Yes, Samsung Foundry has struggled with its 3nm process, facing lower yields and fewer major customers than initially expected. While Samsung was the first to mass-produce 3nm gate-all-around (GAA) chips in mid-2022, the process has not yet achieved the production efficiency or market adoption needed to challenge TSMC’s dominance.
Background: Samsung’s 3nm Ambitions
Samsung Foundry, the contract chip manufacturing arm of Samsung Electronics, has long aimed to overtake TSMC in the race for smaller, more efficient semiconductors. In June 2022, Samsung announced the mass production of its 3nm process using GAA transistors, a first in the industry. This was a significant technical milestone, leapfrogging TSMC, which planned to stick with FinFET transistors for its own 3nm node. The move was seen as a bold attempt to win high-profile clients like Qualcomm, NVIDIA, and AMD, who currently rely heavily on TSMC.
How 3nm GAA Transistors Work
To understand Samsung’s struggle, you need to know what makes 3nm GAA different. Traditional transistors use a FinFET design, where the conducting channel is a vertical fin surrounded by the gate. In a GAA (Gate-All-Around) transistor, the gate wraps completely around the channel, typically using horizontal nanosheets. This provides better electrostatic control, reducing leakage current and improving performance at the same power. Samsung’s 3nm GAA process (named 3GAE) was designed to offer up to a 45% power reduction, a 23% performance boost, and a 16% area reduction compared to its 5nm process. However, this complexity also makes manufacturing harder and more sensitive to defects.
Yield Problems: The Core Issue
The primary struggle for Samsung’s 3nm has been yield – the percentage of usable chips on a wafer. Early reports from industry analysts suggested yields were stuck around 10-20% for the most complex chips, far below the 60-70% needed for mass production profitability. Even by late 2023, yields were reported to have improved to around 50-60%, but this still lagged behind TSMC’s more mature 3nm process, which had yields in the 70-80% range. Low yields mean higher costs per chip, making Samsung’s 3nm uncompetitive for large-volume orders from major customers.
Customer Attraction: Who’s Using It?
Because of yield issues and performance concerns, Samsung’s 3nm has attracted few major customers. The only confirmed large-scale user is Samsung’s own System LSI division, which uses 3nm for its Exynos processors (like the Exynos 2400 in the Galaxy S24 series in some markets). Other potential customers, such as Qualcomm, have reportedly chosen TSMC for their flagship chips. For instance, the Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 and 8 Gen 4 are manufactured on TSMC’s 3nm and 4nm processes. NVIDIA and AMD also continue to use TSMC for their high-end GPUs and CPUs. The lack of external customers means Samsung cannot spread the development and production costs, slowing the learning curve and improvements.
Comparison: Samsung 3nm vs. TSMC 3nm
It’s helpful to compare the two foundries’ approaches:
- Transistor type: Samsung uses GAA (nanosheet); TSMC uses FinFET for its N3 node (with GAA planned for 2nm).
- Performance: TSMC’s N3 offers roughly 10-15% performance gain at the same power, or 25-30% power reduction at the same speed, compared to its N5. Samsung’s 3GAE claims similar numbers, but real-world results have been less impressive.
- Yield: TSMC’s 3nm yield is notably higher (reported to be above 70% for some designs), while Samsung’s is still catching up.
- Customers: TSMC’s 3nm is used by Apple (A17 Pro, M3), Qualcomm, NVIDIA, and AMD. Samsung’s is mostly self-supplied.
This comparison shows that while Samsung was technically first, TSMC’s process is more mature and reliable, which is what chip designers prioritize.
Common Problems and Misconceptions
One common misconception is that Samsung’s 3nm is a failure in absolute terms. In reality, it works and is used in some products, but it’s not competitive enough for the high-end market. Another issue is the confusion between Samsung’s 3nm GAA and its older 4nm process. Some chips labeled as “4nm” (like the Snapdragon 8 Gen 1) were made on Samsung’s 4nm, which had thermal and efficiency problems, hurting Samsung’s reputation. The 3nm is a different node, but the trust deficit remains. Additionally, Samsung has faced challenges with its GAA design ecosystem – EDA tools and IP libraries were not fully optimized for GAA, making it harder for customers to design chips for Samsung’s process.
Alternatives and the Road Ahead
For customers, the main alternative to Samsung 3nm is TSMC’s 3nm and 4nm processes. TSMC’s 4nm is actually a refined 5nm node and is used for many mid-range and some flagship chips. For Samsung itself, the next step is its 2nm GAA process, planned for mass production in 2025. Samsung is hoping that the lessons learned from 3nm will make 2nm more successful. However, the company faces an uphill battle: it needs to prove to customers that its yields are stable and its process is reliable. Some analysts suggest that Samsung might even skip full 3nm production for external customers and focus on 2nm, but that remains speculative.
How to Choose a Foundry (For Chip Designers)
If you were a chip designer, choosing between Samsung and TSMC would depend on several factors:
- Yield and Reliability: TSMC currently offers higher yields, reducing cost per die.
- Performance/Power: Both offer similar specs on paper, but TSMC’s process has proven better in real silicon.
- Design Support: TSMC has a more mature ecosystem of IP and EDA tools.
- Capacity and Flexibility: Samsung might offer more flexible capacity for smaller orders, but TSMC has more total capacity.
- Cost: Samsung often offers lower wafer prices to attract customers, but low yields can negate that advantage.
Ultimately, for most high-performance applications, TSMC is the safer choice today.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is Samsung’s 3nm process a complete failure?
A: No, it’s not a complete failure. It is in production and used in Samsung’s own Exynos chips. However, it has not met expectations in terms of yield and customer adoption, making it commercially less successful than TSMC’s 3nm.
Q: Why is Samsung’s 3nm yield so low?
A: The GAA transistor architecture is more complex to manufacture than FinFETs. The process involves stacking nanosheets and removing sacrificial layers, which creates more opportunities for defects. Samsung is still learning to control these processes at scale.
Q: Will Samsung’s 3nm improve over time?
A: Yes, yields typically improve as a process matures. Samsung has already increased yields from around 20% to 50-60% over a year. However, it remains to be seen if it can reach the level needed to attract major customers like Qualcomm or NVIDIA.
Q: Does Samsung use 3nm in its own phones?
A: Yes, Samsung uses its 3nm GAA process for the Exynos 2400 chip in the Galaxy S24 series sold in some regions (like Europe and South Korea). In other regions, the phone uses a Qualcomm Snapdragon chip made by TSMC.
Q: What is the difference between 3nm and 4nm?
A: The “nm” number is a marketing label, not a physical measurement. In general, a smaller node means denser transistors and better efficiency. Samsung’s 3nm is a new architecture (GAA), while its 4nm is an evolution of FinFET. However, the actual performance difference can be small, and yield issues can make 4nm more practical.
Q: Is TSMC’s 3nm better than Samsung’s?
A: Currently, yes. TSMC’s 3nm has higher yields, better performance in real products (like Apple’s A17 Pro), and a more robust ecosystem. Samsung was first to mass-produce 3nm, but TSMC’s process is more mature and commercially successful.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Use Mac More Efficiently: 21 Proven Tips
- Best CPUs for Gaming and Streaming: Encoder Guide
- How to Compare AI Features and Performance in Phones
- Nginx Blocks in CentOS: Config Guide
- Create Google Meet Account: Step-by-Step Guide
- AI Frameworks: How Developers Choose and Ship Them