keepcalculator

06 Numbers and Powers

Vietnam vs Taiwan: Electronics & Semiconductor Figures

Card No. 06·27193 · Updated · Standard formula, shown below

Vietnam and Taiwan are both major players in global electronics manufacturing, but the figures show they occupy very different tiers: Taiwan produces over 60% of the world’s semiconductors and more than 90% of the most advanced logic chips, while Vietnam’s strength lies in electronics assembly and packaging, with semiconductor output still a fraction of Taiwan’s. In 2023, Taiwan’s semiconductor manufacturing revenue was roughly $70 billion, compared to Vietnam’s emerging chip industry, which is still in the single-digit billions. This article breaks down the key numbers, explains what they mean, and helps you understand which country suits different manufacturing needs.

Background: How Taiwan and Vietnam Got Here

Taiwan’s semiconductor dominance began in the 1970s when the government founded the Industrial Technology Research Institute (ITRI) and later spun off TSMC in 1987. The island invested heavily in R&D, built a complete supply chain from design to packaging, and now hosts over 200 semiconductor companies. Vietnam’s electronics industry took off later, around the 2000s, when Samsung and other multinationals moved assembly operations there to diversify supply chains. Vietnam has focused on consumer electronics assembly (phones, laptops, wearables) rather than advanced chip fabrication, though it is now building its first semiconductor plants with foreign investment.

Semiconductor Manufacturing: The Core Numbers

When comparing semiconductor manufacturing, the most telling figures are market share and production value. Taiwan accounts for about 68% of global foundry revenue (2023), with TSMC alone generating over $70 billion. Vietnam’s semiconductor manufacturing revenue is estimated at under $1 billion, mostly from testing and packaging facilities. In terms of advanced processes (7nm and below), Taiwan produces nearly all of the world’s supply, while Vietnam has no advanced fabs. Vietnam’s government has set a goal to have its first semiconductor fab by 2030, but it will likely start at mature nodes (28nm or larger).

Electronics Assembly and Exports: Vietnam’s Strength

Vietnam’s electronics sector is dominated by assembly and export of finished goods. In 2023, Vietnam exported over $130 billion in electronics, making it the third-largest electronics exporter globally after China and Hong Kong. Major products include smartphones (Samsung produces about half of its global output there), laptops, and audio equipment. Taiwan, by contrast, exports about $180 billion in electronics, but a large portion is semiconductor components and high-end hardware. Vietnam’s electronics exports have grown at an average of 15% annually over the last decade, while Taiwan’s growth has been slower but steadier.

Supply Chain and Ecosystem: Depth vs. Breadth

Taiwan has a complete semiconductor ecosystem: design (MediaTek, Realtek), fabrication (TSMC, UMC), packaging (ASE), and equipment (ASML’s lithography machines are installed there). Vietnam’s ecosystem is shallow, with most companies involved in assembly, testing, and simple component manufacturing. Vietnam has about 50 semiconductor-related companies, mostly foreign-owned, while Taiwan has over 1,000. Vietnam’s supply chain relies heavily on imported components from China, South Korea, and Taiwan. Taiwan’s supply chain is self-sufficient for most steps except raw silicon wafers and some materials.

Costs and Workforce: What the Figures Show

Labor costs are a major differentiator. Vietnam’s average manufacturing wage is about $300 per month, compared to Taiwan’s $1,500–$2,000. This makes Vietnam attractive for labor-intensive assembly. However, semiconductor fabrication is capital-intensive, not labor-intensive, so labor costs matter less. Taiwan has a highly skilled engineering workforce, with over 100,000 semiconductor engineers; Vietnam has about 5,000–10,000 chip design engineers, though the government aims to train 50,000 by 2030. Taiwan’s engineering talent is a key reason fabs are located there, despite higher wages.

Investment and Government Support: The Numbers Behind Growth

Taiwan’s government has historically provided tax breaks, R&D subsidies, and infrastructure for its semiconductor industry. In 2023, Taiwan’s government announced a $10 billion package to support advanced chip R&D. Vietnam is now offering similar incentives: a 10% corporate tax rate for semiconductor projects (versus the standard 20%), land lease exemptions, and import duty waivers. Vietnam has attracted over $10 billion in semiconductor-related FDI in the last five years, including from Intel (its largest assembly and test facility in the world is in Ho Chi Minh City) and Amkor (a $1.6 billion packaging plant). Taiwan’s investment in semiconductor fabs is over $50 billion annually.

Risks and Geopolitical Factors

Taiwan’s semiconductor dominance carries geopolitical risk due to tensions with China. Many companies are adopting a “China+1” strategy, and Vietnam is a major beneficiary. However, Vietnam lacks the infrastructure (stable power, water, and skilled labor) to host advanced fabs. Taiwan’s risk is offset by its technological lead and the fact that advanced chips are hard to replicate. For electronics assembly, Vietnam offers a more stable political environment than Taiwan, but it faces risks from typhoons and power shortages. The figures show that Taiwan’s semiconductor output is irreplaceable in the short term, while Vietnam’s assembly role is growing but substitutable.

How to Choose Between Vietnam and Taiwan

Your choice depends on what you manufacture:

  • Advanced semiconductors (7nm and below): Taiwan is the only realistic option, as no other country has the technology.
  • Mature-node chips (28nm and above): Taiwan has the capacity, but Vietnam is building fabs for these nodes by 2030.
  • Electronics assembly (phones, laptops, consumer goods): Vietnam offers lower labor costs and growing infrastructure.
  • Semiconductor packaging and testing: Vietnam is competitive, with Intel and Amkor operating large facilities.
  • High-end hardware and components: Taiwan has a mature ecosystem and skilled workforce.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Vietnam a threat to Taiwan’s semiconductor dominance?

Not in the short term. Vietnam lacks the technology, infrastructure, and skilled workforce to produce advanced chips. Its semiconductor industry is focused on packaging and testing, which is a lower-value part of the supply chain. Taiwan’s lead in advanced fabrication is protected by decades of R&D and capital investment.

What is the main difference between Vietnam and Taiwan’s electronics industries?

Taiwan specializes in semiconductor fabrication and design, while Vietnam focuses on assembly and final product manufacturing. Taiwan produces the “brains” (chips), and Vietnam assembles them into devices. This is why Vietnam’s electronics exports are high in value but lower in profit per unit.

Which country has lower manufacturing costs?

Vietnam has significantly lower labor costs, but total manufacturing costs depend on logistics, infrastructure, and import duties. For assembly, Vietnam is cheaper; for chip fabrication, Taiwan is more cost-effective due to economies of scale and government support.

Can Vietnam build a semiconductor fab?

Vietnam is planning to build its first fab by 2030, but it will likely be a mature-node facility (28nm or larger). Building an advanced fab requires massive investment ($20 billion+), a reliable power grid, and thousands of engineers—all of which Vietnam is still developing.

How does the US-China trade war affect these two countries?

Both benefit from supply chain diversification. Vietnam gains more assembly orders as companies move out of China, while Taiwan gains more chip orders as the US seeks to reduce reliance on Chinese manufacturing. However, Taiwan faces pressure to restrict exports to China, which could hurt its sales.

What is the future outlook for both countries?

Taiwan will likely maintain its semiconductor lead for at least a decade, while Vietnam will grow its assembly and packaging sectors. Vietnam aims to triple its semiconductor industry revenue by 2030, but it will remain a supporting player rather than a competitor to Taiwan.

Related

Method: the standard formula for this calculation, rounded as each result states. See how the calculators work or report an error.

More cards in this drawer

The whole Numbers and Powers drawer →