polluting vehicles. The UK government has announced a ban on the sale of new petrol and diesel cars from 2035, which means you can still buy and drive used diesels after that date, but new ones won’t be available.

What is the resale value of diesel vs petrol cars?

Depreciation rates vary by model and market conditions. Currently, petrol cars tend to hold their value better than diesels because of concerns about emission zones and future restrictions. However, larger diesel cars that are popular with high-mileage drivers can still have strong resale values.

Can I save money by buying a used diesel car?

Yes, if you buy a used diesel, you avoid the steepest part of depreciation. However, you should check whether it’s compliant with any local emission zones and factor in potential repair costs for older diesel components like the DPF.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →