What Can You Cook in a Toaster Oven?

You can cook almost anything in a toaster oven that you would cook in a full-size oven—roasts, casseroles, baked goods, and even entire meals—just in smaller batches. It toasts, bakes, broils, and often air-fries, making it a versatile countertop appliance for one to four people. The key differences are smaller capacity, faster preheating, and closer heat elements, so cooking times and temperatures often need slight adjustments.

Formula

The calculator above gives a rough time adjustment for converting a standard oven recipe to a toaster oven. The main formula is:

Suggested toaster oven time = standard oven time × 0.75

Where:

• Standard oven time (tstd) – the recipe’s original baking time in minutes.
• Oven time (t) – the actual time you plan to use, just for comparison.
• Time ratio – your planned time divided by the standard time; 1.0 means same, less than 1 means shorter.

This 75% rule is a common starting point because toaster ovens heat up faster and have less air volume, so food often cooks quicker. It is not a precise conversion—always check for doneness with a thermometer or visual cues.

Worked Example

You have a casserole recipe that says bake at 350°F for 60 minutes in a standard oven. You want to cook it in your toaster oven.

1. Take the standard time: 60 minutes.
2. Multiply by 0.75: 60 × 0.75 = 45 minutes.
3. Set your toaster oven to the same temperature (350°F) and check at 45 minutes.

The calculator’s suggested time is 45 minutes. In practice, start checking at 40 minutes because toaster ovens can have hot spots. Use an instant-read thermometer for meat and poultry.

What a Toaster Oven Does Well

Toaster ovens excel at small-batch cooking and reheating. They preheat in 3–5 minutes, use less energy than a full oven, and don’t heat up your kitchen as much. Here are foods that come out noticeably better than in a microwave:

• Toast and bagels – even browning, crispy edges.
• Pizza slices – crisp crust, melted cheese, no sogginess.
• Roasted vegetables – caramelization and browning at high heat.
• Chicken wings or drumsticks – crispy skin without deep frying.
• Cookies and small cakes – even baking for small batches.
• Melting cheese – open-faced sandwiches, nachos, gratins.
• Reheating fried foods – restores crunch better than a microwave.

Many models also have a broil setting, which is perfect for browning the top of casseroles or finishing a steak.

What You Can Bake

You can bake almost anything that fits on the pan. Standard 9-inch cake pans usually don’t fit, but 8-inch or smaller do. Muffin tins (6-cup), small loaf pans, and pie plates (9-inch or smaller) are common. Cookies, brownies, and biscuits work well. For yeast breads, a toaster oven can produce a good loaf, but you may need to rotate the pan halfway because heat distribution is less even than a full oven.

Baking tips:

• Use a light-colored pan to prevent over-browning on the bottom.
• Place the rack in the middle position for most baking.
• Rotate the pan 180° halfway through the baking time.
• Check doneness 5–10 minutes early if you used the 75% time rule.

Roasting and Broiling

Roasting a whole chicken is possible if it fits under the heating elements (usually a 3–4 lb bird). Smaller items like chicken thighs, fish fillets, and vegetables are ideal. The high heat and close proximity to the elements give a nice sear and crisp skin.

Broiling works best for thin cuts (fish, chicken breast pounded flat) or for melting/browning. Keep the door slightly ajar on some models to prevent overheating—check your manual. Always use a broiler-safe pan, not glass, to avoid shattering.

Air-Frying and Dehydrating

Many newer toaster ovens include a convection fan, which circulates hot air. This is what makes air-frying possible. You can make crispy french fries, chicken nuggets, and even vegetable chips with a light oil spray. The fan also helps bake more evenly.

Some models have a dehydrate setting at low temperatures (140–170°F). You can dry apple slices, herbs, or jerky, but it takes several hours. Check your manual for the temperature range and recommended times.

Choosing a Toaster Oven

When selecting a toaster oven, consider these factors:

• Size – measure your counter space and check the interior capacity (usually 0.5–1.5 cubic feet).
• Wattage – higher wattage (1500W+) heats faster and maintains temperature better.
• Settings – look for bake, broil, toast, and convection/air-fry if you want those.
• Temperature range – most go up to 450°F; some go to 500°F for pizza.
• Accessories – included pan, rack, and air-fry basket.
• Ease of cleaning – removable crumb tray and nonstick interior help.

There is no “best� brand for everyone; choose based on your cooking style and space.

Common Problems and How to Avoid Them

Toaster ovens have a few quirks:

• Uneven browning – rotate pans and use the middle rack.
• Burning edges – lower the temperature by 25°F if edges brown too fast.
• Smoke – grease drips can cause smoke; place a baking sheet under the food.
• Hot spots – the back often gets hotter; position food accordingly.
• Glass door shattering – avoid sudden temperature changes; don’t put cold glass on a hot surface.

If your food is consistently undercooked inside, check if the convection fan is on—it speeds cooking. If it’s overcooked on the outside, lower the temperature, not the time.

Safety and Energy Use

Toaster ovens are generally safe if used correctly. Keep them away from curtains and paper towels. Don’t cover the vents. Always unplug when cleaning. Because they draw high wattage (up to 1800W), avoid plugging them into an extension cord with other high-power appliances.

Energy-wise, a toaster oven uses about half the energy of a full-size oven for the same cooking task, because it heats a smaller space. For small meals, this can save electricity over time.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I cook a frozen pizza in a toaster oven?
Yes, but check the pizza’s instructions. Usually, you bake at the recommended temperature for about 75% of the time, then check. Place the pizza directly on the rack for a crispier crust, or on a pan if you prefer softer.

Can I use metal pans and foil in a toaster oven?
Yes, metal pans and aluminum foil are generally safe, but keep foil away from the heating elements to prevent arcing. Do not use plastic or paper with a non-stick coating.

How do I clean a toaster oven?
Unplug it and let it cool. Remove the crumb tray and wash with soapy water. Wipe the interior with a damp cloth and mild cleaner. Do not submerge the appliance in water.

Can I bake bread in a toaster oven?
Yes, small loaves and rolls work well. Use a loaf pan that fits, and rotate halfway. The crust may be softer than a full oven, but it’s still good.

Why is my toaster oven smoking?
Usually food drippings or grease. Place a baking sheet on the lower rack to catch drips, and clean the crumb tray regularly. If smoking persists, check for food stuck to the heating elements.

Can I reheat leftovers in a toaster oven?
Yes, and it often tastes better than a microwave. Use a low temperature (300°F) and cover with foil if the food is drying out.

Related

• AI Evaluation Benchmarks: Which to Use
• AI Adoption Speed & Agentic AI Talent Needs
• IPS Monitors and Eye Comfort: What Panels Can and Can’t Do

in t | Oven time (min) | min | 30 | 0
in tstd | Standard oven time (min) | min | 60 | 0
out ratio | Time ratio | - | t / tstd | 2
out adjust | Suggested toaster oven time | min | tstd * 0.75 | 0