Old games should generally be remade only when the original is genuinely inaccessible or technically broken on modern hardware, and left alone when the remake would strip away what made the game special. A good remake preserves the core experience while updating usability; a bad one replaces it with a modern game wearing a familiar name. The real question isn’t whether remakes are good or bad—it’s which games need them and how the work is done.
Why Remakes Happen
Remakes exist for three main reasons: preservation, profit, and creative ambition. Preservation-driven remakes (like Shadow of the Colossus on PS4) update graphics while keeping the gameplay intact. Profit-driven remakes (like Final Fantasy VII Remake) expand a beloved story into multiple full-price games. Creative remakes (like Resident Evil 2 2019) reinterpret the original with new mechanics and a new tone. All three can be valid, but they answer different questions. A preservation remake asks, “How do we let people play this today?” A creative remake asks, “How would we make this if we started now?” The audience for each is different, and conflating them leads to disappointment.
The Case for Remaking
The strongest argument for remaking is accessibility. Many classic games are trapped on dead hardware, require CRT televisions, or have controls that feel unplayable by modern standards. A remake can fix that. System Shock (2023) kept the 1994 game’s level design and story but rebuilt the interface, making it playable on modern PCs. Demon’s Souls (2020) did the same for PS5, preserving the original’s difficulty and level structure while updating visuals and performance. These remakes succeed because they remove barriers without changing the experience. They also introduce younger players to games they would never otherwise try, which can create a new audience for the originals.
The Case for Leaving Games Alone
The strongest argument against remaking is that games are products of their time. The blocky polygons of Metal Gear Solid (1998) are not a flaw to be fixed; they are part of its visual language. The tank controls of Resident Evil (1996) were a deliberate design choice that created tension. When a remake smooths these rough edges, it often removes the very friction that made the game memorable. Warcraft III: Reforged (2020) is a cautionary tale: it changed the art style, removed community features, and shipped with bugs, angering fans who had wanted a simple visual upgrade. The original was already playable on modern PCs; the remake solved a problem that didn’t exist and created new ones.
What Makes a Good Remake
A good remake starts with a clear goal. Ask what the original did well and what has aged poorly. The gameplay loop, story, and level design usually age better than graphics, controls, and UI. A good remake updates the latter without altering the former. It also respects the original’s difficulty and pacing. Crash Bandicoot N. Sane Trilogy (2017) kept the exact level layouts and physics, only updating visuals and sound. Black Mesa (2020) expanded Half-Life‘s later levels but kept the core combat and puzzle design. Both were praised because they felt like the originals, only more polished. A good remake also knows when to stop: it doesn’t add new characters, rewrite the story, or turn a 10-hour game into a 40-hour epic unless that was the plan from the start.
When a Remake Is a Bad Idea
A remake is a bad idea when the original is still easily playable and the changes are purely cosmetic. The Last of Us Part I (2022) was a remake of a 2013 game that was already available on PS4 and PC with a remaster. The remake added better graphics and accessibility options, but it did not change the gameplay or story. Many players saw it as a cash grab. A remake is also a bad idea when the original’s flaws are essential to its identity. Silent Hill 2 (2024) kept the original’s story and atmosphere but changed the camera and combat. Some fans felt the new combat made the enemies less terrifying, because the original’s clumsy controls were part of the fear. When you fix the “problems,” you may fix the game out of existence.
Alternatives to Full Remakes
Not every old game needs a full remake. There are several lighter options that preserve the original while making it more accessible:
- Remaster: A visual and performance upgrade that keeps the original code and gameplay. Examples: Halo: The Master Chief Collection, Bioshock Remastered.
- Port: Moving the original to a new platform with minimal changes. Examples: Chrono Trigger on Steam, Final Fantasy IX on Switch.
- Re-release: Making the original available on modern stores, often with emulation. Examples: Super Mario 3D All-Stars, Castlevania Anniversary Collection.
- Fan patch or mod: Community fixes for resolution, controls, and bugs. Examples: Deus Ex Revision, Morrowind OpenMW.
These options are cheaper and faster than a remake, and they keep the original intact. A remaster is often the right choice for a game that is already good but looks dated. A port is right for a game that is unplayable on modern hardware but otherwise fine. A re-release is right for a game that is rare or expensive. Only when these options fail—when the game is truly broken on modern systems or the design is too dated to be enjoyable—should a full remake be considered.
How to Decide for a Specific Game
If you are a developer or publisher considering a remake, or a fan wondering whether your favorite game should get one, work through this checklist:
- Is the original playable on modern hardware? If yes, a remaster or port is usually enough.
- Is the original’s story and gameplay still engaging? If yes, a remake should only update visuals and controls.
- Are the original’s flaws (clunky controls, confusing UI, bad camera) fixable without changing the core loop? If no, a remake may be impossible.
- Is there a large audience that wants to play the game but can’t? If no, a remake may not be worth the cost.
- Can you preserve the original’s tone, difficulty, and pacing? If you feel the need to “modernize” these, you are making a different game.
If the answer to any of the last three questions is “no,” then leaving the game alone is the better choice. The original will still be there for fans, and a bad remake can damage the legacy of a beloved game. If you do remake it, consider also releasing the original alongside it, so players can compare and choose.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do remakes often change the story or characters?
Because the new developers want to make the game “relevant” to modern audiences, or because the original story had plot holes or dated tropes. Sometimes this works (the Resident Evil 2 remake expanded the story without breaking it), but often it alienates fans who wanted the original story. A remake that changes the story is really a reboot, and should be marketed as such.
Are remakes always better than remasters?
No. Remakes are riskier and more expensive, and they can fail by changing too much. Remasters are safer because they preserve the original experience. A remaster is usually the better choice for a game that is still fun to play, while a remake is only necessary when the game is fundamentally broken on modern systems.
What is the difference between a remake and a remaster?
A remaster uses the original code and assets, improving resolution, textures, and performance. A remake builds the game from scratch, often with new assets, code, and sometimes new mechanics. Remasters are cheaper and faster, but they can’t fix deep technical issues. Remakes can, but they risk changing the feel of the game.
Why do some remakes get so much hate?
Because they often change the things fans loved. The Warcraft III: Reforged backlash was about missing features and a changed art style. The GTA: The Trilogy – Definitive Edition backlash was about bugs and a cartoonish look. Fans want the same game with better graphics, not a different game with the same name. When a remake fails to deliver that, the hate is immediate and loud.
Should old games be left alone if they are still playable?
Generally yes. If a game runs on modern hardware and is still enjoyable, a remake is unnecessary. The resources could go to new games or to preserving games that are actually inaccessible. The best way to respect an old game is to make it available and let players experience it as it was, not to replace it with a modern interpretation.
Can a remake ever be better than the original?
Yes, when the original had clear flaws that the remake fixes without losing the essence. Resident Evil 2 (2019) is widely considered better than the 1998 original because it kept the tension and exploration while improving controls and visuals. Metroid: Zero Mission (2004) improved on the original Metroid by adding a map and better controls. The key is that the remake must be a faithful improvement, not a reinvention.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Skip Ryobi and Milwaukee? Harbor Freight Tools to Buy
- Funny Subreddits That Make You Laugh
- Why Retro Gaming Is Still Worth Playing Today
- Sell Your EV Now Before Prices Plummet?
- KDE Connect Vulnerabilities: Are These Versions at Risk?
- Neptune Facts That Will Blow Your Mind