Roadside assistance and towing are two distinct services: roadside assistance brings help to your vehicle at its current location for minor issues, while towing transports your vehicle to another location, usually a repair shop. You call roadside assistance for a flat tire or dead battery, but you need a tow when your car cannot be safely driven or fixed on the spot.
Formula
The calculator estimates the cost of a tow truck trip. The formula is:
Cost = Distance × Rate per mile
Where:
- Distance (miles) is how far the vehicle is towed.
- Rate per mile ($/mile) is what the towing company charges per mile.
The second output shows approximate time assuming an average towing speed of 45 mph (including loading and traffic).
Worked Example
Using the default values: distance = 15 miles, rate = $5 per mile.
- Multiply distance by rate: 15 × 5 = 75.
- The estimated towing cost is $75.00.
- Time estimate: (15 / 45) × 60 = 20 minutes.
So towing a car 15 miles at $5/mile costs about $75 and takes roughly 20 minutes.
What Roadside Assistance Covers
Roadside assistance is a service you call when your vehicle has a problem that can be fixed at the scene. Common covered services include:
- Jump-starting a dead battery
- Changing a flat tire with your spare
- Delivering a small amount of fuel if you run out
- Lockout assistance if you lock your keys inside
- Minor mechanical repairs, like a loose hose
Most roadside assistance plans include a limited amount of towing, often 5 to 10 miles, as part of the membership. Beyond that limit, you pay per mile.
What Towing Covers
Towing is a separate service that moves your vehicle from one place to another. You need a tow when:
- The car won’t start and can’t be jump-started
- The engine overheats and cannot be safely driven
- The transmission fails
- The vehicle is in an accident and cannot be driven
- You need to transport a non-running car to a shop or home
Towing companies charge a hook-up fee plus a per-mile rate. The national average is about $5 per mile, but rates vary by region and time of day. Heavy-duty towing for trucks or RVs costs more.
Key Differences at a Glance
| Aspect | Roadside Assistance | Towing |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Fix at the scene | Transport to another location |
| Typical duration | 15–45 minutes | 30 minutes to several hours |
| Cost | Often included in membership | Hook-up fee + per-mile charge |
| When needed | Flat tire, dead battery, lockout | Accident, major breakdown |
| Equipment | Service truck with tools | Flatbed or wheel-lift tow truck |
How to Choose Between Them
Ask yourself: can the problem be fixed where the car is parked? If yes, call roadside assistance. If no, call a tow truck.
Consider these factors:
- Safety: If you’re on a busy highway, it’s safer to have the car towed to a shop than to attempt a repair on the shoulder.
- Cost: Roadside assistance is usually cheaper than a tow, especially if you have a membership.
- Time: A tire change takes 20 minutes; a tow to a shop might take an hour or more.
- Your skill level: If you don’t know how to change a tire, roadside assistance is the right call.
Common Problems and Misconceptions
One common misconception is that roadside assistance includes unlimited towing. In reality, most plans cap towing at 5–10 miles; beyond that, you pay out of pocket. Another is that all tow trucks are the same—flatbed trucks are safer for all-wheel-drive and low-clearance vehicles, while wheel-lift trucks are cheaper but may not be suitable for every car.
Another issue: some drivers call roadside assistance for a problem that requires a tow, wasting time. For example, if your engine seizes, a jump-start won’t help—you need a tow. Conversely, calling a tow truck for a flat tire when you have a spare is overkill and costs more.
Cost Comparison
Roadside assistance memberships typically cost $50–$150 per year and include services like tire changes and jump-starts. A single tow without membership can cost $75–$250 depending on distance. If you use roadside assistance even once, the membership often pays for itself.
Some auto insurance policies include roadside assistance as an add-on, and credit cards may offer it as a perk. Always check what your policy covers before you need it.
Safety Tips When Stranded
Whether you need roadside assistance or a tow, safety comes first:
- Pull over as far from traffic as possible, ideally past a guardrail or onto the shoulder.
- Turn on hazard lights and set up reflective triangles if you have them.
- Stay inside the vehicle with doors locked if you’re on a highway; call for help on your phone.
- If a stranger stops to help, roll the window down slightly and ask them to call a professional instead of accepting a ride.
- When the tow truck arrives, verify the driver’s identity and that they are from the company you called.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does roadside assistance include towing?
Most roadside assistance plans include a limited amount of towing, usually 5 to 10 miles. If your car needs to be towed farther, you pay the difference per mile. Some premium plans offer longer towing distances.
How much does a tow truck cost per mile?
The average is about $5 per mile, but it can range from $2 to $10 depending on your location, time of day, and vehicle type. There is also a hook-up fee of $50–$150 before the mileage charge.
Can I use roadside assistance for a car that won’t start?
Yes, if the problem is a dead battery or a minor issue. The technician will try a jump-start. If the car still won’t start, they may recommend a tow to a shop.
Is it cheaper to join a roadside assistance plan or pay per use?
If you use roadside assistance once a year, a membership is usually cheaper than paying for a single tow. If you never break down, you might not recoup the cost. Consider your driving habits and vehicle age.
What’s the difference between a flatbed and a wheel-lift tow truck?
A flatbed truck carries the entire vehicle on a flat platform, which is safer for all-wheel-drive cars and low-clearance sports cars. A wheel-lift truck lifts the front or rear wheels off the ground, which is cheaper but can damage some drivetrains.