Forge Magma vs Arcane Pickaxe: Which Is Better?

Forge Magma and Arcane Pickaxe are two distinct tool paths in the game Hypixel SkyBlock, and the better choice depends entirely on your playstyle and progression stage. Forge Magma is a combat-oriented pickaxe that excels at mining in the Crimson Isle, while Arcane Pickaxe is a utility tool designed for faster gemstone collection and is often used as a secondary pickaxe for its ability to instantly mine certain blocks. This article breaks down their stats, abilities, and optimal use cases so you can decide which one deserves a slot in your hotbar.

Background: Where Each Pickaxe Comes From

Forge Magma is a pickaxe obtained by upgrading a Gemstone Pickaxe with a Magma Core (dropped by Magma Cubes in the Crimson Isle). It requires Combat Level 22 and Mining Level 20 to use. Its signature ability, Magma Core, grants +10 Mining Speed for every 10 Mining Fortune, but only while on the Crimson Isle. This makes it a powerful tool for farming hard-stone and glowing blocks in that specific area.

Arcane Pickaxe, on the other hand, is crafted from an End Stone Pickaxe and an Arcane Catalyst (obtained from the End). It requires Mining Level 12 and grants Arcane Instability, which gives a 50% chance to instantly mine any block that would normally take longer than 0.5 seconds. It also has a base +50 Mining Speed and +50 Mining Fortune, but its real draw is the ability to break gemstones instantly, making it a favorite for gemstone mining in the Crystal Hollows.

How the Abilities Work in Practice

Forge Magma’s ability is passive and always active while on the Crimson Isle. The bonus speed scales with your Mining Fortune, so a high-fortune build (e.g., with a Divan’s Drill and maxed gemstones) can push its effective speed into the thousands. However, outside the Crimson Isle, it becomes a standard pickaxe with no special perks.

Arcane Pickaxe’s ability is a chance-based instant mine. This does not work on blocks that are already instant (like soft clay) or on ores that require a specific tool tier. It shines on gemstones, which have a base breaking time of 1.2 seconds. With the 50% chance, you effectively halve the average time per gemstone, which translates to a massive boost in blocks mined per hour when combined with high Mining Fortune.

Choosing Between the Two

Ask yourself what you do most in the game:

If you spend most of your time in the Crimson Isle (farming reputation, killing mobs, mining hard-stone for coins), Forge Magma is the clear winner. Its speed bonus is unconditional and scales with fortune.
If you mine gemstones in the Crystal Hollows (for profit or for the Gemstone Gauntlet), Arcane Pickaxe is superior because of the instant-mine chance. It also works on other slow blocks like obsidian, making it a good general utility pickaxe.
If you do a mix of both, consider carrying both. The Forge Magma for Crimson Isle and the Arcane Pickaxe for everything else. Many players use the Arcane Pickaxe as a secondary tool for its instant-mine ability, even after acquiring a Drill.

Common Misconception: Arcane Pickaxe vs. Pickonimbus

A frequent question is whether Arcane Pickaxe is better than the Pickonimbus 2000 (a drill-like pickaxe). The Pickonimbus has a higher base mining speed (1,500) and a +25% mining speed boost, but it does not have an instant-mine ability. For gemstones, the Arcane Pickaxe’s instant-mine chance often results in a higher practical mining speed, especially if you have high Mining Fortune. However, the Pickonimbus is better for hard-stone or other blocks where the instant-mine doesn’t trigger. There is no single “best� – it depends on the block you are mining.

Cost and Upgrade Path

Forge Magma requires a Gemstone Pickaxe (which itself needs 5 of each gemstone and 120 Mithril) plus a Magma Core. The Magma Core is a rare drop (about 0.5% chance) from Magma Cubes, so it can be expensive to buy from the Auction House. Arcane Pickaxe requires an End Stone Pickaxe (crafted with 3 End Stone and 2 sticks) and an Arcane Catalyst. The Catalyst is a rare drop from Endermen, but it is generally cheaper than the Magma Core. Both pickaxes can be re-forged and enchanted, and they can be used as a base for the Divan’s Drill (which is the ultimate mining tool), but that requires a different upgrade path.

Safety and Practical Tips

When using either pickaxe, always ensure you have the correct Enchantments: Efficiency V is essential to reduce base breaking time, and Fortune III or higher is crucial for gemstones. Also, note that the Arcane Pickaxe’s instant-mine ability does not work on blocks that require a higher Breaking Power, so you still need a pickaxe with sufficient Breaking Power for ores like Titanium or Mithril. There is no real-world safety concern, but in-game, it is wise to keep a spare pickaxe in your ender chest in case you die in the Crimson Isle or Crystal Hollows.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Forge Magma work outside the Crimson Isle?

No. The Magma Core ability only activates while you are on the Crimson Isle. Outside that area, Forge Magma is just a basic pickaxe with decent stats, but no special perk.

Can Arcane Pickaxe instantly mine all blocks?

No. It has a 50% chance to instantly mine any block that takes longer than 0.5 seconds to break, but it does not work on blocks that require a higher Breaking Power than the pickaxe has. For example, it cannot instantly mine End Stone or Obsidian unless your Breaking Power is high enough.

Which pickaxe is better for making money?

It depends on the current market. Gemstones (especially Topaz and Jade) tend to be profitable, so the Arcane Pickaxe’s instant-mine ability can increase your gems per hour. However, the Crimson Isle’s hard-stone and glowing blocks also sell well, and Forge Magma’s speed bonus makes that farming faster. Check the Bazaar prices before deciding.

Can I use both pickaxes at the same time?

You can carry both in your hotbar, but you can only use one at a time. Many players hotkey one to slot 1 and the other to slot 2, switching based on the area they are mining in.

Is the Arcane Pickaxe worth it if I already have a Gemstone Gauntlet?

The Gemstone Gauntlet (from the Crystal Hollows) has higher base stats than the Arcane Pickaxe, but it does not have the instant-mine ability. If you are mining gemstones, the Arcane Pickaxe can still be useful as a secondary tool for breaking the initial block of a vein, but the Gauntlet is generally better for sustained mining.

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →