keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Star Wars Dilemma: How to Take the Franchise Forward

Card No. 06·80075 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

The Star Wars franchise faces a clear dilemma: after the mixed reception of the sequel trilogy and several spin-off projects, the path forward requires balancing new storytelling with the beloved legacy characters and settings. This article outlines the key strategic options—ranging from new eras and media formats to creative leadership—and explains what each approach offers, along with the risks and rewards.

The Current State of the Franchise

Since Disney acquired Lucasfilm in 2012, Star Wars has expanded far beyond the original trilogy. The sequel trilogy (Episodes VII–IX) grossed billions but divided fans over its narrative choices. Meanwhile, standalone films like Rogue One and Solo had varying success, and the television series The Mandalorian and Ahsoka have found critical and commercial favor. The franchise now spans films, live-action series, animated shows, books, comics, and games, each with its own fanbase and expectations. This fragmentation is both a strength and a challenge: there is more content than ever, but no single unifying vision.

Option 1: Explore New Eras and Timelines

One of the most discussed strategies is moving away from the Skywalker saga entirely. The Old Republic era—set thousands of years before the films—offers a blank canvas with Jedi and Sith in large numbers, ancient conflicts, and no need to tie into existing movie plots. Similarly, the High Republic (set about 200 years before The Phantom Menace) has already been established in books and comics, and could be a rich setting for films or series. The advantage is creative freedom; the risk is that audiences may not feel the same emotional connection to characters they don’t already know. However, The Mandalorian proved that new characters in a familiar era can succeed.

Option 2: Embrace Serialized Storytelling

The success of The Mandalorian and Ahsoka suggests that long-form streaming is a sustainable model. Unlike a two-hour film, a series allows for deeper character development and world-building. Disney+ has already announced several upcoming shows, including Skeleton Crew and The Acolyte, which could test this approach. The key is to maintain high production values and coherent writing across episodes. A risk is oversaturation: releasing too many series simultaneously can dilute the brand. A balanced calendar, with one or two shows per year, might keep demand high.

Option 3: Reinvigorate the Theatrical Experience

Despite the streaming boom, theatrical releases remain the franchise’s biggest revenue driver. The last film, The Rise of Skywalker (2019), earned over $1 billion, proving the box office potential is still there. To move forward, Lucasfilm could focus on event films that are self-contained but connected to a larger narrative. For example, a film set during the Old Republic could be a standalone epic, while a new trilogy could be planned with a clear, pre-planned story arc. The challenge is avoiding the behind-the-scenes turmoil that plagued the sequel trilogy, where directors changed and scripts were rewritten. A clear creative vision from the outset is essential.

Option 4: Diversify Across Media

Star Wars has always been a transmedia franchise, but the modern era offers more opportunities than ever. Video games like Jedi: Fallen Order and Jedi: Survivor have been praised for their storytelling, and animated series like The Clone Wars and Rebels have developed devoted followings. Expanding into new genres—such as horror (like the upcoming The Acolyte, which is described as a mystery-thriller) or comedy—could attract new audiences. The key is to ensure that each medium respects the core themes of the franchise: hope, redemption, and the struggle between good and evil.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

Several missteps have hurt the franchise in the past. Over-reliance on nostalgia (e.g., bringing back Palpatine in The Rise of Skywalker) can feel forced. Ignoring established lore, as seen in some Legends vs. canon debates, alienates hardcore fans. And a lack of planning—like the disjointed sequel trilogy—can lead to inconsistent storytelling. To avoid these, Lucasfilm should:

  • Hire a dedicated story group that ensures continuity across all media.
  • Allow directors and writers to take creative risks, but within a clear framework.
  • Listen to fan feedback without being solely driven by it.
  • Balance new characters with legacy ones, rather than relying on cameos.

What Fans Actually Want

Fan surveys and online discussions reveal a few common desires: more original stories, less fan service, and a return to practical effects. Many fans appreciate the darker, more complex tone of Andor, which focuses on political intrigue and character drama. Others want to see the Jedi Order in its prime, before the fall. There is also a strong appetite for the Old Republic, which has been teased in games and books but never fully explored on screen. Ultimately, fans want to feel that the franchise is moving forward, not just rehashing old hits.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will there be a Star Wars Episode X?

As of now, Lucasfilm has not announced a new main saga film. The focus is on standalone films and series. However, Kathleen Kennedy has mentioned that a new film is in development, but details are scarce. It’s possible that the next theatrical release will be a spin-off or a new era, rather than a continuation of the Skywalker saga.

What is the next Star Wars movie?

The next confirmed theatrical release is Untitled Star Wars film (currently scheduled for 2026), directed by Sharmeen Obaid-Chinoy, with a script by Steven Knight. It is rumored to be set after the events of The Rise of Skywalker and involve Rey rebuilding the Jedi Order. However, release dates have shifted before, so this could change.

Why did the sequel trilogy receive mixed reviews?

Critics and fans point to a lack of cohesive planning, with each film being written and directed by different people without a unified story arc. Some also disliked the treatment of legacy characters and the rushed pacing of the final film. The trilogy still grossed billions, but it failed to capture the same universal acclaim as the original trilogy.

Is the Old Republic canon?

The Old Republic era is currently considered “Legends” (non-canon) by Lucasfilm, but elements have been brought into canon, such as the planet Taris and the character Darth Bane. There have been rumors of an Old Republic film or series, but nothing official has been announced. If it happens, it would likely be a fresh take rather than a direct adaptation of the games.

How can I get into Star Wars if I’ve never seen it?

Start with the original trilogy (Episodes IV–VI) to understand the core story. Then, watch The Mandalorian for a more modern take. If you enjoy animated shows, The Clone Wars is excellent but long. For a darker, more mature story, Andor is a great choice. Avoid starting with the prequels or sequels, as they are more divisive.

What is the best order to watch all Star Wars movies and shows?

There are several recommended orders. For a first-time viewer, release order (Episodes IV–VI, then I–III, then VII–IX) is simplest. For a chronological experience, start with Episode I and go through IX, but insert the animated shows and spin-offs at the appropriate times. Many fans prefer “Machete Order” (IV, V, I, II, III, VI), which preserves the twist in The Empire Strikes Back. Ultimately, it depends on your preference for narrative flow.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →