For lunar missions, NASA’s Space Launch System (SLS) is currently the only rocket capable of sending the Orion crew capsule directly to the Moon, making it the better choice for the Artemis program’s near-term crewed landings. However, SpaceX’s Starship, designed for full reusability and in-orbit refueling, offers a more flexible and potentially more cost-effective long-term architecture for sustained lunar exploration. This article compares the two rockets across key criteria to help you understand which is better suited for different lunar mission profiles.
Background: The Two Programs
The Space Launch System (SLS) is NASA’s super heavy-lift rocket, developed under the Artemis program. It uses a core stage with four RS-25 engines (modified Space Shuttle main engines) and two solid rocket boosters, with an upper stage (Interim Cryogenic Propulsion Stage, or ICPS) for trans-lunar injection. SLS is designed to send the Orion capsule, along with up to 27 metric tons of payload, to the Moon in a single launch. Its first uncrewed test flight, Artemis I, launched in November 2022.
Starship is SpaceX’s fully reusable super heavy-lift launch system, consisting of the Super Heavy booster and the Starship spacecraft. It is designed to carry up to 100-150 metric tons to low Earth orbit (LEO) in its expendable configuration, and with orbital refueling, it can send large payloads to the Moon and Mars. As of 2025, Starship has completed several high-altitude and orbital test flights, but it has not yet performed a lunar mission. NASA selected a Starship variant (the Human Landing System, or HLS) to land astronauts on the Moon for Artemis III and Artemis IV.
How Each Rocket Works
SLS works like a classic expendable launch vehicle: it lifts off from the pad, burns its core stage and boosters, then the upper stage places Orion into a trans-lunar trajectory. Orion then performs its own maneuvers to enter lunar orbit and return to Earth. SLS is not reusable; each launch is a complete loss of the hardware.
Starship works differently. The Super Heavy booster separates and returns to the launch site for a powered landing, while the Starship spacecraft continues to orbit. For lunar missions, Starship would be refueled in low Earth orbit by a series of tanker launches, allowing it to travel to the Moon with a full payload. The HLS variant has no heat shield and is not designed to return to Earth; it only shuttles astronauts between lunar orbit and the surface.
Capability Comparison
When comparing raw payload capacity, Starship is the clear winner. SLS Block 1 can send about 27 metric tons to trans-lunar injection (TLI), while Starship, with orbital refueling, can land over 100 metric tons on the lunar surface. This means Starship can deliver habitats, rovers, and large science equipment in one trip, whereas SLS would require multiple launches or smaller payloads.
However, SLS’s advantage is that it can send Orion directly to the Moon with a single launch, which is critical for crew safety and mission simplicity. Orion has a launch abort system and is designed for deep-space reentry, while Starship HLS is not a crew capsule and requires a separate launch of Orion to bring astronauts to lunar orbit.
Cost and Reusability
Cost is a major factor. SLS is estimated to cost around $2 billion per launch (including development costs), and each launch is expendable. Starship is designed to be fully reusable, with the booster and ship returning for multiple flights. SpaceX aims to reduce launch costs to under $10 million per flight eventually, though this has not yet been achieved. For a single lunar mission, SLS may be cheaper than developing Starship’s refueling infrastructure, but for a sustained program with many launches, Starship’s reusability could make it far more economical.
It’s also worth noting that Starship requires a complex in-orbit refueling process, which has not yet been demonstrated. Each lunar mission would need multiple tanker launches (estimates range from 8 to 16) to fill the Starship’s tanks, adding complexity and risk.
Safety and Reliability
SLS is based on proven technology (Space Shuttle-derived components) and has flown once successfully. Orion’s launch abort system provides a high level of crew safety during ascent. Starship, on the other hand, is a new design with no crewed flights yet. Its landing and refueling procedures are untested, and it lacks a launch abort system for the crew (though the HLS variant would not carry crew during launch). For crewed lunar missions, SLS currently offers a safer, more mature option.
Mission Profiles: Which Is Better for What?
- Artemis II (crewed flyby, 2025): SLS is the only option, as it’s the only rocket that can send Orion on a free-return trajectory around the Moon.
- Artemis III (crewed landing, 2026): Both are needed: SLS launches Orion with the crew, and Starship HLS lands them on the surface.
- Artemis Base Camp (sustained presence): Starship is better suited for delivering large habitats, rovers, and supplies due to its high payload capacity.
- Small robotic science missions: SLS’s high cost makes it impractical; smaller commercial rockets like Falcon Heavy are more cost-effective.
Common Misconceptions
One common misconception is that Starship can replace SLS entirely. In reality, Starship HLS cannot return to Earth, so it still needs Orion (launched by SLS) to bring astronauts home. Another misconception is that SLS is obsolete because it’s expendable. For crewed missions, the safety and simplicity of a single-launch architecture may be worth the cost.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can Starship land on the Moon without refueling?
No. Without refueling in low Earth orbit, Starship would not have enough propellant to reach the Moon and land with a meaningful payload. The HLS variant relies on multiple tanker launches to fill its tanks before departing for the Moon.
Is SLS more powerful than Starship?
In terms of thrust at liftoff, SLS Block 1 produces about 39,000 kN, while Super Heavy produces about 74,000 kN, making Starship more powerful. However, SLS is more powerful than Starship for trans-lunar injection because Starship needs to use its own engines to brake into lunar orbit, whereas SLS’s upper stage gives Orion a direct push.
Why does NASA use Starship if SLS is already built?
NASA selected Starship HLS because it could land astronauts on the Moon with a large payload capacity, which SLS alone cannot do. SLS can only send Orion to lunar orbit; it has no lander. Starship fills that gap, and its reusability could lower costs for future missions.
Could Starship be used for Artemis II?
No. Artemis II is a crewed flyby of the Moon using Orion, which requires the SLS rocket. Starship is not designed for Earth reentry with crew, and it has no launch abort system for crewed ascent.
Which rocket will be used for the first crewed lunar landing?
Both. SLS will launch Orion with the crew, and Starship HLS will land them on the Moon. This is the plan for Artemis III, currently scheduled for 2026.
Conclusion
In summary, SLS is better suited for immediate crewed lunar missions that require a proven, safe, and direct path to the Moon. Starship is better suited for future large-scale lunar operations, where its high payload capacity and reusability can enable a sustained presence. For the Artemis program’s first landings, the two rockets are complementary rather than competing.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Funny Subreddits That Make You Laugh
- Why Retro Gaming Is Still Worth Playing Today
- Skip Ryobi and Milwaukee? Harbor Freight Tools to Buy
- Neptune Facts That Will Blow Your Mind
- Survival Crafting Game Fatigue: Why & How to Fix It
- Sell Your EV Now Before Prices Plummet?