Modern cars are safer, more efficient, and more connected than ever, but several recent industry trends have introduced real downsides that frustrate owners and even compromise long-term value. This article examines seven such trends—from touchscreen-only controls to oversized wheels—explaining why they make cars worse for many drivers and what you can look for instead.
Background: Why Car Design Changed So Fast
The shift toward these trends wasn’t random. Stricter global fuel-economy and emissions rules pushed automakers to downsize engines, add turbochargers, and use lighter materials. At the same time, consumer demand for the latest tech features created a market for giant screens and driver-assistance systems. Cost pressures also play a role: a single touchscreen replacing dozens of physical buttons saves manufacturing and assembly time, even if it costs more to repair later. These forces converged in the last decade, making the modern car a very different machine from the one many drivers learned on.
Touchscreen-Only Controls: Distraction and Cost
The most widely criticized trend is the removal of physical buttons for climate control, audio, and even wipers, replaced by menus on a central touchscreen. Automakers argue this simplifies the cabin and enables over-the-air updates, but the safety trade-off is significant.
- Distraction: Adjusting a knob or slider takes about one second of eyes-off-road time; navigating a touchscreen menu can take 5–10 seconds. At 60 mph, that’s 440–880 feet of travel while looking at a screen.
- Cost: A failed screen can render HVAC, audio, and vehicle settings unusable. Replacing a modern infotainment display often costs $1,000–$2,500 including parts and labor, versus $50–$200 for a simple switch.
- Durability: Screens have no tactile feedback, and they crack or delaminate over time, especially in hot climates.
Some manufacturers have started reversing course, reintroducing physical knobs for volume and temperature after customer complaints, but many new models still force you into submenus for basic functions.
Oversized Wheels and Low-Profile Tires
Automakers increasingly fit 19-, 20-, or even 22-inch wheels with rubber-band tires (aspect ratios of 35 or 40) to make cars look sportier. The drawbacks are well documented:
- Ride quality: Less sidewall means less cushioning, so potholes and expansion joints are felt directly. Harshness increases, and NVH (noise, vibration, harshness) rises.
- Cost: A single low-profile tire for a 20-inch wheel can cost $200–$400, and they wear faster. Wheel damage from curbs and potholes is more likely and more expensive to repair.
- Fuel economy: Heavier wheels and wider tires increase rolling resistance, reducing MPG by 1–2% compared to smaller wheels.
- Winter performance: Low-profile tires are often summer or all-season compounds with less snow grip; dedicated winter tires in these sizes are pricey and scarce.
The trend is purely aesthetic—no handling benefit is felt by typical drivers, and the trade-offs are felt every day.
Engine Downsizing and Turbocharging
To meet emissions targets, automakers have replaced naturally aspirated engines with smaller turbocharged units. A 1.0-liter three-cylinder turbo can produce power similar to an old 1.6-liter four, but real-world behavior differs:
- Lag: Turbos need time to spool, causing a delay between pressing the throttle and feeling acceleration. This is especially noticeable from a stop or in stop-and-go traffic.
- Long-term reliability: Turbochargers run hot and add complexity. Oil changes must be done on time; using the wrong oil or skipping intervals can lead to turbo failure, a $1,500–$3,000 repair.
- Fuel economy: Under heavy load, a small turbo engine can use more fuel than a larger naturally aspirated engine because it’s working harder.
Mild-hybrid and full-hybrid systems can mitigate these issues, but many budget models still rely on small turbos without electrification, leaving drivers with lag and potential long-term costs.
Subscription Features and Over-the-Air Paywalls
Automakers are increasingly treating features that were once standard or one-time options as ongoing subscriptions. Examples include remote start, heated seats, navigation, and even performance upgrades (like BMW’s remote engine boost or Tesla’s acceleration boost).
This trend makes cars worse in several ways:
- Value: You pay for hardware that’s already installed but locked behind a software paywall. If you stop subscribing, you lose functionality you may have used for years.
- Resale: A used car with lapsed subscriptions may be less attractive to buyers who don’t want to pay monthly fees.
- Privacy: Subscription services often require data collection, raising concerns about who has access to your driving habits.
While some subscriptions are optional, the trend toward gating basic features is a clear step backward for consumer ownership.
Complexity and Repair Costs
Modern cars are packed with sensors, cameras, radar, and electronic control units. This complexity improves safety and convenience, but it also makes repairs more expensive and sometimes impossible for independent shops.
- Diagnostics: A simple check-engine light can require a $150 diagnostic fee just to read codes, and the cause may be a faulty sensor that costs $300–$800 to replace.
- Calibration: After a windshield replacement, many cars require recalibration of the forward-facing camera and radar. This adds $200–$500 to a job that used to be $300.
- Software locks: Some automakers restrict parts to authorized dealers, forcing you to pay dealer labor rates ($150–$250/hour) instead of an independent mechanic.
Owners are keeping cars longer, but the rising cost of repairs is pushing many to trade in earlier, which is exactly what automakers want—but it’s bad for your wallet.
How to Choose a Car That Avoids These Trends
If you want to push back against these trends, here are practical steps when shopping:
- Look for physical controls: Check that climate and audio have dedicated buttons or knobs, not just touchscreen menus.
- Choose smaller wheels: Opt for the base or mid-trim wheels (17–18 inches) rather than the largest available. You’ll get a smoother ride and cheaper tires.
- Prefer naturally aspirated engines or hybrids: A larger non-turbo engine or a hybrid provides smoother power and often better real-world economy.
- Read the fine print on subscriptions: Ask which features are included for the life of the car vs. which require a paid plan.
- Check repair costs: Before buying, look up common repair costs for that model—especially for the infotainment screen and sensors.
- Consider an older model: A 3–5 year old car may have fewer of these trends and still offer modern safety features.
No car is perfect, but being aware of these trade-offs helps you choose one that fits your priorities.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are touchscreen-only controls really that dangerous?
Yes, studies show that using touchscreens while driving increases eyes-off-road time significantly compared to physical buttons. Even simple tasks like adjusting the temperature can take several seconds of attention, raising crash risk. Some countries are considering regulations to require physical controls for essential functions.
Do bigger wheels always mean worse fuel economy?
Not always, but generally yes. Larger wheels are heavier and wider, which increases rolling resistance and aerodynamic drag. The effect is typically 1–2% worse fuel economy compared to the smallest available wheel size on the same car. The difference is more noticeable in city driving.
Can I replace low-profile tires with taller ones?
You can, but you must maintain the overall diameter to avoid speedometer errors and clearance issues. For example, going from 235/40R19 to 235/45R18 is possible if the car’s brakes and suspension allow. Always consult a tire professional to ensure proper fitment.
Are subscription features worth it?
It depends on the feature and your usage. Remote start or navigation might be worth $10–$20/month if you use them daily, but you’re essentially renting a feature that used to be a one-time cost. Consider whether you’d be willing to pay that fee for the life of the car.
Will older cars be cheaper to maintain?
Generally, yes, because they have fewer electronic systems and simpler engines. However, older cars may have worn components and lack modern safety features. A 2015–2018 model often strikes a good balance between reliability, repairability, and features.
Related
Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.
More cards in this drawer
- Photoshop vs Lightroom AI Features Compared
- DNF vs DNF5: Which Package Manager?
- Nostalgic Classic Games Revamped on G2A?
- Nvidia RTX 4000 Super GPUs: Full Specs & Buying Guide
- Korean SUV Making BMW and Audi Owners Question Their Choices?
- Selfie Stick Buying Reasons: 7 Real Benefits