keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Roman Space Telescope vs Euclid: Mission Goals

Card No. 06·78757 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

The Roman Space Telescope (Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope) and Euclid are both space observatories designed to study dark energy, dark matter, and the expansion of the universe, but they use different instruments, wavelengths, and survey strategies to achieve complementary goals. Roman focuses on high-resolution infrared imaging and spectroscopy of distant supernovae, exoplanets, and galaxies, while Euclid specializes in wide-field visible and near-infrared imaging and spectroscopy to map the large-scale structure of the universe and measure cosmic shear. Together, they will provide the most detailed 3D map of the cosmos ever created, helping astronomers understand why the universe’s expansion is accelerating.

Background: Why Two Dark Energy Missions?

Dark energy, the mysterious force driving the accelerated expansion of the universe, was discovered in 1998 through observations of distant supernovae. Since then, astronomers have sought to measure its properties with increasing precision. The Roman Space Telescope (formerly WFIRST, renamed in 2020 after NASA astronomer Nancy Grace Roman) and Euclid (an ESA mission with NASA contributions) are both designed to tackle this puzzle, but they were conceived with different strengths.

Euclid launched in July 2023 and began science operations in early 2024. It is designed to survey a vast portion of the sky—about 15,000 square degrees—using a 1.2-meter mirror and two instruments: a visible-light imager (VIS) and a near-infrared spectrometer and photometer (NISP). Roman, scheduled to launch by May 2027, will have a 2.4-meter mirror (the same size as Hubble’s) and a much narrower field of view, but with higher resolution and sensitivity in the infrared.

Primary Science Goals: Dark Energy and Dark Matter

Both missions aim to answer the same fundamental questions: What is dark energy? How has it changed over time? What is the nature of dark matter? However, they use different observational techniques to get there.

  • Euclid primarily uses two methods: weak gravitational lensing (measuring how dark matter distorts light from distant galaxies) and baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO, the imprint of sound waves in the early universe on the distribution of galaxies). By mapping the shapes and positions of billions of galaxies, Euclid will create a 3D map of dark matter and trace the expansion history.
  • Roman also uses weak lensing and BAO, but its key strength is supernova distance measurements. It will find thousands of Type Ia supernovae in the infrared, which are more uniform and less affected by dust than in visible light. Roman will also measure the growth of cosmic structure through the clustering of galaxies.

How They Work: Instruments and Orbits

Euclid is placed at the Sun-Earth L2 Lagrange point, about 1.5 million km from Earth, where it can observe the sky without interference from Earth’s infrared glow. Its visible imager (VIS) takes ultra-sharp images of galaxies to measure their shapes, while NISP splits infrared light into spectra to measure galaxy distances and redshifts.

Roman will also orbit L2, but its 2.4-meter mirror gives it a resolution comparable to Hubble’s, yet with a field of view 100 times larger than Hubble’s infrared camera. It will carry two instruments: the Wide Field Instrument (WFI) for imaging and slitless spectroscopy, and the Coronagraph Instrument for directly imaging exoplanets by blocking starlight.

Key Differences: Field of View vs. Resolution

The most significant difference is the trade-off between field of view and resolution. Euclid’s camera covers a huge patch of sky (0.57 square degrees per exposure), allowing it to survey 15,000 square degrees in about six years. Roman’s WFI covers 0.28 square degrees per exposure, but with finer pixel scale (0.11 arcseconds vs. Euclid’s 0.1 arcseconds for VIS, though Roman’s infrared resolution is sharper).

In practice, Euclid will map the large-scale distribution of galaxies over a broad area, while Roman will zoom into specific regions to study detailed shapes, measure supernovae, and follow up on Euclid’s discoveries. They are designed to complement each other: Euclid provides the wide-angle view, Roman provides the close-up.

Exoplanets: Roman’s Unique Addition

While Euclid is purely a cosmology mission, Roman includes a coronagraph instrument to directly image exoplanets and debris disks. This is a major difference. The coronagraph will block the light from a host star to reveal faint planets orbiting it, testing new technology for future missions. Roman’s exoplanet program also includes microlensing surveys to detect planets by the gravitational bending of light from a background star. Euclid has no exoplanet capability.

When to Use Which? Complementary Roles

Astronomers will combine data from both missions. For example, Euclid’s wide survey will identify thousands of galaxy clusters and lensing events; Roman will then observe the most interesting ones in detail. For supernova cosmology, Roman’s infrared observations are more precise than Euclid’s, but Euclid’s larger sample of galaxies for lensing will provide independent constraints. The missions are not competitors but partners.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which telescope is more powerful?

Power depends on the task. Roman has a larger mirror and higher resolution, making it better for detailed imaging and spectroscopy of individual objects. Euclid has a much wider field of view, making it better for surveying vast areas of sky quickly. They are equally powerful in their respective niches.

Will Roman replace Euclid?

No. They are complementary. Euclid launched earlier and is already collecting data; Roman will launch later and focus on different observations. Together they will provide a more complete picture than either could alone.

Can they see dark matter directly?

No, dark matter does not emit light. Both missions detect its effects through gravitational lensing—the bending of light from distant galaxies by the gravity of dark matter. By mapping the distorted shapes of galaxies, they create a map of where dark matter lies.

How do they measure dark energy?

They measure the expansion rate of the universe at different times in the past. One method is to observe Type Ia supernovae (standard candles) to measure distances; another is to measure BAO (the scale of galaxy clustering) and weak lensing (how dark matter shapes the growth of structure). Comparing these measurements tells us how dark energy has influenced expansion.

What is the cost of each mission?

Roman’s cost is estimated at about $4 billion (NASA’s total mission cost). Euclid’s cost is about €1.4 billion (ESA’s cost, including launch). These are public figures from space agencies.

When will we see results?

Euclid’s early data releases have already begun in 2024, with full survey data expected over the next few years. Roman is scheduled to launch by May 2027, with first science data likely in 2028. Cosmological results will accumulate over several years.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →