keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Squadron 42 vs Star Citizen: Which First?

Card No. 06·81166 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

If you are deciding between Squadron 42 and Star Citizen, play Squadron 42 first if you want a complete, story-driven experience, and play Star Citizen first if you want the open-world multiplayer sandbox. The two games are part of the same universe but serve very different purposes: Squadron 42 is a single-player campaign with a fixed narrative, while Star Citizen is a persistent online universe where you create your own goals.

Background: Two Games, One Universe

Both games are developed by Cloud Imperium Games (CIG) and share the same fictional setting: the United Empire of Earth (UEE) in the 30th century. Squadron 42 was originally pitched as the single-player component of the original Star Citizen crowdfunding campaign in 2012. Over time, it grew into a separate, standalone product. Star Citizen is the massively multiplayer online (MMO) portion, where thousands of players share a single persistent server (or “shard”) and interact in a living universe.

The two games share technology, ships, and lore, but they are distinct purchases. Owning one does not automatically give you the other, though some pledge packages include both. The development of both has been unusually long and public, with continuous crowdfunding and alpha releases. As of 2025, Star Citizen is in a playable alpha state, while Squadron 42 has been shown in trailers but has not yet been released to the public.

How Each Game Works

Squadron 42 is a cinematic, scripted campaign. You play as an elite fighter pilot (customizable character) who joins the UEE Navy and fights against the Vanduul, an alien race. The game features a linear storyline with missions, dialogue choices, and a cast of actors (including Gary Oldman and Mark Hamill). It is designed to be played alone, offline, and at your own pace. Think of it as a space-combat RPG with a beginning, middle, and end.

Star Citizen is a sandbox MMO. You start with a ship and a small amount of credits, and you can do almost anything: trade cargo, mine asteroids, bounty hunt, explore, or just fly around. There is no fixed story; instead, you create your own goals. The game is persistent, meaning your actions affect the shared universe (though wipes have happened during alpha). It is always online, and you will encounter other players and NPCs. The game is still in alpha, so features are added regularly, and bugs are common.

Which Should You Play First?

The answer depends on your preferences, but here is a clear breakdown:

  • Choose Squadron 42 first if: you enjoy story-driven games like Mass Effect or Wing Commander, you want a complete experience without relying on other players, or you are new to space sims and want a guided introduction to the universe and flight mechanics.
  • Choose Star Citizen first if: you love open-world sandboxes like Elite Dangerous or EVE Online, you are comfortable with an unfinished game that changes frequently, or you want to play with friends right away and don’t mind a steep learning curve.

Many players will eventually want both. Squadron 42 can serve as a tutorial for the universe, introducing you to factions, ships, and combat. Star Citizen, in turn, offers the freedom to apply those skills in a living world. If you are on a budget, note that Squadron 42 is typically cheaper than a game package that includes Star Citizen, but both are sold separately.

Costs and What You Get

Both games require a one-time purchase (no subscription required, though optional subscriptions exist for perks). As of 2025, a standalone Squadron 42 pledge costs around $45, while a Star Citizen game package (which includes the MMO and a starter ship) starts around $45 as well. However, many ships in Star Citizen are sold separately for real money, which can add up. It is important to understand that Star Citizen is not pay-to-win in the traditional sense—you can earn most ships in-game—but the initial pledge determines your starting ship and access to certain features.

Here is what you get with each:

  • Squadron 42: a single-player campaign, offline play, and the full story. No microtransactions.
  • Star Citizen: the persistent online universe, access to all current and future alpha updates, and a starter ship. Optional microtransactions for ships and cosmetics.

If you buy a package that includes both (often called a “combo” or “dual” pack), you save a little compared to buying separately. Check the official website for current pricing, as it has changed over time.

Common Problems and Misconceptions

Misconception: Both games are the same. They share a universe, but Squadron 42 is a linear story, while Star Citizen is an open MMO. They are not interchangeable.

Misconception: Star Citizen is a scam or vaporware. While development has taken over a decade, the game is playable and receives regular updates. It is not a scam, but it is still in alpha, so expect bugs and missing features.

Common problem: Performance issues. Star Citizen is demanding on PCs. It requires a modern CPU, at least 16GB RAM (32GB recommended), and a fast SSD. Even then, frame rates can be inconsistent, especially in busy cities. Squadron 42, when released, will likely be better optimized since it is a single-player experience.

Common problem: Learning curve. Star Citizen has a steep learning curve. You will need to learn how to fly, navigate, and manage your ship’s systems. There is no hand-holding. Squadron 42, being scripted, will likely introduce mechanics gradually.

Comparing the Experiences

To help you decide, here is a side-by-side comparison of key aspects:

  • Story: Squadron 42 has a fixed story with characters and a narrative arc. Star Citizen has no story; you write your own.
  • Multiplayer: Star Citizen is online-only, with PvP and PvE elements. Squadron 42 is single-player only.
  • Replayability: Squadron 42 can be replayed to see different dialogue choices, but the story is the same. Star Citizen is endlessly replayable due to its sandbox nature.
  • Development status: Squadron 42 is not yet released (as of 2025). Star Citizen is in alpha and playable now.
  • Time commitment: Squadron 42 is a finite experience (likely 20-40 hours). Star Citizen is a time sink; you can spend hundreds of hours and still have goals.

If you want a polished, cinematic experience, wait for Squadron 42 (or buy it now and play when it releases). If you want to jump into a universe today, Star Citizen is your only choice.

Alternatives to Consider

If you are unsure about either game, consider alternatives that offer similar experiences:

  • Elite Dangerous is a space sim with a persistent galaxy, similar to Star Citizen but more mature and with less hand-crafted detail.
  • No Man’s Sky offers a more casual, colorful space exploration experience with multiplayer.
  • Wing Commander series (the spiritual predecessor to Squadron 42) offers classic space combat campaigns.
  • Star Wars: Squadrons is a focused, story-driven space combat game with a shorter campaign.

These alternatives are cheaper and fully released, making them safer bets if you are hesitant about the unfinished state of Star Citizen or the delay of Squadron 42.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Squadron 42 included with Star Citizen? No, they are separate purchases. However, some pledge packages include both, often at a discount. Check the official store for “combo” packs.

Can I play Squadron 42 without an internet connection? Yes, Squadron 42 is designed as a single-player offline game. You will not need an internet connection to play it.

Will my ships in Star Citizen transfer to Squadron 42? No, your Star Citizen ships are for the online universe only. Squadron 42 has its own ships and progression tied to the story.

Is Star Citizen pay-to-win? No, you can earn all ships in-game with credits. However, buying ships with real money speeds up progression and supports development. It is not considered pay-to-win because ships are not strictly better—each has strengths and weaknesses.

When will Squadron 42 be released? As of 2025, no official release date has been announced. It has been in development for many years, and CIG has not committed to a date. It is best to assume it will release when it is ready.

Which game has better graphics? Both use the same engine and art style, so graphics are comparable. Star Citizen may have more dynamic lighting and weather, but Squadron 42 will likely be more optimized for performance.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →